-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
1/24
>==1#=7#=# P^EB
]H^WB]OIH
]RNJE@OBP]B^EGE@OP
WOQO ]OIO]H^WRIOJ
@@B WO\BE^HGB==22>=== Leirbe~ ghp \ecahpWbjbl#6 >0< 220
= Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp
Wjl#6 5?7 9
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
2/24
>==1#=7#= ]IECO GHEP]IECO GHEP]IECO GHEP]IECO GHEP]IECO
GHEP
^b`b}h `ojh~hpo
^ VBPDO^EO BJ\E^O ]E^BP$WBEQBE^O
GB\BPO|ojgbdo~ oj|bp
W~ogeh ]bg~hirbcpbG`ogop o}p g`ogop* ]bg~ih
I~ocgb docwd o pro w~ogeh cop@b~edceop go ]oe h gb @~epwh*
gbpgbh Ghdecih gb ]opphp }oppocgh }bjhgb odhp ow oh geo gb ]p`ho*
o`hc$wb`edbcwhp go ~bp}hcponejegogb qrb~ go Ln~e`o go Ei~bfo qrb~
go Pocwo@opo go Depb~e`~geo#
Bpwop grop bcwegogbp ~bjeiehpop wdponegh ahc~o~ o w~ogeh
ogo}wocgh$pb ohp ch|hp wbd}hp* b p opped pb`hd}~bbcgb hp dejao~bp
gb }bpphop
qrb hd}o~b`b~od* drewh bd bp}b`eojco Pb wo$Lbe~o Pocwo b oecgo o
pr}b~eh~ }~bpbco gh Nep}h gb @hedn~o* Pbc$ah~ G# Ojnech @jbwh ch
Ghdecih gb]opphp#
Ojirdop |hvbp wb~h gewh qrb o w~o$geh f ch h qrb b~o#
Bcwbcgh }b~lbewodbcwb h }bcpo$dbcwh gbppop }bpphop*
~b`h~gocghqrb o _recwo b Pb wo$Lbe~o Pocwo* wec$aod o }~bpbco
pedrjwcbo gb hewh hrch|b po`b~ghwbp* |ecghp gop l~birb$
peop |evecaop b hd bjbp hp pbrp }o~h$qreochp* }b~chewocgh o
doeh~eo coEi~bfo bd }b~docbcwb \eijeo* opph`e$ocgh$pb o bpwbp h
}h|h gb ]bg~ih#
Hp }bg~hirbcpbp hcwecrod o ahc$~o~ bpwo w~ogeh* `hd rdo lh~wb
}~b$pbco* |ecghp gb whgh h }op b gh bp$w~ocibe~h# }~h||bj qrb bpwo
wbcaopegh o ]p`ho qrb doep }b~bi~echpow~oer gbpgb h ec`eh gh p`rjh#
Hp fh$|bcp }bg~hirbcpbp lh~od hp o`wh~bplrcgodbcwoep cbpwbp
o`hcwb`edbcwhp*
pbd}~b }~bpbcwbp* qrb~ chp Bp`rwbe$~hp* qrb~ co Nocgo
Lejo~dce`o* qrb~ ch @h~h go Ei~bfo# Crd dbpdh geo*bpwbp fh|bcp
`hcpbire~od pb~|e~ coNocgo b ch @h~h# @h~~eod hd ojbi~eogb rdo
o`we|egogb }o~o hrw~o#
P `hd }bpphop `hdh bpwop qrbpb `hcpbirb docwb~ rdo
w~ogeh`bcwbc~eo b |ojh~evo~ h }ow~edceh`rjwr~oj b ~bjeiehph gb rdo
hdrcego$gb drewh ocweio hdh o gb ]bg~ihI~ocgb#
P db o}bwb`b ah~o~ lh~odop }ojo|~op bdh`ehcogop go chp$po
}~edbe~o$godo* Do~eo @o|o$`h Pej|o#
Bpwo~eo o lojo~ hcpeih }~}~eo*do~`ocgh }opph hd o pro db$d~eo gb
wbd}hp lbjevbp |e|eghpbd Jhr~bch Do~qrbp !ahfb*Do}rwh%# b|bjo|o rd
ph~~ephwh pec`b~h qrb gb|b wb~ gbp}b~$wogh h h~oh ghp dhodne`o$chp#
O lhwhi~oleo o}whr bppo b $ }~bpph lbjev b porghpo* lojh co$qrbjo
porgogb `hcab`ego }h~ qrbd j |e|br* qrbd j cop`brhr qrbd }opphr
drewhp ghp ochpgo pro dh`egogb* crd wbd}h gbhr~h* |e|egh pbd
}~b`hc`bewhp ~o$`eoep* ph`eoep hr ~bjeiehphp# Oio~$~ocgh op grop
nocgbe~op* hp pbrphjahp }o~b`bd gevb~6 gbe bd$db~b`h~go~ h odh~ qrb
wodnd
^B@HD]BCPO@b~whp dhcibp* ed}bgeghp gb wb~ lejahp* hnwd oecgo
ahfb `hd o }joc
~|h~b; rdo geico ~b`hd}bcpo b o i~oo gb Gbrp#@b~whp dhcibp* hdh
qrb ed}bjeghp }bjo d edo ~b`hd}bcpo b }h~ whgo o
Gbrp* lh~od `~eocgh gop doep nbjop ljh~bpwop gb pbd}~b b qrb
pbd}~geicele`o~* onbcho~ b }~hwbib~# Gbpwo`ocgh oecgo whghp hp doep
~b bd}jo~bp gb ~|h~bp#
B i~oop o drewhp dhcibp }h~ bppb drcgh lh~o b }bjhp wbd}hp eghp*
acp* pbrp lejahp b ab~gbe~hp ge~b`whp* qrb rprl~rdhp co i~oo gh
Pbppo bch~db ~b`hd}bcpo#
H Nrppo`h rd b bd}jh jh`oj#B oIecikh nejhno ! `hcab`ego `hdh h
ce`h lppej |e|h bcw~b op ~|h~bp% rd
b bd}jh drcgeoj#
WBDHP###Wbdhp qrb geicele`o~ h drcgh ~r~oj# B pb ch lh~ hd
hn~op* qrb h pbfo o }h~ }ojo|~op# qrb gb}hep gb wocwh ~o}o* we~o*
}b b gbe o; h dbjah~ dbpdh pb~ o
ch gel`ej lovb~ dbjah~# B pb dbjah~o~dhp* bpwodhp o hcw~enre~
}o~o hbqrejn~eh b }o~o rd ble`ov ordbcwh go bp}b~oco gh chpph
|e|b~# O}oc`odecah b~wh# H odecah qrb wb~bdhp qrb ponb~ w~ejao~ o
}o~we~ gop hqrb oecgo |odhp wbcgh#
B h qrb doep chp `rpwo* gevb~bd$chp qrb ped* qrb lovbd* qrb
owbcgbcogo/ Ch chp jeiod ### cbcard# Pb we|b~ qrb pb~* qrb pbfo;
dop oh dbchplood gb wochp epph* qrb ch/ _rb cp pbd}~b wbdhp h chpph
pwowrp ~r~oj chdbogodbcwb }bjo }~bpbco lpe`o gb ` |e|b~dhp; gb `
`hcw~enre~dhp`hcwo~dhp#
qrb whghp* ch dcedh* wbdhp ge~bewh p chppop }ojo|~op gb
h}eceec`jrgo* jo~h/
H]H^WRCEGOGBP BWB^COPO Cowr~bvo nolbfo$chp gb rdo docbe~o/B
whghp hp ochp* g$chp pbd}~b ch|op h}h~wrcegogbp gb jbdn~oco* g
gb gbp`hnb~wo b gb gbpjrdn~b#Opped* whghp cp; doep bpqrb`eghp*
doep gepw~oghp* doep h`r}oghp*
b doep ecpbcp|bep wbdhp pbd}~b rdo ~b}bweh ocroj gh qrb o
Cowr~bd edh bp}jbcgh~* gb ogo bpwoh* chp wbd }o~o hlb~b`b~ b
w~ocpdewe
]h~wocwh* h qrb f }opphr bpwb och* |hjwo~ ch }~ edh och*
ecgrnewowhghp hp geop* ao|b~ pbd}~b drewh doep }o~o `hjab~ b
pbcwe~# Epwh* bpw~oirbdhp e~~b|b~pe|bjdbcwb b hrw~op wocwop* gb
`hcwbgh* olb~egel`ej ~b`r}b~oh#
Dop* o Cowr~bvo* bpw pbd}~b `o}ov gb chp }b~gho~ b gb chp go~
wh}h~wrcegogbp gbpwb drcgh* }o~o chp ~bgede~dhp nopwo
qrb~b~dhp/
@HD]HPEBPB ONPW^O@BP
wbcah o bpwo wb~~o* o bpwo ibcwb*o bpwop h~bp* o bpwbp abe~hpo
bpwb jedo#
Do~eo gb|b wb~ ~b`h~gogh oqrb$jb phj jecgh o cop`b~ bd
or~h~op`o~~biogop gb }~hdbppop# Rd~bch|ogh gbp}b~wo~ }o~o o
|ego
b }bjh ihpwh gb |e|b~#Oqrbjb ph~~eph ch bcioco6 Do$
~eo @o|o`h Pej|o lhe drewh lbjevcoqrbjo wb~~o b cp* qrb o
bcwbcgb$dhp* ponbdhp b o`wodbcwb }h~$qrb ph~~edhp qrocgh h chpph
}op$pogh bd l~e`o chp gbcrc`eo#
@HJABEWO GB POCIRB
BD ]BG^IH I^OCGB Ch }~ edh geo >< gb On~ej* Pnogh* h
@bcw~h biehcoj gb Pocirb gb @hedn~o* ~bojevo rdo@hjabewo gb Pocirb
cop ecpwojobp ghp Nhdnbe~hp \hjrcw~ehp gb ]bg~ih I~ocgb* gop 5ah~op
p ?0#== ah~op#
O bgeh 0?==1#=7#=< 0^BIEH^BIEH^BIEH^BIEH^BIEH
WHGHPhp OCE\B^PO^EOCWqrb pb lood
o`hd}ocao~ gh @o~w@jebcwb b NE* wd
GBP@HCWH pr~}~b\BCAO @HCAB@B^
H PBR/
RD ]HCWH GB ]O^WEGO B CHPECGE@OWH GHP WQWBEP BCW^BIHR
GE]JHDO
H Pecge`owh ghp W~onojaogh$~bp W wbep* Jocel`ehp b \bpwr$~eh gh
@bcw~h* }~hdh|br ch }op pogh geo 0= gb Do~ h obcw~bio ghp Ge}jhdop
gh @r~$ph gb Bgr`oh b Lh~doh gbOgrjwhp gb @rpwr~o# O `b~ed$ceo
`hcwhr* oecgo* `hd rdob }hpeh ghp w~onojahp ~boje$voghp oh jhcih gh
`r~ph b rdgbplejb gop lh~docgop `hd }b op `hc lb``e hco gop }bj op
}~}~ eop#
Bpwb `r~ph qrb `hclb~b rdoqrojele`oh }~hleppehcoj b h 5och gb
bp`hjo~egogb wb|b `hdhhnfb`we|h ghwo~ op lh~docgopgb hd}bwc`eop
bp`hjo~bp b hd$ }bwc`eop co ~bo go `hpwr~o#
Bpwe|b~od }~bpbcwbp* ojdgb lh~docgop b lh~dogh~op* o }~bpegbcwb
gh ~blb~egh Pecge`o$wh* Lwedo @o~|ojah* h ]~bpe$gbcwb go @do~o
Drce`e}oj gb@opwocabe~o gb ]b~o* ]~hl# Lb~$cocgh Jh}bp* Kojegp
No~~bwh*`hcab`egh pecge`ojepwo* bcw~bhrw~hp#
Ocwbp ghp gbplejb* Lwedo@o~|ojah rphr go }ojo|~o }o~ooi~ogb`b~ p
Orwo~qreop gb Le$irbe~ ghp \ecahp b @opwoc$abe~o gb ]b~o* qrb
o}heo~od bp$
wo ece`eowe|o* b ~bole~do~ o leco$jegogb gbpwb `r~ph ch o}heh
ord i~r}h gb drjab~bp gbpbd$ }~b iogop }~h `r~ ocg h ofrg$jop o
ecpb~e~$pb co |ego o`we|o*gocgh opped doep pbcwegh pprop |egop# Rd
}hcwh gb }o~wego b ch gb `abi ogo $bclowevhr#
O}p h gbplejb* rpo~od go }o jo |~ o Kojeg p No~~ bw h b
Lb~cocgh Jh}bp#H }~edbe~h* ~bojhr o `hcfr$
ioh gb bplh~hp bcw~b h Pec$ge`owh b Orwo~qreop b o ed}h~$wc`eo
go lh~doh* wb~decoc$gh `hd }ojo|~op gb ec`bcwe|hp lh~docgop#
Wodnd Lb~cocgh Jh}bpgbe hr }ojo|~op gb ec`bcwe|h*ole~docgh qrb
bpwodhp oqre }o~o ioc ao~ wbd}h* qrb h
w~onojah doep doicle`h bpwgbcw~h gb |h`p b qrb cogo `o}ov gb
|bc`b~ o chppo }~$ }~eo |hcwogb b `hcpegb~hr ep$wh o }~h|o
ecbqr|h`o gb qrb|h`p }hgbd e~ doep ojd#
H Orwo~`o |ojh~evhr* gb}hep*o lh~doh* ole~docgh qrbqrocwh doeh~
bjo lh~* doepaonejewoghp bpwodhp o |bc`b~b* bd chdb go Orwo~qreo*
gbe$
hr o pro ecwbe~o gep}hceneje$gogb $ ow oh jedewb $ }o~o hdbjop
`hjonh~o~ b ofrgo~#
Bd chdb gop lh~docgop*rphr go }ojo|~o @~epweco Lb~$cocgbp lbv hp
oi~ogb`edbcwhpp lh~dogh~op b p bcwegogbpqrb wh~co~od }hpp|bj
bpwb@r~ph* gbpgb h Pecge`owh* pOrwo~qreop gb @opwocabe~o gb]b~o $
`bgc`eo gb bp}oh* b
Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp $ `bggb orwh`o~~h* wb~decocg|egocgh whghp hp
}~bpb }o~o }o~we`e}o~bd crd jo }h~ bjop }~b}o~ogh* h}hgogb }o~o
lh~docgop* lhgh~bp b `hc|egoghp `hc|e~bd* `hdbcwo~bd o b }hpb
gbplejb b }o~wejao~bd dhwhp |e|eghp gr~ocwb h `r
@
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
4/24
>==1#=7#===1#=7#=2 gb On~ej pbdbjaoco ghp ochp ocwb~eh~bp*
oOrwo~qreo `opwocabe~bcpb }~b}o~hr rd }~hi~odo ojrpe|h oh >2 gb
On~ej gb ?597* gblh~do o `hdbdh~o~ bpwo gowo#
Gh }~hi~odo gbpwb och gbpwo`odhp oecorir~oh co @opo gh Wbd}h goB
}hpeh H qrb h Wbow~h8* }~hdh|ego }bjo Nenjehwb`o Drce`e}oj qrb wb~
jrio~ }b jop ?? ah~ op* pbire go go w~oge `eh cojPbpph Phjbcb chp
]ohp gh @hc`bjah* }bjop ?> ah~op# p ?9 ah~op* wb~ jrio~
rdopo~gecaogo }h}rjo~#
On~ej }h~ b `bjc`eo h dp go ~bch|oh*go }~edo|b~o* gh phj b go
Jenb~gogb#
On~ej wodnd }o~o hp }h~wrirbpbp*peccedh gb Gbdh`~o`eo#
]h~qrb }~b`eph jbdn~o~ h egboj go^b|hjrh ghp @~o|hp qrb w~hr b
jenb~gogbb gbdh`~o`eo b o bp}b~oco gb rdoph`ebgogb doep frpwo b
doep l~owb~co* hDrce`}eh }~b}o~o$pb }o~o `hdbdh~o~ h 07Oce|b~p~eh
gh >2 gb On~ej $ ~blb~b lhcwbgo Orwo~qreo `opwocabe~bcpb#
]ecwr~o Gb`h~o
gb Do~eo Lb~co
@OPO GH WBD]H
H`opwocabe~bcpb]orjh go Pej|o@h~~beo* lhe~b`bcwbdbcwbgepweciregh
}bjhP}h~w Jepnho bNbcle`o `hd hBdnjbdo gbHr~h gbGbge`oh*}bjhp
pbrp`ecqrbcwo ochpgb lejeohcoqrbjb `jrnb*`hd}jbwoghp ch}oppogh geo
2gb Frcah gb
>==9#]orjh go Pej|o @h~~beo ~b`bnbr o ~b$
lb~ego gepwech ch }oppogh geo >0 gbDo~h* ch ]o|ejah Oh~boco
gh Bp$wgeh go Jrv* o `hc|ewb gh ]~bpegbcwbgh @jrnb* Jrep Leje}b
\ebe~o $ qrb `h$jh`hr h bdnjbdo co jo}bjo gh `opo`hgb ]orjh @h~~beo
$* bd `b~edceo qrboje wb|b jrio~ ecwbi~ogo cop `hdbdh$~obp gh
`bcwpedh qro~wh oce|b~p$~eh gh P}h~w Jepnho b Nbcle`o#
]orjh go Pej|o @h~~beo ece`ehr o pro o`$we|egogb }~hleppehcoj ch
qrog~h ghp pb~$
Gb >5 gb Do~ho ?2 gb On~ej* o@opo gh Wbd}hpb~}oj`h gbrdo b
}hpehgb ]ecwr~oGb`h~owe|o !bdwbjo* }h~`bjoco*|eg~h b
hrw~hpdowb~eoep%}~hwoihcevogo}h~ Do~eoLb~cocgo]bppho* o~wepwo`hd
lh~wbp~ovbp bd@opwocabe~o gb]b~o* gogh h pbrdo~egh pb~cowr~oj gb
]b~o*hcgb }oppodi~ocgb }o~wb ghwbd}h#
Oih~o qrb hp |bcwhp l~ehp gh Ec|b~ch f pb lh~od b op ljh~bp bpwh
o `hdbo~ o ljh~bp`b~* o @opo gh Wbd}h }~b}o~o$pb f }o~o on~e~ op
prop }h~wop o rdob }hpeh co qroj Do~eo Lb~cocgo]bppho chp `hcwo rd
}hr`h go prow~ofb`w~eo gbcw~h gh rce|b~ph ghp }ec$`ep b chp dhpw~o
rd }h~whljeh drewhge|b~pele`ogh b `hjh~egh qrb* `b~wo$dbcwb* go~
wodnd rd whd bp}b`eojo bpwbp }~edbe~hp geop gb }~edo|b~o#
Cowr~oj gb Jepnho dop docwbcghrdo lh~wb jeioh hd h hc`bjah
gb
@opwocabe~o gb ]b~o* Do~eo Lb~cocgowbd co }ecwr~o rdo gop prop
doeh~bp }oebp b* ogo dhdbcwh o}~h|bewogh }o~o gbpbc|hj|b~ h pbr
`~bp`edbcwho~wpwe`h ow~o|p go }~we`o gbpoleocwbgb gelb~bcwbp
w`ce`op# Pbirecgh h qrb oedoiecoh docgo b h wojbcwh }b~dewb*Do~eo
Lb~cocgo ch pb ocpo gb we~o~ }o~wegh gh }hgb~ go }ecwr~o b h pbr
bp$wejh o`ono }h~ l~re~ gh phdow~eh hr dbp$`jo gb wrgh oqrejh qrb
wbd oppedejoghoh jhcih go pro o}~bcgevoibd# ]o~obpwo o~wepwo* op
}hppenejegogbp gb }~h$dh|b~ rd |b~gogbe~h bc`hcw~h hdh nbjh ph
|opwppedop b* oh b b~`b~ opro o~wb phn o wb wr~o go wbjo* go
}h~`bjo$co* go b~de`o* gh |eg~h hr gh wb`egh*Do~eo Lb~cocgo }~h`r~o
hnwb~ rd hc$ frcwh gb hn~op qrb ~boj`bd h bc`ocwhgop cowr~bvop
dh~wop b gop }oepoibcp b
lo`ejdbcwb pb bcqrog~bd ch odnebcwb`hcwbd}h~cbh* `hclb~ecgh$jab
rdwhqrb gb |e|o`egogb b bjbic`eo#
]~e|ejbieocgh rdo }ecwr~o doep ~bojep$wo b lrc`ehcoj qrb pb
ogo}wo wocwh oh n~oc h go wbjo hdh w~ocp}o~c`eo gbrdo fo~~o hr
gbje`ogbvo gb rdo whojao*Do~eo Lb~cocgo ~bpb~|o$chp rdo b }h$peh
qrb hcwd rd }hr`h gb wrgh bchp ecp}e~o o |epewo~ o @opo gh Wbd}h
gb>5 gb Do~h o ?2 gb On~ej* chdbogodbc$wb gb Wb~o o Pb wo gop
?=a== p ?5a==hr ohp Lecp$gb$Pbdoco b Lb~eoghp gop?=a== p ?0a== b
?7a== p ?1a==#
Do~eo Lb~cocgo ]bppho b o]ecwr~o
O |e|b~ bd Jepnho* egogb qrb o |ercop`b~ bd ?52=* Do~eo Lb~cocgo
]bp$
Orwo~qreo jocoIreo gh Drc`e}bO Orwo~qreo gb @opwocabe~o gb
]b~o
jochr ~b`bcwbdbcwb h Ireo gh Drc`e}b*rd ecpw~rdbcwh gb
dhgb~cevoh ogdecep$w~owe|o* qrb }hwbc`eo o o}~h edoh bcw~b
oorwo~qreo b h drc`e}b#
Pb~|e~ nbd b `ogo |bv dbjah~ whghp hp@opwocabe~bcpbp h chpph
}~h}pewh $ ~b$lb~b lhcwb goqrbjo Orwo~qreo#
Ow~o|p gbpwb Ireo* h drc`e}b }hgb`hcprjwo~ h lrc`ehcodbcwh ghp
gelb~bcwbp~ihp orw~qre`hp* o h~iocevoh ghp pb~$|ehp drce`e}oep#
Wbd* eirojdbcwb* o }hppe$ nejegogb gb |eprojevo~ hp ge|b~php
opprcwhpqrb }hgbd pb~ w~owoghp ch pb~|eh gbOwbcgedbcwh Ib~oj* nbd
`hdh hp gh`rdbc$whp cb`bpp~ehp o o}~bpbcwo~#
H Ireo bpw gep}hc|bj }o~o ghycjhogbd Gh`rdbcwhp Hc$Jecb ch peweh
go @do~oDrce`e}oj gb @opwocabe~o gb ]b~o#
pho ]~hbco Dbcgbp ghp Pocwhchp qrb hc`jrer h ocweih 9 ochJe`br
Do~eo Odjeo \ov gb @o~|ob qrb* }hpwb~eh~dbcwb* i~ocgo pro |ego lhe
ge~b``ehcogo }~bo lecoc`be~o#
Whgo|eo* Do~eo Lb~cocgobp`hcgbr h ihpwh }bjop o~wbp jbjodbcwb
lrch gb noc`~eo gbpbd}bcahr gr~ocwb 00 ochp }p$pb oecgo o
}~hppbire~ rd ocweih#
Opped pbcgh* bd ?55
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
5/24
>==1#=7#=< 2^BIEH $ @OPW^BIEH $ @OPW^BIEH $ @OPW^BIEH $
@OPW^BIEH $ @OPWOCABE^O GB ]B^OOCABE^O GB ]B^OOCABE^O GB
]B^OOCABE^O GB ]B^OOCABE^O GB ]B^O
O @o~wo Bgr`owe|o gh @hc`bjah gb@opwocabe~o gb ]b~o
hnwb|b}o~b`b~ lo|h~|bj go Ge~b`h^biehcoj gb Bgr`oh gh @bcw~h!G^B@%
b gh Ionecbwb gbBpwowpwe`o b ]jocbodbcwh goBgr`oh !IB]B% }bjh qrb
hnwb|bAhdhjhioh* bd ?2 gb Focbe~h gb>==1* go Decepw~o go
Bgr`oh*Do~eo gb Jr~gbp ^hg~eirbp* o}p]o~b`b~ `hcfrcwh go
Ge~b`h^biehcoj gh @bcw~h b gh Ionecbwbgb Bpwowpwe`o b ]jocbodbcwh
goBgr`oh qrb pojebcwo h ~bp}bewh}bjo dbwhghjhieo }~h}hpwobpwocgh bd
`hclh~degogb `hd oph~ebcwobp go }hjwe`o bgr`owe|o#
Oecgo pbircgh h dbpdh ]o~b`b~* o}~h}hpwo gb ecwb~|bch ch
}o~qrbbp`hjo~ ec`egb co bgr`oh }~$bp`hjo~ bch ? `e`jh gh bcpech
npe`h b gbpweco$pbo `hc`bcw~o~ rd ce`h bpwonbjb`edbcwhgb bcpech gb
we}hjhieo BN?(F? whgo o }h}r joh gbpwbp c|b ep gb bgr `oh(bcpech*
wb~decocgh `hd rd bjhieh ohDrce`}eh @opwocabe~bcpb* `hcpegb~oc$gh
qrb h gh`rdbcwh bjonh~ogh `hd hbplh~h ghp ge|b~php }o~`be~hp
gh@hc`bjah Drce`e}oj gb Bgr`oh ~b|bjo
H Ecowbj bpw o cbih`eo~ `hd o @do~o gb @opwoc$
abe~o gb ]b~o* ch gepw~ewh gbJbe~eo* o hcpw~rh ch hc$`bjah gb rd
@bcw~h gb L~eopqrb gb|b~ wb~ 2= qro~whp#
Pbircgh O @hdo~`o`hcpbirer o}r~o~* o Ge~b`$h gh Ecowbj*
}~bpegego }h~ Fhp Ojo~`h W~hce* ~bcb$pbPnogh* ?> gb On~ej* bd
@op$wocabe~o gb ]b~o* hd h }~bpe$gbcwb go orwo~qreo* Lb~coc$gh
Jh}bp !co lhwh%#
H bc`hcw~h gbpweco$pb oocojepo~ op |~eop ae}wbpbpgb jh`ojevoh gh
bd}~bbcge$dbcwh* qrb* pb lh~ o|ocwb*gb|b~ }oppo~ bd }~ec`}eh }bjo
`hcpw~rh gb ecpwojo$
bp gb ~oev# H }~h`bpph }o~o`~eo~ rdo ch|o rcegogb gbo}heh oh
wr~epdh ecwb~ch bohp w~onojaogh~bp bc`hcw~o$pb crdo lopb gb bpwrgh
gb|eonejegogb b gb|b~ `rjde$co~ hd o o}~bpbcwoh }bjoorwo~qreo gb
rdo ocgegowr$~o ohp lrcghp `hdrcew~ehp }o~o h pb`wh~#
@BCW^H GB L^EOP BD @OPWOCABE^OECOWBJ CBIH@BEO @HD
ORWO^_REONBNEOCH ^HPECAO
onocghco @hdocgh ghpNhdnbe~hp gb
@opwocabe~o gb ]b~oH @hdocgocwb Nbneoch Ocwrcbp^hpecao }bger
~b`bcwbdbcwb o pro
}op poi bd oh _rog~h gb Ahc~o ghpNhdnbe~hp \hjrcw~ehp gb
@opwocabe~ogb ]b~o hcgb @hdocgocwb gh @h~}hO`we|h a >> ochp
`~eocgh* opped* rdbch~db |oveh coqrbjo @h~}h~oh#
@hd 25 ochp* Nbneoch ^hpecao rdghp doep `o~epdwe`hp `hdocgocwbp
ghgepw~ewh gb Jbe~eo b ow co`ehcoj* pbcghgbpgb Focbe~h gb
>==> @hcpbjabe~h Co`ehcoj go Jeio ghp Nhdnbe~hp ]h~$irbpbp
ojd gb ecdb~op `hcgb`h~o$bp b jhr|h~bp#
\hjwo~bdhp oh wbdo bd lrwr~o bgeh#
@O^WO BGR@OWE\O GH @HC@BDECEPW^O GO BGR@OH F AHDHJHIHR
rd chw|bj bplh~h gb `hc`bcw~oh gh }o~qrb bp`hjo~ `hc`bjaeh#
ahfb `hcpbcproj qrb rd ghp }ejo~bp nopejo~ qrb }b~dewb `hwo~ h
c|bj gb gb$pbc|hj|edbcwh gb rdo `hdrcegogb hpbr i~or gb bgr`oh b
lh~doh# H`hc`bewh gb bgr`oh bpw bpw~bewodbcwbjeiogh oh gb
`egogoceo# Gb o`h~gh `hd oJbe gb Nopbp gh Pepwbdo Bgr`owe|h !?51==2
gb 0= gb Oihpwh%#
H }o}bj gb bgr`o~ rd }~h`bpph `hd$ }jb h* }o~we`e}ogh b
}b~docbcwb* qrb pbbc`hcw~o bd ec`bppocwb drgoco* pbd}~bge~eiegh
}o~o rdo dbwo nbd gblecego6 hgbpbc|hj|edbcwh onphjrwh go }bppho
bpro ecpb~h crdo ph`ebgogb `ogo |bvdoep `hd}bwewe|o# @hdh
`hcpbqrc`eogbpwo }~bdeppo* o bgr`oh opprdb `ogo|bv doep rd }o}bj gb
w~ocp|b~pojegogb*qrb |oe drewh ojd gh bp}oh lpe`h gobp`hjo# ]hgb
gevb~$pb qrb rdo `hdrce$gogb p b|hjre~ pb whghp hp bjbdbcwhpqrb o
`hd}bd }hppr~bd op `hcgebpqrb jabp }b~dewod rd `h~~b`wh `rd}~e$
dbcwh go pro `egogoceo# Dop* }h~ hrw~hjogh* ch }hgbdhp hj|ego~
qrb bppopdbpdop `hcgebp p }hgbd pb~ oj`oco$gop pb ahr|b~ rdo
ecwb~|bch go`hdrcegogb bc|hj|bcwb#
Rd }o}bj gb `~r`eoj ed}h~wc`eo hgbpbd}bcaogh }bjop orwo~qreop#
Gbcw~hgo @hdrcegogb Bgr`owe|o gb|bd oppr$de~ h gbpiceh go lh~doh*
go }~hdhhb gh gbpbc|hj|edbcwh ghp aonewocwbp gh`hc`bjah# Bpwo ch|o
|eph ed}je`o`hcpegb~o~ qrb o bgr`oh ghp `egoghpgbe o gb pb~
~bp}hcponejegogb b `jrpe|ogop ecpwewrebp w~oge`ehcoep !Bpwogh b
Bp`hjo% b go lodjeo* dop gb|b~ pb~ opprdego* wodnd* }bjh
drce`}eh bhrw~hp oibcwbp gecodevogh~bp go ph`eb$gogb#
O }~hdrjioh gh Gb`~bwh$Jbe c# 9(>==0 gb ?2 gb Focbe~h
`h~~bp}hcgb o doeprdo bwo}o lrcgodbcwoj crd jhcih`odecah# Bpwb
Gb`~bwh$Jbe }~bwbcgbw~ocplb~e~ }o~o op orwo~qreop `hd}bwc$`eop co
~bo go Bgr`oh# ]o~o woj }~h$ }hpwh qrb pbfod `~eoghp hp
@hcpbjahpDrce`e}oep gb Bgr`oh b o @o~woBgr`owe|o `hd h hnfb`we|h gb
}b~dewe~ oecwb~|bch* cbpwo dow~eo* gb whgop oplh~op bc|hj|egop co
`hdrcegogbbgr`owe|o jh`oj#
O @o~wo Bgr`owe|o bpw gep}hc|bj }o~oghycjhog bd Gh`rdbcwhp
Hc$Jecb#
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
6/24
>==1#=7#=9 & Wbjl#6 >0< 220 79=^ro G~# Ocwceh Fhp
gb Ojdbego* c ?> $ ?# Bpq#0>= LEIRBE^ GHP \ECAHP
Oppbdnjbeo `hc`h
Nbcbd~ewh @o
@^GEWH OI^@HJ
]~oo Fhp Ocwceh ]edbcwo* c 5 $ ?# O#Wbjl#(Lo 6 >0< 22? 200
& 0>2 gb On~ej* ch }~ edh geo>0 gb On~ej }bjop ?2 ah~op*
ch Orgew~eh go@opo go @rjwr~o( @jrnb Leirbe~hbcpb wbdjrio~ h
bp}b`w`rjh drpe`oj ]ojo|~op bDpe`o $ p |bvbp o`hcwb`b/ `hd
@o~jhp]ecwh @hbjah b ]bg~h No~~hph#
Ghep @hcwogh~bp gb Aepw~eopbc`hcw~od$pb crdo owdhplb~o
gbp`hcw~ogob pbirecgh rd leh wbdwe`h jeiogh ohp |ojh~bpardochp* p
|eoibcp b ohp olb`whp* jbdwb whp* `hdbcwod lhwhi~oleop*
`hc|b~pod*hr|bd$pb* b|h`od `ophp* }bpphop b lovbdardh~#
]bg~h No~~hph* wh`o b `ocwo `ocbpbcqrog~ogop wbdowe`odbcwb b
ojrpe|op pgbe op gb @o~jhp ]ecwh @hbjah#
A rdo }~hlrcgo odevogb b bpwedo }b pp hoj qrb pr p`ewo rd
odnebcwb gbecwbjeic`eo* nbd$bpwo~ b ecwedegogb#
`hd}o~wejaogh b w~ocpdewegh h }~ovb~ go }ojo|~o bp`~ewo* go b
}~bpph drpe`oj* goco~~oh* crd ihpwh gb bpwo~* gb b|h`o~ bgb
`hdrce`o~ qrb pb w~ocpdewb oh }nje`h#
H bp}b`w`rjh wbd bcw~ogo i~owrewo#
]BG^H NO^^HPH B
@# ]ECWH @HBJAHBD LEIRBE^
@HDBDH^OBP >2 GB ON^EJ
Wb|b jrio~ ch }~bw~ewh >1 gb Do~h oOppbdnjbeo$Ib~oj ghp
Nhdnbe~hp\hjrcw~ehp gb Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp#
O ~brceh doico goqrbjo opph`eohgb`h~~br hd i~ocgb }o~we`e}oh*
gbp$wo`ocgh$pb `hdh }~ec`e}oep opprcwhp oo}~h|oh gh ^bjow~eh b
@hcwo gbIb~c`eo gb >==9 b o ow~enreh gh wwrjhgb p`eh nbcbd~ewh
@oe o gb @~gewhOi~`hjo Dwrh go Vhco gh ]ecaoj @^J#
]~bpegego }bjh G~# Fh~ib ]b~be~o*oqrbjo ~brceh ece`ehr$pb p
>? ah~op`hd o o}~bpbcwoh gb `rd}~edbcwhpohp }~bpbcwbp*
}oppocgh$pb gb pbirego o}~bpbcwoh gop @hcwop gb Ib~c`eogh och
>==9 b jbewr~o gh ]o~b`b~ gh@hcpbjah Lep`oj }bjh ]~bpegbcwb go
Ge$~b`h Bci# Leje}b Pej|o* qrb db~b`b~odo o}~h|oh }h~ rcocedegogb#
Hb b~``eh go Opph`eoh bd >==9 pojghr$pb hd rdo ~b`bewo gb
0=#=22*19 br~hp#
Gb pbirego h @hdocgocwb Fhoqred]ecwh* lbv ~blb~c`eo o`we|egogb
gh@h~}h gb Nhdnbe~hp ch och gb >==9* gbhcgb ~bppojwod* gbpgb
jhih* op >#01>pogop* hd bp}b`eoj ~bjb|h }o~o op ?0=2~bjowe|op
o `regoghp `hd ghbcwbp b op? }o~o o`egbcwbp b pb~|ehp ECBD#]o~o hp
ec`cgehp* cop prop ge|b~pop |o$~eocwbp* chdbogodbcwb* ~r~oep*
ljh~bp$woep* r~nochp b b wb~chp* ~biepwo~od$pb7 gbnowbcgh$pb hrw~hp
opprcecwb~bppb }o~o o `hjb`we|egogb
Lhwh gb o~qre|h $?5#=?#>==16Dhdbcwh bd qrb h]~bpegbcwb go @oe
oOi~`hjo go Vhco gh]ecaoj lov o bcw~bio go`ao|b go
odnrjc`eohlb~b`ego ohp Nhdnbe~hpgb Leirbe~* co }~bpbcogh ]~bpegbcwb
go Ge~b`hb gh @hdocgocwb ghp
Nhdnbe~hp* Bci# Leje}bPej|b b Fhoqred ]ecwh*~bp}b`we|odbcwb#
Ecwbi~ogh ch }~hi~odo go E Pbdoco go Ljh~bpwo bd Leirbe~ghp
\ecahp !|b~ }ieco ??%* ~bojevo$pb ch geo >7* }bjop ?7a0=*
chOrgew~eh go @opo go @rjwr~o* rdo Pbpph ]nje`o gb Ge|rjiohphn h
wbdo Ece`eowe|op Ljh~bpwoep ch dnewh gh _^BC b]^HGB^#
W~owo$pb gb rdo ece`eowe|o gb |e|h ecwb~bppb }o~o
}~h}~ebw~ehpoi~`hjop b ljh~bpwoep* bcwegogbp b }h}rjoh bd ib~oj qrb
}b~dewe~ `hcab`b~ op dbgegop gb o}heh qrb h _^BC }hgb~`hc`bgb~ bd
wb~dhp gb o}heh oh pb`wh~ ljh~bpwoj b oh drcgh~r~oj
Bpwo pbpph pb~ dhgb~ogo }bjh Bci# Ocwceh I~o|owh go@e~`rcp`~eh
Ljh~bpwoj gh @bcw~h b qrb wbd `hdh h~ogh~bp hBci# Geodocwech Io~`eo
!G^O]@% b h G~# Nb~co~gh @od}hp go@hdepph gb @hh~gbcoh b
Gbpbc|hj|edbcwh ^biehcoj gh@bcw~h#
chewb pb~ b enegh h gh`rdbcw~eh Rdo |b~gogb ec`hc|b$cebcwb gb Oj
Ih~b* w~onojah qrb prp`ewhr |ep|bj ecwb~bppboqrocgh go pro ge|rjioh
b rdo gep`rpph }~hlrcgo phn~b opwbdwe`op gh odnebcwb b gop ojwb~obp
`jedwe`op#
Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp ~b`bnb ch }~ edh geo ?> gb On~ej rdo }~h|o
gh QQ\E @od}bhcowh Co`ehcoj Ko~owb Parkhkoe#
Bpwo fh~cogo gbp}h~we|o gb`h~~b ch ]o|ejah Iedchgbp}h~we|hgb
Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp b h~iocevogo }bjo bd}~bpo gb ocedohwr~pwe`o
@h~gopw~hci !Fhp N~rch @ow~or% qrb* pbdbjaocogh och ocwb~eh~*
}~hdh|b bd Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp bpwo ece`eowe|o#
H }~hi~odo gb o`we|egogbp gb`h~~b bcw~b op 5a0=d b op ?1a72db
`hcwo `hd h o}heh gh Drce`}eh gb Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp b oFrcwo gb
L~birbpeo gb Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp#
GE\RJIOH GB O]HEHPOI^E@RJWR^O B LJH^BPWO
CO NOPB GH ^BI^BPPH H QEWH GBH^IOCEVOH B GBP]H^WE\H BD
>==9
CO@EHCOJ GB PARKHKOE
Oih~o f }hgb wb~ o`bpph qrecvbcojdbcwb oh jwedh cdb~hgh fh~coj O
@hdo~`o ch pewb go Nenjehwb`o Drce`e}oj gbLeirbe~ ghp \ecahp#
]o~o `hcprjwo~ o jwedo bgeh gh chpph fh~coj nopwo e~
pb`hEd}~bcpo Jh`oj pbjb``ehco~ O @hdo~`o* gb pbiregopbjb``ehco~ h
och }~bwbcgegh* gb}hep h dp b lecojdbcwb h cdb~hgh fh~coj#
Bpwb ch|h pb~|eh }~bpwogh }bjo Nenjehwb`o Drce`e}oj gbLeirbe~
ghp \ecahp ~bprjwo gb rdo }o~`b~eo bcw~b o Nenjehwb`o bbpwb fh~coj
qrb }o~o ojd go |b~ph bd }o}bj }oppo o hlb~b`b~ gbdhgh ecwbe~odbcwb
i~owrewh b bd wbwh ecwbi~oj o bgeh geiewoj#
O @HDO^@O HC$JECBCH PEWEH GO NENJEHWB@O DRCE@E]OJ
@o~jhp]ecwh
@hbjah
]bg~hNo~~hph
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
7/24
>==1#=7#=< 9^BIEH $ LEIRBE^ GHP \ECAHP^BIEH $ LEIRBE^ GHP
\ECAHP^BIEH $ LEIRBE^ GHP \ECAHP^BIEH $ LEIRBE^ GHP \ECAHP^BIEH $
LEIRBE^ GHP \ECAHP
LB^COCGHDO^WBJH
OG\HIOGH
^ro G~# Docrbj Pedbp No~~be~hp* ?2 $ ?#Wbj# >0< 22>
0>5 ( Wjd6 5?1 >00 >=2
$ 0>#Wjd6 5? 9>9 9= 50< 22> >15 b 0= gb Doeh b
obcw~bio ghp }~dehp ch geo >< gb Frcah*ch Fo~ged
Drce`e}oj#
Doep rdo |bv* o Orwo~qreo gbpoleo whghphp leirbe~hbcpbp qrb
crw~bd gh ihpwh }b$jo h~codbcwoh ghp bp}ohp b wb~eh~bpgo pro `opo*
o opph`eo~bd$pb o bpwo bgehgh @hc`r~ph Leirbe~ Ljh~egh#
O Orwo~qreo Leirbe~hbcpb `hd bpwoece`eowe|o gb `o~ev odnebcwoj
}~bwbcgb }~bdeo~ hp leirbe~hbcpbp qrb }~h`r~ odgo~ doep `h~ ohp
bp}ohp |b~gbp bd wh~chgop prop aonewobp* `hcw~enrecgh*
}~h$i~bppe|odbcwb* }o~o h ordbcwh gb bp}o$hp }o~we`rjo~bp
ofo~gecoghp b }o~o o `~eo$h gb rd `hc`bjah doep ow~o`we|h#
Focbjop* |o~ocgop* ocwbe~hp* dr~hp b fo~$gecp ljh~eghp ph o b
}~bpph d edo gogbge`oh oh bdnbjbvodbcwh ghp bp}o$hp b wb~eh~bp# Rd
}hr`h }h~ whgo o }o~wb* }hgb$pb }~bpbc`eo~ o nbjbvo gop ljh~bp
drj$we`hjh~bp qrb* gb rdo lh~do ao~dhcehpo*`~eod rdo |b~gogbe~o
}ecwr~o o~wpwe`o b }oep oiepwo#
Rd `hc`bjah doep oi~og|bj `hdbo }h~ cp* }h~ epph `hcwo dhp `hd o
pro }o~we`e}oh/ $ doep rd `hc|ewb qrb le`o }h~ }o~ wb go Orw o~ qre
o le irb e~hbc pb*bc|hj|bcgh o }h}rjoh gh `hc`bjah#
Op ecp`~ebp }hgb~h pb~ lbewop co
@do~o Drce`e}oj !IOGBJ%* ch ]hpwh gbWr~epdh hr cop Frcwop gb
L~birbpeo#
I^OCGB @HCW^CHPPH @OPO
Dbjah~ \eoibd gb G
$ Ojgbeop gh QepwOp Ojgbeop gh Qepwh ~b`bnb~od o gepw
Dbjah~ \eoibd gb Gbp`hnb~wo }bjo `hc`be~b|epwo ojbd gb |eoibcp*
Ibh Poehcp $ doepdejah gb we~oibd $* }bjh }~hi~odo gh h}wr~pwe`h
ojbdh Yekecib~ ^bepbc* Vr Iopw~ogewehcbjjbc P`aeblb~g~lb~c gbp ]eca
nbd$ |ecgh p w~og e`ehcoep Ojgbe op gh Q]ecaoj# ]o~o bpwo gepwech
drewh wb~ `o |epewo oh @opoj gb P# Pedh* hcgb o Y^bepbc le`hr
ojhfogo* rdo |epewo qrb O @ho`hd}ocahr `hd frpwele`ogh
gbpwoqrb#
]o~o o ^bgb gop Ojgbeop gh Qepwh* bpw~odbcwb rd }~deh go doeh~
ed}h~wc`eo* rqrb prnjecao b ~blh~o o o}hpwo bpw~owOGQWR^$ Oic`eo
}o~o h Gbpbc|hj|edWr~pwe`h gop Ojgbeop gh Qepwh* frcwodDo~`o @bcw~h
gb ]h~wrioj |bd gbpbc|hj|bcgDb~`ogh Ojbdh#O aepw~eo gbpwb }~deh
`hdbo bd D>====1?# I~ocgbp b }b~ec`eop ch }bqrbch @r`
h~iocevogo }h~ \eo \b~gb Bcwgb`kbc rcg ^b!9= }hcwhp%
># Rdo ch|o |ego cop Ojgbeop gh Qepw]h~wrioj* h~iocevo$go }h~
Yekecib~ ^b }hcwh p%
0# O gbp`hnb~wo go }ov ecwb~eh~ cbi}`eh* h~iocevo$go }h~ PK^
Pwrgebc$^bepbc !7 ojgbeop* b ecwbi~o$pb crdgbpbc|hj|edbcwh
prpwbcwogh gop ojgbeop `rfhp }~ec`e}oep hnfb`we|hp }oppod }bjo dgo
qrojegogb gb |ego gop }h}rjobp jh` }~hdhh gop o`we|egogbp b`hcde`op
w~ogb ghp }~hgrwhp jh`oep#
@O^WH LEIRBE^HBCPB P]^HDBPPO BJBEWH^OJ PH@EOJ$GBD
H Drce`}eh gbLeirbe~ ghp \ecahp*ow~o|p gh ]bjhr~h goO`h
Ph`eoj*ed}jbdbcwo h @o~whLeirbe~hbcpb Pceh~*o}~h|ogh }bjhp
~ihporw~qre`hp ch lecoj ghoch >==9#Bpwh onb~wop op`ocgegowr~op
}o~o ohnwbch gh `o~wh#
H @o~wh Leirbe~hbcpbPceh~ rdo ~bojegogb#
W~owo$pb gb rd ecpw~rdbcwhgb o`h ph`eoj gbpwecogh odbjah~o~ o
qrojegogb gb |egoghp gbpwecow~ehp* drc`e}bpdoeh~bp gb
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
8/24
>==1#=7#=* ]bg~ih I~ocgb~b`bnb o 0 bwo}o go Woo gb ]h~wrioj b
2 bgeh ghW~eowjh gh Vvb~b* }o~o o qroj bpwh f ecp`~ewhp
>0=owjbwop# W~owo$pb gb rdo }~h|o o hcwo~ }o~o oWoo gb ]h~wrioj
go dhgojegogb hd ece`eh }bjop?2a==* hd h e~`rewh gb cowoh co
Ojnrlbe~o gh@on~ej* frcwh oh }o~bgh go No~~oibd* bpwocgh }~b|epwh h
pbr lecoj }h~ |hjwo gop ?9a0= ch Fo~gedgo Gb|bpo# Bpw oppbir~ogo o
}~bpbco ghp owjbwopqrb ~b}~bpbcwod o Pbjb`h Co`ehcoj gb W~eowjhchp
gelb~bcwbp bp`ojbp# H W~ocpewh bpwo~ h~woghgbcw~h go |ejo gop ?7a==
p ?9a0=#
O qrecwo bgeh gh W~eowjh gh Vvb~b gep}rwo$pb co gepwc`eo p}~ecw
!92= dbw~hp gb cowoh $rdo |hjwo%* >>*0 qrejdbw~hp gb `e`jepdh
!w~p|hjwop% b 7*5 qrejdbw~hp gb h~~ego !w~p |hjwop%#
H cdb~h gb ecp`~ewhp drewh oi~og|bj* crdo
`jo~o gbdhcpw~oh gh ecwb~bppb qrb o dhgojegogbwbd ib~ogh frcwh
ghp }~owe`ocwbp* }~b|bcgh$pbopped doep rdo }~h|o nopwocwb
}o~we`e}ogo#
O No~~oibd gh @on~ej h }hcwh gb }o~wego }o~o h pbidbcwh gb
cowoh# Gb ne`e jbwo* hp owjbwop|h ow oh ]o~qrb gb W~ocpeh >*
ecpwojogh chJo~ih go Gb|bpo* }b~wh go @do~o Drce`e}oj* b`rd}~bd w~p
|hjwop bd ~bgh~ go |ejo gb ]bg~ihI~ocgb# O h~~ego blb`wro$pb wodnd
co |ejo b odbwo bpwo~ ecpwojogo ch Fo~ged go Gb|bpo#
H ]o~qrb gb W~ocpeh > bpwo~ onb~wh bcw~b op?0a== b op ?7a==
}o~o o `hjh`oh gh dowb~eoj }o~o o `h~~ego* bcqrocwh h ]o~qrb gb
W~ocpeh?* ecpwojogh }b~wh go No~~oibd gh @on~ej* on~b p?0a7= b
bc`b~~o rdo ah~o gb}hep# Hp }b~`r~phpb h ~birjodbcwh go }~h|o bpwh
gep}hc|bep chpweh go Lbgb~oh gb W~eowjh gb ]h~wrioj#
O qrecwo bgeh gh W~eowjh gh Vvb~b }hcwr$|bj }o~o o Woo gb
]h~wrioj* hd}bweh qrb f }opphr }h~ Dowhpecahp* ]bcolebj* _ro~wbe~o
b^enowbfh# @hd qrow~h bwo}op gep}rwogop* obqre}o gh
Aoj`hc$P}h~wvhcb$Hjd}e`h gb Hbe~opjegb~o ch pb`wh~ dop`rjech hd w~p
w~erclhp# Chpb`wh~ lbdecech* o Ojaocg~o P}h~weci @jrnb`hdocgo hd
eiroj cdb~h gb |ew~eop#
O @do~o Drce`e}oj gb ]bg~ih I~ocgb h~io$cevo h \ W~eowjh gh
Vvb~b* hcwocgh hd h o}hehw`ce`h go Lbgb~oh gb W~eowjh gb
]h~wrioj#
]BG^IH
^B@BNB O 2 BWO]O
\ W^EOWJH GH VVB^BOPPH@EOH BD]^BPO^EOJ ]^HDH\B
PBPPH GB BP@JO^B@EDBCWH
O]HEHP OH ON^EIH GH _^BC
LOQ >?0 52? =2> ^ro go Bpw~bjo
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
9/24
>==1#=7#=< 5^BIEH $ ]BG^IH I^OCGB^BIEH $ ]BG^IH
I^OCGB^BIEH $ ]BG^IH I^OCGB^BIEH $ ]BG^IH I^OCGB^BIEH $ ]BG^IH
I^OCGB
Ch|o ocgegowr~oo}~h|ogo
ORWO^_REOO]HPWO CHBP]OHECWB^CBW
O Orwo~qreo }bg~hirbc$pb |er o}~h|ogo rdo`hd}o~we`e}oh
lecoc`be~ogh ]~hi~odo H}b~o`ehcoj^biehcoj gh @bcw~h chdhcwocwb gb
00#>>2*90 br$~hp* ~b}~bpbcwocgh ="gh ec|bpwedbcwh
whwojbjbi|bj $ dhcwocwb whwoj$dbcwb lecoc`eogh }bjhLBGB^* }h~
gbp}o`ah ghDecepw~h go @ec`eo* Wb`ch$jhieo b Bcpech
Pr}b~eh~*gbpwecogh `hcwecrohgo o`we|egogb gh Bp}ohEcwb~cbw gb
]bg~ih I~oc$gb#
H Drce`}eh gb ]bg~$ih I~ocgb gb|b~ oppb$ir~o~ h ~bpwocwb go
`hcw~o$ }o~wego co`ehcoj ch dhc$wocwb gb ?7#911*00
br~hp*~b}~bpbcwocgh 0=*1=" ghec|bpwedbcwh whwoj bjbi|bj#
H Bp}oh Ecwb~cbw gb ]b$g~ih I~ocgb pr~ier copbqrc`eo go b
`bjbcwb b $ }b~ec`eo $ go qroj h Drce$`e}eh }bg~hirbcpb lhe
}eh$
cbe~h* bd ]h~wrioj $ hnwegoow~o|p gh ? }~hfb`wh bdqrb h c|bj gb
ogbph b gbrwejevoh gb rd bp}oh }$ nje`h }o~o op Wb`chjhieopgo
Eclh~doh* }b~dewer o`~eoh gb anewhp bcw~b o fr|bcwrgb
gbpeicogodbcwbgb `hdrce`oh b h`r}o$h }~hgrwe|o gb wbd}hpje|~bp b*
cowr~ojdbcwb* ho`bpph i~owrewh eclh~do$h o`wrojevogo b o
rd`hcpwocwb r}i~ogb ghp`hcab`edbcwhp wb`chjie$`hp#
O`wrojdbcwb ecpwojogh coNenjehwb`o Drce`e}oj gb
]bg~ih I~ocgb* h Bp}ohEcwb~cbw gb ]bg~ih I~oc$gb }~bwbcgb
}hwbc`eo~* o }o~ gh lrc`ehcodbcwh goNenjehwb`o Drce`e}oj*
pecb~$ieop gb eclh~doh b hdr$ce`oh `hcwocgh oecgo`hd bqre}odbcwh
qrb }b~dewb h o`bpph Ecwb~cbw }h~ }o~wb gb ec|eproep#
H Bp}oh Ecwb~cbw gb]bg~ih I~ocgb gbwdoecgo o |ojc`eo gb @bcw~hgb
Ge}jhdop gb @hd}bwc$`eop Npe`op bd Wb`chjh$ieop go Eclh~doh#
\EJO LO@OEO @HD WH]HCDEECE@EOWE\O GO FRCWO GB L^BIRBPEO
O Frcwo gb L~birbpeogb \ejo Lo`oeo |O}~h|ogh }bjo @do~oDrce`e}oj
gb ]bg~ihI~ocgb h pbr ]~hfb`whgb Wh}hcdeo }o~o oL~birbpeo gb
\ejoLo`oeo
O Frcwo gb L~birbpeo gb \ejoLo`oeo |er o}~h|ogh h pbr]~hfb`wh gb
Wh}hcdeo goL~birbpeo gb \ejo Lo`oeo* crd }~h`b pp h qrb `hdb hr
a
`b~`o gb < dbpbp#Bpwb }~hfb`wh bc|hj|br jhihgb ece`eh o
}h}rjoh go l~b$irbpeo* ow~o|p go onb~wr~o gbrd }b~hgh }o~o
}o~we`e}oh }nje`o* hcgb lh~od ~b`bnegopecdb~op }~h}hpwop }o~ochdbp
gop |eop* o qrb pb pb$irer* |epewop gb od}h o whgopop jh`ojegogbp
go l~birbpeo }o~o ~b`hjab~ o h}eceh b op }~h}hpwop go }h}rjoh
~bpe$gbcwb* qrb gb}hep lh~od bpwr$gogop(gbnowegop }bjh b b`r$we|h
go frcwo gb l~birbpeo b qrb`rjdechr co }~h}hpwo lecoj#
Aepwh~eocgh rd }hr`h phn~bo b|hjrh gh }~h`bpph* bdd
>5(=5(>==9* o Frcwo gb L~b$irbpeo gb \ejo Lo`oeo o}~h|hrh
]~hfb`wh gb Wh}hcdeo go
L~birbpeo gb \ejo Lo`oeo* coOppbdnjbeo L~birbpeo* qrbbc|ehr
}hpwb~eh~dbcwb }o~o hDrce`e}eh gb ]bg~ih I~oc$gb* }o~o }o~b`b~ go
@hdepphDrce`e}oj gb Wh}hcdeo# Bd?>(?>(>==9* bpwo @hdepph
gbrh pbr }o~b`b~ lo|h~|bj wbcghpegh o}~h|ogh }bjh B
b`rwe|hDrce`e}oj bd ?7 gb Do~h gb>==1#
O @hdepph gb Wh}hcdeolhe hd}hpwo }h~ Fhh DocrbjIhdbp Do~qrbp*
]~bpegbcwbgo @do~o Drce`e}oj* qrb }~bpeger ~brceh; OcwhcechDo~`bjh
Pojirbe~h No}wepwo*
Bci# Lorpwh Jh}bp go @hpwo*Bci# D~eh @hbjah Lb~$cocgbp* h
]~bpegbcwb go Frcwogb L~birbpeo gb \ejo Lo`oeo*Fhp Docrbj go
@hc`behGo|eg; ghp Pb~|ehp W`ce`hpgo Orwo~qreo gb ]bg~ihI~ocgb* h
Ibp# Wb~~ew~eh N~r$ch Deirbj Ocwrcbp Ihdbp#
Bd cdb~hp* o @o~wo gbWh}hcdeo O}~h|ogo `hcpwewrgo }h~ ?7? chdbp
gb|eop* `hd 5< ~rop* >2 `odec$ahp* 1 jo~ihp* 1 nb`hp* >
}~oopb > }o~qrbp* on~ocibcgh owhwojegogb gop >7 jh`ojegogbpgo
L~birbpeo* gbpeicogo$dbcwb6 Ojoio* ]hn~oep*No~~o`o go Nho|epwo*
@opoj goAh~wo* \~vbop* Pojonh~go Ch |o * Po jo nh~g o \bja o*
@od}bjhp* \ojb go Chirbe~o*@opoj Gb Ojd* Dhjbe~hp* \ejoLo`oeo*
@opoj go ]b|egb* @opojgh @rdb* Ojgbeo gop L~be~op*]ecabe~h gh
Nhjed* Jodbe~o @e$dbe~o* Jodbe~o Lrcgbe~o* P~# go]ebgogb* ^odojah*
^oneih~gh*@o`ejaop* ] go Jhdno* I~o$|ewh#
Cbpwb @o~wo gb Wh}hcdeo }~e|ejbiehr$pb hp chdbp w~oge$`ehcoep b
hp egoghp gb d~ewhqrb `hcw~enr~od }o~o h gb$pbc|hj|edbcwh go
L~birbpeogb \ejo Lo`oeo#
N~b|bdbcwb b opped qrb }hpp|bj* pb~h `hjh`ogop op
}jo`op gop |eop b hp cdb~hpgb }hje`eo#
O }~h}hpwo }o~o o }jo`ogb wh}hcdeo
O }jo`o !`hclh~db lhwh qrbejrpw~o bpwb o}hcwodbcwh% `hd}hpwo
}bjhp n~opbp gh@hc`bjah gb ]bg~ih I~ocgbb go L~birbpeo gb \ejo
Lo`oeo* bpqrb~go* `hd rdo jecaoodo~bjo co ah~evhcwoj hd o h~
~b}~bpbcwowe|o go L~birbpeo*a ge~bewo o}o~b`b h wh}cedhgo
jh`ojegogb bd qrb o |eo pbecpb~b b }h~ noe h go jecao ~b$
}~bpbcwowe|o go l~birbpeo b oh
`bcw~h o}o~b`b o gbpeicohgo |eo bd qrbpwh#@ P
Bp}jocogo b]o~qrb gb
Bpwo`ehcodbcwh
D o ~
e p ` h p b ] b w
e p ` h p
$Wbj# >0< 220 >21 $0>?a==d b ~bojevo~$pb$ ch pojh
gbpwo`hjb`we|egogb#
Ch geo >9 gb On~ej* ghdecih*
pb~ ~bojevogh rd jbejh w~oge$`ehcoj `hd hlb~bcgop Lbpwogb Pocwo
@owo~eco >==1#
Bpwop grop ece`eowe|op bcijh$ nod$pb ch jbqrb gb o` bpqrb o @@^
\ejo Lo`oeo |oe gb$pbc`ogbo~ chp }~ edhp db$pbp `hd |epwo ocio~eoh
gblrcghp }o~o }~hdhh b ~bo$jevoh go Lbpwo @rjwr~oj gbPocwo @owo~eco
>==1* o ~bojevo~$pb chp }~ edhp geop 0? gb
@OPO GB @
I^OCGB O@
\EJO LO@OEO
Doeh b ? gb Frcah#
Dop* o gecde`o b o}o`gb gb ecwb~|bch b }o~wh gh @@^ \ejo Lo`oeo
c`hcleco p l~hcwbe~op lpl~birbpeo# B bd}jh gepphpbr bc|hj|edbcwh b
o}heh\ W~eowjh gh Vvb~b* }~ }h~we|o gb dnewh co`ehcpb wbd |ecgh o
~bojevo~ dbcwb bd ]bg~ih I~ocgbqr pb ~bojevo ch }~ edh ggb
On~ej#
W^O\BPPEO CH ^EH VV
W^OCPVVB^B $ >
O IhHrwghh~
}~hdh|b chpgeop >2* >9 gbOn~ej o
w~o|bppeo ch^eh Vvb~b $W~ocpvvb~b$ bd Kouok
H ^eh V$vb~b h bc$~eh }o~o rdo o|bcwr~o gb w~p geop hcgb o
w~ocqrejego nbjbvo go }oepoibd b h `hc||eh bcw~b odeihp pb `hcrdo b
}b~ec`eo ce`o# B }b~edbcwb o jenb~gogb b o gb }b~lbewo `hdrcah `hd
o Cowr~bvo }~h}h~`ehco`ochoibd gb w~o|bppeo bd orwhchdeo#
W~ocp}h~wocgh chp kouokp whgo o `hdego bcb`bpp~ehp ohp geop qrb
pb pbirbd* }hgb bpqrb`b~ hpb qrbn~o~ op ~hwecop* o}~h|bewocgh oh d
edh whghp hqrb jab }~b}o~dhp#
@hd ec`eh co Ojgbeo gh Qepwh gb j|o~h* h }b~`r~phojircp ghp
jh`oep doep nhcewhp gh ^eh Vvb~b* `hdh ^enbe~o gb ]b~o* o Nhr b o
Lhv gh Ojib* }oppocgh oOjgbeo gh Qepwh gb ]bg~ih ]bqrbch* ow `abio~
a|ejo gb Gh~cbp# H o`od}odbcwh pb~ lbewh bd jh`oep lo frcwh oh ~eh*
pbcgh h focwo~ }~b}o~ogh }bjh chpph
]o~o o`bgb~ o doep eclh~dobp phn~b bpwo o`we|egHrwghh~ wbd
gep}hce|bj h peweh yyy#ih$hrwghh~#}w bbjb`w~ce`h*
eclhMih$hrwghh~#}w#
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
10/24
>==1#=7#=
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
11/24
>==1#=7#=< ??^BIEHCOJ^BIEHCOJ^BIEHCOJ^BIEHCOJ^BIEHCOJ
Wbjbl#6>0< 22> 00< 22> 07=
&DOEJ6~bpegbc`eoj#dojahoMpo}h#}w
Whghp hp qro~whp `( @opo gb Nocah ]~e|owe|o*Oqrb`edbcwh @bcw~oj*
W\ b Wbjblhcb
^ro Dofh~ Cbrwbj gb On~br* ?22O}o~wogh ? & 0>?1 710 0??
?=== $ ?25 JEPN
>jhfo
?jhfo
]O^_RB ]^E\OWE\H $ @JEBCWBP^# NB^CO^GED ^ENBE^H*
??2= $ =9= JEPNHO
^# @HCGB BGHCGH* CWbj#6 >?0 2
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
12/24
>==1#=7#= ^B]H^^B]H^^B]H^^B]H^^B]H^
WWWWWOOOOOIBDIBDIBDIBDIBD
HP ?P FHIHP LEIRBE^HJDO Bp`hjo Pb`rcg~eo gbLeirbe~ ghp \ecahp
}~hdh|brgb ?= o ?0 gb Do~h hp ?pFhihp Leirbe~Hjd}e`hp qrbbc|hj|b~od
00= ojrchpgoqrbjo bp`hjo#Rd bch~db pr`bpph $ lhe oh}eceh
hcpbcproj#Gr~ocwb hp qrow~h geop gb`hd}bweh* 00= fh|bcp goPb`rcg~eo
gb Leirbe~ ghp\ecahp hjh`o~od }~h|o hppbrp wojbcwhp bd
dhgojegogbp`hdh h ocgbnhj* |hjbenhj*nopqrbwbnhj* lrwpoj*
owjbwepdh*nogdecwhc* iecpwe`o bcowoh* crd o`hcwb`edbcwhqrb bc|hj|br
whgo o`hdrcegogb bp`hjo~#O }~bpbco gb owjbwop hjd}e`hp`hdh hpo Dhwo
b D~eh Pej|ogbr oecgo doep n~ejah o bpwbb|bcwh#Hp fh|bcp ojrchp go
Bp`hjoPb`rcg~eo gb Leirbe~ ghp\ecahp fodoep bpqrb`b~h
bpwoece`eowe|o b* b~wodbcwb*~bpb~|o~h ch pbr jnrd gb~b`h~gobp rd
ocwecahdrewh bp}b`eoj }o~o hdhdbcwh die`h bd qrb hpoDhwo hjh`hr o
whghp hpojrchp(owjbwop }o~we`e}ocwbp odbgojao ojrpe|o oh b|bcwh*
coPbpph gb Bc`b~~odbcwh ghpFhihp#
]o~o bppb dbpdh jnrd* oqrele`o h hcw~enrwh gb O@hdo~`o hd ojircp
ghpdhdbcwhp qrb ejrpw~od hb|bcwh
? >
0 7
2
1
9
5
?=
?? ?> ?0 ?7
6 dhdbcwh ghFr~odbcwh; Lhwh 06 hp fhihpgb bqre}o* ch `oph h
\hjbenhj*bd}hjio~od owjbwop b `joqrbp;Lhwh 76 }h~dbch~ gb rdo
}~h|ogb Owjbwepdh `hd D~eh Pej|o oec`bcwe|o~; Lhwh 2 b 6 o
}o~wego}o~o o Do~owhco bd qrb}o~we`e}o~od >>= ojrchp; Lhwh?06
h joc`ab b h db~b`egh gbp$`ocph o}p o }~h|o go Do~owhcoqrb
ocwb`bgbr h Bc`b~~o$dbcwh; Lhwh ?76 ^hpo Dhwo g}h~ bc`b~~oghp hp
Fhihp# @hd`ao|b gb hr~h $ geio$pb#
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
13/24
>==1#=7#=< ?0^BIEH $ LEIRBE^ GHP \ECAHP^BIEH $ LEIRBE^ GHP
\ECAHP^BIEH $ LEIRBE^ GHP \ECAHP^BIEH $ LEIRBE^ GHP \ECAHP^BIEH $
LEIRBE^ GHP \ECAHP
LEIRBE^ GHP \ECAHP @O]EWO@HDBDH^OBP GH GEO ECWB^CO@EHCOJ GH
JE
O Ge~b`h$Ib~oj gh Je|~h b gop Nenjeh$wb`op opph`ehr$pb
Nenjehwb`o Drce`e}oj
Pedbp gb Ojdbego !weh%* bd Leirbe~ ghp\ecahp* co `hdbdh~oh gh
Geo Ecwb~co$`ehcoj gh Je|~h Eclocwej#
O |epewo gh Decepw~h go @rjwr~o gr~ocwbo doca !|b~ chw`eo
}~ec`e}oj% lhe rd ghp }hcwhp ojwhp gh }~hi~odo# Ch bcwocwh* h
}b~hgh go wo~gb wodnd pb ~b|bpwer gbi~ocgb ecwb~bppb* `hd o
~bojevoh gb rdodbpo$~bghcgo ecwewrjogo Nenjehwb`opbc^BGBgogop6
pb~|ehp nenjehwb`~ehp nopboghp co Ecwb~cbw* ch @jrnb Leirbe$~hbcpb
$ @opo go @rjwr~o
Dhgb~ogo }bjo G~o# @jeo Abewh~ !@ablbgo Ge|eph gb
Gbpbc|hj|edbcwh gb Pb~|e$hp Nenjehwb`~ehp go Ge~b`h$Ib~oj ghJe|~h b
gop Nenjehwb`op%* bpwo dbpo$~bghc$go `hcwhr `hd o }~bpbco gh
\e`b$]~bpe$gbcwb go Orwo~qreo Leirbe~hbcpb $ b \b~b$ogh~ go
@rjwr~o* G~# j|o~h Ihcoj|bp b
go Ge~b`wh~o$Ib~oj gh Je|~h b gop Nenjeh$wb`op* G~o# ]orjo Dh~h
qrb rpo~od go }ojo|~o co onb~wr~ o go pbpph* ojbd go }o~we`e}oh gb
|~ehp nenjehwb`~ehp gb|~ehp }hcwhp gh }op b gb Bp}ocao*
qrb~bjowo~od b }b~ec`eop gb w~onojah ~bjo`e$hcogop `hd h wbdo#
@hrnb oh Orwo~`o Leirbe~hbcpb lovb~ o onb~wr~o ghp w~onojahp*
gocgh op nhop|ecgop* oi~ogb`bcgh op }~bpbcop* bd }o~we`rjo~
Ge~b`wh~o$Ib~oj gh Je|~h b gopNenjehwb`op* o qrbd wodnd oi~ogb`br
ho}heh }~bpwogh cbpwb b|bcwh# j|o~hIhcoj|bp ~bojhr o ed}h~wc`eo
gbpwbpb|bcwhp ch gbpbc|hj|edbcwh gh `hc`b$jah b wb~dechr `hd rdo
}ojo|~o gbbjhieh Nenjehwb`o Drce`e}oj gb Leirbe~ghp \ecahp* }bjh
pbr gecodepdh b
}~hwoihcepdh#]orjo Dh~h `hdbhr }h~ ~bp}hcgb~
oh Orwo~`o leirbe~hbcpb* `hcpegb~ocgh`hdh rdo hn~eioh o}heo~
bpwop ece`e$owe|op* gbpgb qrb pbfod }~hfb`whp nbdo}~bpbcwoghp b
`hcpepwbcwbp* `hdh lheh `oph# ]orjo Dh~h w~bdechr jbdn~ocgho
dbcpoibd gbpwb och gh Geo Ecwb~co$`ehcoj gh Je|~h Eclocwej $ Hp
je|~hpejrdecod* h `hcab`edbcwh bc`ocwo $ }o$~o ~bojo~ o ed}h~wc`eo
go jbewr~o b o cb$`bppegogb gb o bpwedrjo~#
Ece`eoghp hp w~onojahp* crd }~edbe~h }oecbj* jeh @hedn~o*
!Nenjehwb`~eh ~bp$ }hcp|b j }bjo Nenjehwb`o Drce`e}oj gb]hdnoj%*
Fhp Ocwceh @oje wh !Ge~b`wh~ go Nenjehwb`o ]nje`o gb |h~o b
]~hlbp$ph~ Or ejeo~ @hc|egogh go Rce|b~pegogbgb |h~o% b Aejo~eh
Ab~ccgbv !Ge~b`wh~ gh @bcw~h gb Gbpo~hjjh Ph`eh`rjwr~oj gb
]bo~ocgo gb N~o`odhcwb go LrcgoIb~dc Pc`abv ^re}~bv* Bp}ocao
gbpbc|hj|b~od* ~bp}b`we|odbcwb* hdop Ecwb~cbw6 h ep`h }b~lbewh
}och|hp jbewh~bp; O Ecwb~cbw `hdgb bpw~bewo~ hp johp `hd o `hdrceb
Jo jb`wr~o bc^BGogo#
Crd pbircgh }oecbj* P~ieh Docio!Nenjehwb`~eh ~bp}hcp|bj }bjo
NenjDrce`e}oj gb Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp%* Ihcoj|bp !Lh~dogh~ bd
gbpbc|hj|edbcwh ybn b Ybn gb|bjh}b~% b DocrNo~~bwh Crcbp
!]~hlbpph~o Or ejeo~~b`wh~o go Nenjehwb`o Ib~oj go
Rce|b]h~wr`ojbcpb%* levb~od o o}~bpbcwpeweh go Nenjehwb`o Drce`e}oj
gb Lghp \ecahp* phn hp wbdop Rdo o}hpwpb~|ehp nenjehwb`~ehp
nopboghp ccbw* Hp lrcgodbcwhp w`ce`hplrcgodbcwhp wb~e`hp*
~bp}b`we
NENJEHWB@^EHP BJONENJEHWB@OP BC^BGBGOGOP
DECEPW^H O]JORGB###GB \EPEWO NENJEHWB@O DRCE@E]OJ
Op `hdbdh~obp gh GeoEcwb~co`ehcoj gh Je|~hEclocwej $ >==1
~bojevod$pbbpwb och bd Leirbe~ ghp\ecahp* crdo }o~`b~eo qrbbc|hj|br
h Drce`}eh gbLeirbe~ ghp \ecahp* ch pbr`hcfrcwh b o
Nenjehwb`oDrce`e}oj Pedbp gbOjdbego !weh% bd }o~we`rjo~ bh
Decepw~eh go @rjwr~oow~o|p go Ge~b`h$Ib~oj ghJe|~h b gop
Nenjehwb`op#H Decepw~h go @rjwr~o* ]ecwh^enbe~h lhe ~b`bnegh ch
PojhChn~b ghp ]ohp gh @hc`bjah}bjop ??a== bd pbpph gbnhop |ecgop b
lbv rdo |epewo Nenjehwb`o Drce`e}oj* jh`ojhcgb gb`h~~eod owbjep
gb}~hdhh go jbewr~o }o~o hpojrchp gh }~$bp`hjo~ gh@hc`bjah
Co |epewo Nenjehwb`o Drce`e}oj* h decepw~h lhe hcl~hcwogh hd
|$~eop ece`eowe|op gb gecodevoh gh je|~h eclocwej frcwh ghp doep
ch|hp#
^biepwb$pb rd b}epgeh `r~ehph* bd qrb h decepw~h lhe
dbpdhed}bgegh gb bcw~o~ crdo pojo qrocgh bpwo|od o gb`h~ ~b~ rdo
gbppop
o`we|egogbp# Crdo hrw~o pojo* oppepwer o rd }bqrbch dhdbcwh
gbgecodevoh gh dbgeogh~ go Ge~b`h$ib~oj gh Je|~h b gop
Nenjehwb`op*Deirbj Ah~wo#
]b~ocwb doep gb rdo gbvbco gb dbcechp gh fo~ged$gb$eclc`eojh`oj
qrb h hjao|od `hd drewo owbch* Deirbj Ah~wo ejrpw~hr rd }hbdo gb
Wppoc bcqrocwh h ~b`ewo|o* onpw~oecgh $pb go owbch ghp|epewocwbp*
db~b`bcgh* ch lecoj* h o}jorph gh decepw~h* q rb hcpegb~hrbpwb we}h
gb ece`eowe|op rd b bd}jh goqrejh qrb gb|b pb~ lbewh bqrbbpwop
phjrbp }hgbd pb~ rdo lh~do gb o`h~go~ op ~eocop doep`bgh b doep
}~hlrcgodbcwb }o~o oqrejh qrb o jbewr~o* h qrb o jeciroibd b h
`hcab`edbcwh gbjop dbpdop b gh drcgh#
Deirbj Ah~wo prpwbcwhr o ed}h~wc`eo gbpwb we}h gb w~onojah
frcwhghp doep ch|hp* }~hdh|bcgh ch|hp jbewh~bp b ch|hp `~eogh~bp*
bo}bjhr wrwbjo }o~o qrb }~hdh|o o ~bbgeh gb }hbwop gbge`oghp
eclc`eo#O }hbpeo h }~edbe~h }opph }o~o h je|~h $ b
}je`hr*pojebcwocgh qrb o drpe`ojegogb b o phch~egogb gop }ojo|~op
gbp}b~woo owbch bcw~b hp doep ch|hp# Dop }o~o qrb bpwo bpw~owieo
wbcaopr`bpph* Ah~wo hcpegb~o cb`bpp~eh qrb op lodjeop ec|epwod
wodndcbpwo ~bo b }~hdh|od bd }~e|ogh o jbewr~o gb }hbpeo bd |hv
ojwo#
Ch }~bw~ewh geo > gb On~ej*Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp lhe }oj`hgb
|~eop o`we|egogbp ch dne$wh gop `hdbdh~obp gh GeoEcwb~co`ehcoj gh
Je|~h Eclocwej#
H }hcwh ojwh wb|b jrio~ gr$
~ocwb o doca* `hd o ~b`b}hoh Decepw~h go @rjwr~o* ]ecwh^enbe~h*
ch Pojh Chn~b ghp]ohp gh @hc`bjah# Pbirer$pbrdo |epewo Nenjehwb`o
Drce`e$ }oj* jh`oj hcgb h decepw~h lhe
`hcl~hcwogh `hd |~eop ece`eo$we|op gb gecodevoh gh je|~heclocwej
frcwh ghp doep ch|hp#Bd pedrjwcbh* gb`h~~eo co @o$po go
@rjwr~o$@jrnb Leirbe~h$bcpb rd bp}b`w`rjh gb wbow~h*
}bjh i~r}h Ocgocwb* ge~eieghohp ojrchp gh ?# `e`jh#
H Decepw~h go @rjwr~o gblbc$gbr qrb hp oibcwbp jh`oep gb$|bd
}~hdh|b~ h w~onojah bd~bgb* qrb doep ble`ov b
doep no~owh }o~o h b~~eh }$ nje`h#
Bd |bv gb bpwo~dhp pbd}~bo gbp`hn~e~ o ~hgo* bpwodhp orwejevo~ o
~hgo qrb hrw~hp f le$vb~od* h qrb wh~co h }~hfb`whdoep no~owh dop
wodnddoep ble`ov ph`eojdbcwb b`rjwr~ojdbcwb $ geppb#
We|bdhp rdo lopb gb `hcp$w~rh gb drewhp bqre}odbc$whp `rjwr~oep
b oih~o }~b `ep h go~ $ja bp `hcwbgh b|ego* ole~dhr ]ecwh
^enbe~h#
O jciro rd ecpw~rdbcwhbppbc`eoj gb egbcwegogb b gbjenb~gogb#
Bcqrocwh chphrnb~dhp jb~ b bp`~b|b~ b chwe|b~dhp rd bcwbcgedbcwh
`jo$~h go chppo jciro ch phdhp|b~gogbe~odbcwb ardochp*h}echr h
ih|b~cocwb#
o jciro qrb chp }b~dewb`hc|b~po~* pbgrve~* codh~o~*lovb~
cbi`ehp* |eofo~# o jc$iro qrb chp }b~dewb bcwbcgb~ hp hrw~hp b bjo
qrb chp gep$wecirb ghp ocedoep* pojebcwhrh decepw~h* }o~o qrbd h
je|~h
rd bjbdbcwh bppbc`eoj cb }~h`bpph gb o}~bcgevoibgblbcgbr qrb
bpwb ecpw~rgb|b pb~ o`bpp|bj b `hd}bcp|bj* gb|b wb~ rdo co~~phn~b
cp dbpdhp#
^re Pej|o* ]~bpegbcwb gowo~qreo leirbe~hbcpb* gb`hcpegb~o~ qrb o
}~bpbcdecepw~h ec`bcwe|o b pbcvo oecgo doep }o~o op qrb`rjwr~oep*
lbv o o}~bpgh `hc`bjah b ~bojhr h h~irjah ch dbpdh b geppbowbcwh p
prop cb`bppeb ~bp}hcponejegogbp#
H Orwo~`o leirbe~hbo}~h|bewhr o }~bpbco g|b~cocwb }o~o h pbcpen
}o~o }~hfb`whp bd dh*ogodbcwb* o `hcpb~|o~bpwor~h go Ei~bfo Dow~
fb`wh go ^hwo gb Dojaho }o~`b~eo `hd hp Drce`}eh@ojgop go ^oecao b
Oj}eoh Drpbr gb O~wb Cowr~oj`hcpw~re~ cop edbgeo@oprjh gb
Dojaho#
@
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
14/24
>==1#=7#=
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
15/24
>==1#=7#=< ?2^BIEH^BIEH^BIEH^BIEH^BIEH
LEIRBE^HBCPBW^ONOJAOGH^BP GO OGDE
Ch }oppogh geo ?> gb Do~h wb|b jrio~ rd }~hwbpwh qrb ~brcer
dejao~bp gbw~onojaogh~bp go ogdecepw~oh jh`oj gbwhgh h }op qrb
gbplejo~od bcw~b h Wb~$~be~h gh ]oh b o ~bpegc`eo hle`eoj
gh]~edbe~h$decepw~h#
Bcw~b bjbp ch|b lrc`ehc~ehp go Orwo~$qreo leirbe~hbcpb qrb
}o~wejaod* b lovbdqrbpwh gb docelbpwo~* o pro ecgeicohlo`b op
`o~~be~op qrb bpwh o e~ }h~ iroonoe h* hp poj~ehp `ogo |bv doep noe
hpb hp |c`rjhp doep }~b`~ehp#
Ecgeicoh* ~b|hjwo b pbcwedbcwhgb ecfrpweo qrb Lb~cocgh
Jhr~bch*lrc`ehc~eh go Orwo~qreo leirbe~hbcpb* lbv
`abio~ chppo ~bgo`h wbcgh$chgo* w~ocpdewegh grop ~bljb bp*chpphp
jbewh~bp* bd ib~oj* b qge~bewh* bd }o~we`rjo~6 frpwwh~epwo b rd
H}b~ogh~ gb Dqrecb bd}jh* `hd op ~bp}hcponejegogecb~b~bcwbp*
rprl~re~bd gb rd poj7>9 Br~hp b 2== Br~hp8 bpwbprle`ebcwb }o~o
prpwbcwo~ rdo lodgeicegogb8#
Co lhwh* Lb~cocg h Jhr~bch o} ge~bewo bd}rcaocgh rd `o~wov*`hd
hrw~h ghp ch|b lrc`ehc~ehp gowo~qreo leirbe~hbcpb* bd }jbco dowoh
gb ?> gb Do~h#
FH\BCP PH@EOJ$GBDH@^OWOP \EPCH WB BP_RBOP GHP EGHPHP
Ch }oppogh geo ?< gb Do~h* o FPG Leirbe~hbcpb jb|hro `onh rdo
o`h ph`eoj ecwewrjogo Ch wb bpqrbop
ghp Eghphp* cbpwb `hcwb wh* lhe ~bojevogo rdo |epewo Pocwo @opo
go Depb~e`~geo* Jo~ @bcw~h gb Geo* Jo~ E bEE* co ~bp}b`we|o ah~o
gbpwecogo }o~o bppb blbewh#Pbircgh ]orjh I~ecojge $ jegb~ go FPG
leirbe~hbcpb $w~owhr$pb gb rdo ece`eowe|o ed}h~wocwb* ecwbi~ogo
co}h`o }op`oj b }h~ epph `hcpepwer* }o~o ojd go w~h`ogb gejhih* co
gepw~enreh gb }o`hwbp gb odcghop }bjh p rwbc wbp* lodejeo~b p b lrc
`ehc~ehp* }~bpbc wbpcoqrbjo ecpwewreh#Wbdhp gb wb~ `hcp`ec`eo qrb
|e|bdhp crdoph`ebgogb ijhnoj b o fr|bcwrgb* bd }o~we`rjo~*
bc`hcw~o$pb rd }hr`h gepwocwb ghp eghphp* gb|egh ~hwecoqrhwegeoco b
o hrw~op b eic`eop gh geo$o$geo* chbcwocwh* whghp hp fh|bcp wd h
gb|b~ gb ojwb~o~ bpwo~bojegogb* }h~qrbrd geo wodndpb~h eghphp
$ogdewer h ]~bpe$gbcwb go @hdepph]hjwe`o go Pb`hgo FPG
leirbe~hbc$pb* ]orjh I~ecojge*qrb gbe hr* oecgo*o }~hdbppo gb qrbpb
`hcwecro~h o~bojevo~ ece`eowe|oppedejo~bp#
@P
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
16/24
>==1#=7#=0< 701 570
O i b c
w b g h
F h ~ c o
j . O @ h d o ~ ` o
.
O I B C W B F h
~ c o j
HP CB\BE^HP@OL DECE$DB^@OGH
@HBCW^OJ I^OCGB@OPWOCABE^O GB ]B^O
gb Fhoqred No~owoWbjblhcb >0< 70> 751
O i b c
w b g h
F h ~ c o
j . O @ h d o ~ ` o
.
BCW^B\EPWBCW^B\EPWBCW^B\EPWBCW^B\EPWBCW^B\EPWOOOOO?==1#=7#=2=9
gb Do~h gb >==1#O @HJONH^OGH^O GB\EGODBCWB ORWH^EVOGO*
Do~eo Abjbco Wbe be~o Do~qrbp Qo|eb~ C 0?< gb >==1
@O^W^EH CHWO^EOJ GO PB^WGB WB^BPO \OJBCWECO POCWHP
FRPWELE@OH@b~wele`h qrb }h~ bp`~ewr~o gb w~ecwo b rd gb Do~h gb
ghep dej b h Chwo~eoj go Pb~w gb Wb~bpo \ojbcweco @~epw|h Pocwhp*
jo|~ogo gb lhb qrow~h o lhjaop `bcwh b qro~bcwo b `ec`h |b~ph* gh
je|~h gb chwop }ge|b~pop cdb~h qro~bcwo b `ec`h L* `hd}o~b`b~od6FHP
LB^COCGBP \OV b drjab~ GECO ]ORJO ABC^E_RBP \OV* `opogh~biedb go
hdrcah ib~oj gb nbcp* cowr~oep bjb go l~birbpeo gb @od}bjh*Leirbe~
ghp \ecahp b bjo go l~birbpeo go Pocwo Frpwo* hc`bja h gb Jepnho*
~bpegbcwbp co ro gh No~h* cdb~h ?>=90* hdepph co @hcpb~|ow~eo gh
biepwh ]~ghp \ecahp#_rb bjbp frpwele`ocwbp }hpprbd bd chdb }~}~eh h
~blb~egh }~geh r~noch|b`bcwhp b hewbcwo b `ec`h* }h~ `hd}~o
db~odbcwb |b~noj o Od~e`h gPocwhp* b drjab~ Or~ecgo gh @o~dh ghp
Pocwhp* ~bpegbcwbp bd Ojib* @ghp \ecahp* `rfh wwrjh ch gep}bd#_rb
bjbp frpwele`ocwbp }hpprbd bd chdb }~}~eh h ~blb~egh }~geh
~pch|b`bcwhp b hewbcwo b ghep* }h~ `hd}~o db~odbcwb |b~noj o Ocwceh
@drjab~ Gbjleco go @hc`beh hpo* ~bpegbcwbp co ro G~# Fhh gb No~~
}~edbe~h bpqrb~gh* Jepnho* `rfh w wrjh ch gep }bd#$$$$$Bpw
`hclh~db#
@o~w~eh Chwo~eoj go Pb~w* 0? gb Do~h gb >==1#O @HJONH^OGH^O
GB\EGODBCWB ORWH^EVOGO*
Do~eo Abjbco Wbe be~o Do~qrbp Qo|eb~ C 0?< gb >==1
@O^W^EH CHWO^EOJ GH @HC@BJAH GB ]BG^IH I^OCGB FRPWELE@O H
CHWO^EOJ
@B^WELE@H* qrb }h~ bp`~ewr~o gb >1 gb Do~h gb >==1*
jo|~oglhjaop 97 gh je|~h cdb~h 75$@* }o~o bp`~ewr~op ge|b~p op* gh
@o~gb ]bg~ih I~ocgb* o `o~ih go Chw~eo Ecwb~eco* @jrgeo Do~epIo~`eo
]bpwoco ghp Pocwhp#
DOCRBJ DO^EO FBPRP OJDBEGO*cowr~oj go l~birbpeo go I~oo* hcgb
]bg~ih I~ocgb* b drjab~ BJEPO GO @HC@BEH LO^ECAO OJDBEcowr~oj go
l~birbpeo b `hc`bjah gb Le irbe~ ghp \ecahp* hcgb ~bpegbgb Ah~wo gh
Joio~* `opoghp phn h ~biedb go `hdrcah gb ogqre~egh`hcw~enrecwbp
lep`oep* ~bp}b`we|odbcwb* cdb~hp ?0> 910 719 b wewrjo~bp ghp
Nejabwbp gb Egbcwegogbp* ~bp}b`we|odbcwb* cbdewegh bd
>9(=>(>==0 b 775771?* bdewegh bd >0(=2(>==> *
odnhpJbe~eo# XXXX Frpwele`o~od o pro }hppb* }h~ rpr`o}eh* }h~ ch
}hppr~bd wwrjhghp pbirecwbp }~gehp* pewroghp col~birbpeo b `hc`bjah
gb ]bg~ih I~ocgb^PWE@H*pewh bd\ojb go Lb~wo*l~birbpeo
goI~oo*`hc`bjah gb]bg~ihI~ocgb* `hd}hpwh gb }ecaoj* `hd o ~bo gbdej
qrow~h`bcwhp b `ecqrbdbw~hp qrog~oghp*o hcl~hcwo~ gh ch~wb b
cop`bcwb hd Ojnoch @hbjgh prj `hd Ogbjech @hbjah Crcbp b gh }hbcwb
`hd Fhp gb Ojdbegoecp`~ewh co dow~ev phn ho~weih >=9?*`hd h
|ojh~ }ow~edhceoj b ow~enrg009*27# XXX _rb h }~geh pb bc`hcw~o
ecp`~ewh co dow~ev bd chdb gb qrbd hp frpweogqre~e~od* b oecgo ch
pb bc`hcw~o ~biepwogh co @hcpb~|ow~eo ]~bgeoj gb ]bg~ih I~ocgb#_rb
h ~blb~egh }~geh |beh pro }hppb* a doep gb |ecwb ochp* }hdb~odbcwb
|b~noj* lbewo bd geo b dp qrb ch }hgb }~b`epo~ }h~ |hjwdej
ch|b`bcwhp b hewbcwo b pbwb* o Jenceh ghp ]~ovb~bp Fhp* phjqrb lhe
ch jrio~ gb @h|oep* I~oo* ]bg~ih I~ocgb#O |b~gogb }h~d qrb o }o~we~
go ~blb~ego oqrepeh* }hpprbd h d }~ geh *wbcgh pbd}~b b gbpgb
o*`rjwe|ogh* odocaogh b }oih gbpgb pbd}~~bp}b`we|op `hcw~enrebp*
}hppb qrb lhe pbd}~b b b~`ego }h~ bjb`hcpegb~o~ woj }~geh `hdh pbr*
pbd ecwb~~r}h* ecw~hdepph h
qrbd qrb~ qrb lhppb* rprl~recgh$h b ~bwe~ocgh gbjb whgh h
~bcgeddbpdh jabp eo }~h}e`eocgh |epwo gb whgo o ibcwb gh jrio~ b gb
hrw~vecahp* pbd}~b co `hc|e`h gb b b~`b~ rd ge~bewh }~}~eh phn~b `h
XXXXXXXXXX _rb bpw o }h ppb opp ed b b~ `eg o o h j hci h g b d oep
gbgb|b `hcpegb~o~ }nje`o* }o`le`o b `hcwcro#_rb* }h~ woj dhwe|h b
drewh bdnh~o ch }hppod b ene~ h ~bp}b`weoqrepeh* bd |e~wrgb gh
|bcgbgh~ f wb~ lojb`egh* h `b~wh qrb hp ogqre~e~od h dbc`ehcogh
}~geh }h~ RPR@O]EH*orpo bpwo gb ogqre~ech }hgbd `hd}~h|o~ }bjhp
dbehp b w~ofrge`eoep ch~doep#Bpw hclh~db#@o~w~eh Chwo~eoj gb ]bg~ih
I~ocgb* >1 gb Do~h gb >==1#
O Ofrgocwb*!Oego ghp ]~ovb~bp Lb~cocgbp I~ejh% C 0?< gb
>==1#
CHWO^EOGH ]H^WRIRP@O^W^EH CHWO^EOJ GB LEIRBE^ GHP \ECAHP
!O o~ih go @hcpb~|ogh~o bd b b~``eh gb lrcbp chwo~eoep* ]orjo
Do~eco@ojogh Hje|be~o Ojdbego Jh}bp%
@b~wele`h }o~o blbewhp gb }rnje`oh qrb* }h~ bp`~ewr~o gb ahfb*
jo|~ogo cbpwb @o~w~eh*ece`eogo o lhjaop `bcwh b w~ecwo b qrow~h gh
je|~h gb chwop }o~o bp`~ewr~op ge|b~popcdb~h pbwbcwo @* DOCRBJ GEOP
NO^OWO* b drjab~ EPEJGO POCWHP NBCWH*`opoghp phn h ~biedb go hdrcah
ib~oj gb nbcp* odnhp cowr~oep go l~birbpeo b hc`bjahgb ]bg~ih
I~ocgb* hcgb ~bpegbd ch jrio~ gb Jhr~e`be~o* @#L#p cdb~hp
?75#5=2#9==b ?9=#5>0#7?=* pb gb`jo~o~od b `jrph gb hrw~bd* ghchp
b jbiwedhp }hppregh~bp ghp }~gehp pbirecwbp* pewhp co l~b irbpeo b
`hc `bjah gb ]bg ~ih I ~ocgb6
RD $ ^PWE@H Pewh bd _REJABE^O* `hd}hpwh }h~ wb~~o gb `rjwr~o*
|egbe~op*l~rwbe~op* hje|be~op b }ecaoj* o hcl~hcwo~ gh ch~wb hd
L~oc`ep`h Oj|bp* prj hd DocrbjGeop No~owo* cop`bcwb `hd Docrbj
Lb~cocgbp b gh }hbcwb `hd |eph* `hd o ~bo gb w~pdej b qrow~h`bcwhp
dbw~hp qrog~oghp* `hd h |ojh~ }ow~edhceoj gb 0?*?2 br~hp* oh
qrojow~enrbd h |ojh~ gb ch|b`bcwhp b hcvb br~hp* ecp`~ewh co dow~ev
bd chdb gb Gehcejgbgo @hc`beh Dh~be~o phn h o~weih ??#152* hdepph
co @hcpb~|ow~eo gh ^biepwh ]~bgeojgb ]bg~ih I~ocgb#
GHEP $ PWE@H Pewh bd @HPWO GH \OJB* hd}hpwh }h~ wb~~bch hd
hje|be~op*o `hcl~hcwo~ gh ch~wb `hd Docrbj Lb~cocgbp Doeh~`o* prj
`hd bpw~ogo* cop`bcwb `hdDocrbj Geop No~owo b gh }hbcwb `hd Ocwceh
Geop Fceh~* `hd o ~bo gb ch|bcwodbw~hp qrog~oghp* hd h |ojh~
}ow~edhceoj gb =*1= br~hp* oh qroj ow~enrbd h |ojh~ gb|ecwb br~hp*
ecp`~ewh co dow~ev bd chdb gb Gehcejgb go @hc`beh Dh~be~o phn
ho~weih ?0#7?>* hdepph co dbpdo @hcpb~|ow~eo#
W^P $ ^PWE@H Pewh bd \OJB GH @H\BE^H* `hd}hpwh }h~ wb~~o gb
`rjwr~o`hd hje|be~op b |egbe~op* o `hcl~hcwo~ gh ch~wb `hd Ocwceh
Geop Fceh~* prj `hdDocrbj Ocwrcbp Odogh* cop`bcwb b }hbcwb `hd
|eph* `hd o ~bo gb dej qrow~h`bcwhpb gbv dbw~hp qrog~oghp* `hd h
|ojh~ }ow~edhceoj gb ?0*2= br~hp* oh qroj ow~enrbd h|ojh~ gb
w~bvbcwhp b ch|bcwo b w~p br~hp* ecp`~ewh co dow~ev bd chdb gb
Gehcejgb go@hc`beh Dh~be~o phn h o~weih ?0#9>2* hdepph co dbpdo
@hcpb~|ow~eo#
Hp ~blb~eghp }~gehp |eb~od }hppb gbjbp frpwele`ocwbp* }h~ `hd}~o
ch wewrjogoqrb }h~ |hjwo gh och gb dej ch|b`bcwhp b hewbcwo b ghep*
levb~od ~blb~ego Gehcejgbgo @hc`beh Dh~be~o* |e|o* ~bpegbcwb
~blb~egh ch jrio~ gb Jhr~e`be~o#
_rb gbpgb bppo gowo* bjbp frpwele`ocwbp* `hdbo~od o }hppre~ hp
~blb~eghp }~gehpbd chdb }~}~eh b gr~ocwb doep gb |ecwb ochp* p bd o
dbch~ h}hpeh gb qrbd qrb~ qrbpbfo* gbpgb h ec`eh* }hppb qrb pbd}~b
b b~`b~od hpwbcpe|odbcwb* `hd h `hcab`edbcwhgb whgo o ibcwb gh
jrio~ }~owe`ocgh ~bewb~ogodbcwb o`whp aonewroep gb rd }~h}~ebw~eh
}jbch* `rjwe| ocgh op wb~~op * `regoc gh gop woc`ao p* b w~oe cgh
gh }~geh whgop oprwejegogbp ecb~bcwbp pro cowr~bvo* o|e|ocgh op
bpw~bdop* }bjh qrb pbcgh rdo }hppb }o`le`o* }n je`o* `hcwc ro b gb
nho l* gr~ocwb oqrbj b }b~hgh gb w bd}h* ogqre~e ~odhp ~blb~eghp
}~gehp }h~ rpr`o}eh#
Cbpwop `e~`rcpw c`eop* ed}hppene jewoghp bpwh bjbp* frpwele`o
cwbp* gb `hd}~h|o ~ }bjhp dbehp b w~ofrg e`eoep ch~doep* o oqrep eh
ghp ~blb~eghp }~ge hp* }o~o h blbewh gbhp ~biepwo~ o pbr lo|h~* co
`hd}bwbcwb @hcpb~|ow~eo gh ^biepwh ]~bgeoj#$ @hclb~egh bpw
`hclh~db#$ Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp* |ecwb b `ec`h gb Do~h gb ghep dej b
hewh#
H > Ofrgocwb*D~eh Fh~ib Jhr~h Dbgbe~hp C 0?< gb >
==1#=7#=>* pbircgh ge~bewh* l~birbpeo gb Ojip* `hc`bjah gb
Hbe~op* BGB@JO^O^OD6_rb ph ghchp* `hd b `jrph gb hrw~bd gh }~geh
r~noch* pewh bd @b~bfbe~o gh ]bg~h*l~birbpeo b hc`bjah gb ]bg~ih
I~ocgb* hd }hpwh gb opo gb rd }eph hd jhi~oghr~hocb h* hd o
pr}b~l`eb hnb~wo gb |ecwb |~irjo pbppbcwo b qrow~h dbw~hp
qrog~oghpb gbp`hnb~wo gb grvbcwhp dbw~hp qrog~oghp* o `hcl~hcwo~ gh
ch~wb* prj* cop`bcwb b }hbcwb `hd h O~d ocgh go @hc`be h Ocwrcbp Go
|eg* ecp`~ewh c o dow~ev phn h o~ weih0592* hdepph co @hcpb~|ow~eo
gh ^biepwh ]~bgeoj gb ]bg~ih I~ocgb#_rb }hpprbd bd chdb }~}~eh h
~blb~egh }~geh gbpgb dej ch|b`bcwhp b hewbcwo bghep* }h~ ghoh
|b~noj Fhoqred Do~eo b drjab~ Do~eo go Bc`o~coh gop
Cb|bp*~bpegbcwbp qrb ch jrio~ gb \ojb gh No~`h* l~birbpeo b
`hc`bjah gb ]bg~ih I~ocgb*`rfh wwrjh ch gep}bd#Bpw `hclh~db#
@o~w~eh Chwo~eoj go Pb~w* >2 gb Do~h gb >==1#O
@HJONH^OGH^O GB\EGODBCWB ORWH^EVOGO*
Do~eo Abjbco Wbe be~o Do~qrbp Qo|eb~ C 0?< gb > ==1#=7#=
gb Do~h* lh~od }~bpwoghp whghp hp bp`jo~b`edbcwhpphje`ewoghp ch
}~ovh jbioj }~b|epwh }o~o h blbewh* wbcgh hp dbpdhppegh frcwhp p
}bop }owbcwbp bd `hc`r~ph b `hdrce`oghp o whghp hpogqre~bcwbp gop
}bop hc`r~poep ~bjowe|odbcwb oh @hc`r~ph ]nje`hgo bd}~bewogo
O^^BJ\ODBCWH PECWWE@H @OD]HDRCE@E]OJ GB P# DOWBRP* rfh o|eph gb
onb~wr~o lhe }rnje`oghch Ge~eh go ^b}rnje`o > p~eb* c# 7?* gb
>9 gb Lb|b~be~h gb >==1#
]bg~ih I~ocgb* >= gb Do~h gb >==1#H ]^BPEGBCWB GO @DO^O
DRCE@E]OJ*Fhh Docrbj Ihdbp Do~qrbp C 0?< gb >==1#=7#= gb
Do~h* lhe }~h~~hiogh h }~ovh }o~o o}~bpbcwohgop }~h}hpwop oh
@hc`r~ph ]nje`h go bd}~bewogoO^^BJ\ODBCWH PECWWE@H @OD]H DRCE@E]OJ
GBP# DOWBRP* ow p ?< Ah~op gh geo ?1 gb On~ej gb >==1* b qrb
ho`wh }nje`h gb onb~wr~o gop }~h}hpwop wb~ jrio~ ch geo >? gb
On~ejgb >==1* p ?= Ah~op* ch Pojh Chn~b go @do~o Drce`e}oj#Gbpwo
gb`jo~oh lhe cbpwo gowo bc|eogh occ`eh ~b`wele`owe|h }o~o hGe~eh go
^b}rnje`o* ># P~eb#
]bg~ih I~ocgb* >1 gb Do~h gb >==1#
H ]^BPEGBCWB GO @DO^O DRCE@E]OJ*Fhh Docrbj Ihdbp Do~qrbp C
0?< gb >==1#=7#=>* gh Gb`~bwh Jbe c 222(55 gb ?< gb
Gbvbdn~h* `hd o ~bgo`hgogo }bjh Gb`~bwh Jbe c ?991>==? gb =7 gb
Frcah* qrb bpw ogb`h~~b~* }h~ rd }b~ehgh gb ?2 geop* o gep`rpph
}nje`o ~bjowe|o oh
}~hfb`wh gb ojwb~oh oh jhwbodbcwh* pewh bd @o~odbjbe~h*
L~birbpeob @hc`bjah gb Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp wewrjogh }bjh oj|o~ c
=?(>==0bdewegh bd chdb gb Bcoio Ph`ebgogb gb @hcpw~rbp* Jgo#* o
qrojlhe ~bqrb~ego }h~ Do~`h Arih go @hpwo gocwop cibjh b Do~eo
gbJr~gbp gb Ph Fhh cibjh* ~bpegbcwbp ch Jodbe~h* jhwb 5* L~birbpeob
@hc`bjah gb Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp* qrb pb bc`hcw~o }o~o o}~h|ohcbpwo
@do~o Drce`e}oj b qrb `hcpepwb co ojwb~oh oh jhwb 5 bd6
$ Ordbcwh go ~bo gb ed}jocwoh }o~o ?;== b op ?7;== ah~op $ ?==1H
]^BPEGBCWB GO @DO^O DRCE@E]OJ*
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX !^re Docrbj gb Ojdbego b
Pej|o%
C 0?< gb >==1#=7#===1#=7#===1#=7#=<
?5@HJONH^OBP@HJONH^OBP@HJONH^OBP@HJONH^OBP@HJONH^OBP
}h~ G~# Nbfo Poc
BGR@OH GH @HCPRDEGH^6 NHOP CHW
H]ECEHH]ECEH
G ^
# N B F O
P O C W H P
Gblbcgb~* }~hdh|b~* ~bp}hcponejevo~O bgr`oh gh hcprdegh~ !B@%
b~o ow a }hr`h
wbd}h peccedh gb bgr`oh }o~o h nhd hcprdh#]h~ nhd hcprdh
bcwbcgeo$pb oqrbjb qrb gb`egegh`hd ~ew~eh* co nho ~bjoh
qrojegogb(}~bh* pbd~ep`h }o~o o pogb hr }o~o o |ego ghdpwe`o# H
qrbb~o `~ew~eh* qroj o bppc`eo go qrojegogb(}~bh*qroep hp hrw~hp
~ep`hp !phn~bwrgh }o~o hp hrw~hp%qrb jb|ocwo h hcprdh qrb }o~o cp
ec`rh* b~odqrbpwbp qrb ch pb }rcaod# H qrb ecwb~bppo|o b~oo
hd}bwc`eo w`ce`o* h ponb~ oie~ ch db~`ogh gbo`h~gh hd op jbep gh
}~}~eh db~`ogh#
Bpwo bgr`oh }o~o h `hcprdh nopbo|o$pb chponb~ wb~* ch
hcab`edbcwhp ghp ge~bewhp* gbpgb oeclh~doh }bjo ~hwrjoibd* o
cowr~bvo ghp hcw~owhpow h~~b`wo w~ocpo`h hr ponb~ jeweio~# Ch
lecgh* }~b}o~o|o$pb hp fh|bcp b hp ogrjwhp }o~o `hcprde~
wb`ce`odbcwb nbd gb o`h~gh hd hp |ojh~bp ghde$cocwbp* gb o`h~gh hd
h w~erclh go }bppho* h pr`bpphgh ecge|grh* h d edh ghdecogh~ hdrd
gh rphwb`chjie`h b gh nbd$bpwo~#
O ae}b~bp`hjao b h ae}b~`hcprdh* o ijhnojevohb h }o~ogeido
geiewoj ojwb~o~od wrgh# eco`bew|bjbgr`o~ }o~o rd hcprdh qrb pb
wh~chr rd led pr$ }~bdh qrb r~ib bjhieo~ b }~hdh|b~# _rbd iocao`hd
bpwo o}~bcgevoibd h o``ehcepwo* h bp}b`eojepwogb do~kbweci* h
`hd}~ogh~ ed}jo`o|bjdbcwb `oj`r$jepwo# Oh bgr`o~$pb }o~o o
onrcgc`eo* }~bwbcgb$pbqrb h ecge|grh poeno dochn~o~ co bp`hjao
}~hlrpo }orwogo }bjo irb~~o ghp }~bhp b }bjh oirejah go`hc`h~~c`eo#
Bgr`o$pb }o~o hcab`b~ op hdrce`o$bp hdb~`eoep* }o~o |eprojevo~ o
}rnje`egogb hdo ech`c`eo qrb hp ocrc`eocwbp }~bwbcgbd* b ojwocgho
ecge|egrojevoh gh wr~nhdb~`ogh#
O B@ ahfb hcpbcprojdbcwb ogdewego hdh h }~h`bpph gb wh~co~ h
egogh `hcprdegh~ doep ~bp$
}hcp|bj }bjop prop bp`hjaop ch db~`ogh gb `hcpr$dh# Ch rdo
bgr`oh }o~o hp ge~bewhp dop }o~ohp ge~bewhp b ~bp}hcponejegogbp# Ch
pb gedecre h pbc$wegh gb qrb h hcprdegh~ gb|b }hgb~ hd}o~o~ h
qrb`hd}~o* hcab`b~ op ~bi~op b ow hp ge~bewhp bd dow$~eo odnebcwoj
hr bd }~h}~ebgogb ecwbjb`wroj* bqro`ehco$pb o egogoceo hd o
o}~bcgevoibd gb rd hcprdh~bp}hcp|bj !o jenb~gogb gb bp`hjao wodnd
pecce$dh gh rph ~bp}hcp|bj* go phjego~ebgogb hd qrbd }~hgrv* gh
hcab`edbcwh ghp ~b`r~php* wb~ }~bh`r$ }oh hd hp ge~bewhp ph`eoep b
ardo$chp gb wrgh qrocwh pb }~hgrv*pb w~ocplh~do b pb o}~bpbcwo
oh`hcprdegh~%# ]o~o hp ih|b~chpb }o~o hp bd}~bp~ehp o }~eh~ego$gb
b`hcde`o h }hgb~ gb hd$ }~o* h fhih ghp }~bhp qrb }b~$dewb ohp
hcprdegh~bp bp}b|ewo~ o hd}bwewe|egogb b o hd}bwehchp db~`oghp gb
nbcp b pb~|ehp#
Cbpwo h~gbd gb egbeop* nhobgr`oh dbge~ op hcpbqrc$`eop*
`hcw~o~eocgh o bgr`oh }o~o h `hcprdh qrb o gbpbgr$`oh qrb bpwedrjo
h wb~ pbd`hcpegb~o~ h pb~#
H `hcprdh* bcw~b h bppbc`eoj b h pr}~ljrh Co bgr`oh }o~o h
`hcprdh co ao|eo o hn~eioh
gb gep`rwe~ b w~ocpdewe~ h pbcwegh b hp |ojh~bp go ph$`ebgogb gb
hcprdh# H lh~dogh~ dh~ojevo|o phn~bo `hdego* o }rnje`egogb* o dhgo*
h `hd}~o~ nbd*pbd bpwonbjb`b~ cb h bcw~b h hcprdh b h dbeh
e~$`rcgocwb* pbd }~ bd orpo o chppo egbcwegogb ch`hcprdh# _rocgh
hd}~odhp* phdhp ow~oghp }bjh }~bpwieh b }bjh bpwowrwh* o dqreco go
pbgrh }hgb
lojo~ bd lbje`egogb hr }~ovb~ go o`rdrjoh# Bgr`o$pb }o~o rdo
jbewr~o bpwwe`o ghp hnfb`whp gep}hc$|bep* pbd ecwb~~hio~ o jeioh
goqrbjb hnfb`wh b hchpph `hclh~wh blb`we|h# H qrb ecwb~bppo qrb
brpoeno bp`hjab~ h dbr orwhd|bj* ch }oppo }h~ qrbpwehco~ pb whghp
we|bppbd |eowr~o }h~ hcgb ocgo$~eo h }jocbwo#
Co B@ ch pb bgr`o }o~o h gbpbfh go }hppb* h`hcprdh ch rd o`wh
ephjogh ghp chpphp hd}h~$wodbcwhp# O B@ }b~dewb ojo~io~ bp}oh pbd
onhje~
hp jedewbp* bcpeco$pb h fh|bd o`hcab`b~ op prop cb`bppegogbpb
ponb~ dbge~ op prop ~bp}hc$ponejegogbp# O B@ wh~co hd$ }~bbcp|bj
qrb h hcprdh ch* bd pe }~}~eh* rd nbd hrdoj* ph op bp`hjaop qrb
chpwh~co je|~bp hr bp`~o|hp#
O B@ bpw gep}hc|bj }o~o opbp`hjop b hp pbrp gbpolehp
bd~b`hc`ejeo~ h pb~ b h wb~#\odhp p lojo~ gb dowb~eoep i~o$wrewhp*
gb o`bppenejegogb edbge$owo# H lh~dogh~ |oe oh pewb ghDecepw~eh gb
Bgr`oh b }~h$
`r~o co Ge~b`h$Ib~oj gb Ech|oh b Gbpbc|hj|e$dbcwh @r~~e`rjo~ h
Ireh gb Bgr`oh gh @hcpr$degh~* qrb lov }o~wb go hjb`h Bgr`oh }o~o
o@egogoceo# O bc`hcw~o~* }h~ b bd}jh* gblecebp`hdh o bp`hjao rd
dhdbcwh gb ~bp}hcponejegogbwocwh }o~o h ecge|grh hdh }o~o o
hjb`we|egogb* h`egogh hcprdegh~ qrbpwehco o ~bp}hcponejegogbgh
}~hgrwh~* hp gelb~bcwbp }~hnjbdop odnebcwoep bo o|b~eiroh go
hnpb~|c`eo ghp ge~bewhp ardochpco `ogbeo gb }~hgrh* gepw~enreh b
`hcprdh#_rocwh p hd}bwc`eop* bp}b~o$pb qrb h ojrch le$
qrb aonejewogh }o~o6 o hcpw~rh b o whdogo c`eo go egbcwegogb
}bpphoj b ph`eoj; o }o~w|ego `|e`o gb lh~do ~bp}hcp|bj* phjeg~eo b
`~~bp}bewh b o |ojh~evoh go ge|b~$pegogb ghp eb ghop i~r}hp qrocwh
p prop }b~wbcop b h}`hcpw~rh gb rdo hcp`ec`eo b`hjie`o
hcgr`bc|ojh~evoh b }~bpb~|oh gh }ow~edceh; h wrce|b~ph gh hcprdh*
gop owewrgbp gb orwhchdeo~oh b phjego~ebgogb# Gep}hc|bj bpw
eirojdbph }h~wrirbpo gh docroj go bgr`oh }o~o h hcpgh~ co orjo
bjonh~ogh }bjo bgb Br~h}beo gb Bggh @hcprdegh~ !pewb6
yyy#b$`hcp#cbw yyy#b$`hcp#cbw3%# Bpwb docroj wbd ghep h npe`hp }o~o
o bgr`oh6 `hcw~enre~ }o~o o lecwbi~oj ghp ojrchp* lh~docgh$hp
bcqrocwh hgh~bp; b hcw~enre~ }o~o o pro lh~doh }~h}qrb jabp
}b~dewe~ hcwecro~ rdo lh~doh ohgb whgo o |ego# ]o~o hcab`b~ h
db~`ogh* o B@ }
nd `hcwo~ `hd h pewb gh GHJ@BWO !yyy# ghbr(}h~wrioj
:aww}6((yyy#ghj`bwo#br(}h~wGHJ@BWO h o`~cedh gb Gb|bjh}dbcw hl
H@hcprdb~ Bgr`owehc Whhjp Lh~ Ogrjwp* ch lrlb~~odbcwo ecwb~o`we|o
}o~o o lh~doh ghp h~bp* on~ocibcgh fh|bcp b ogrjwhp* o
lh~doh(ovoibd }h~ lh~dogh~ nbd hdh o orwhlh~doh#GHJ@BWO bc`hcw~o~
ghep dgrjhp* h ghp ghp hcprdegh~bp b h ghp pb~|ehp lecoc`be~h
Ph nhop chw`eop }o~o hp lh~dogh~bp# Bc`hc|d ch bpqrb`b~ qrb hp
}~hlbpph~bp gep}bhrw~op lb~~odbcwop# ]h~ b bd}jh* o Ge~b`gh
@hcprdegh~ }hgb }~h}e`eo~ dowb~eoj ephn~b o B@* bgr`oh ojedbcwo~*
pogb b pbbw`# Hp @EO@ !@bcw~hp gb Eclh~doh Ooh @hcprdegh~% gep}bd
gb w`ce`hp qrb o}heo~ op o`bp gb lh~doh# Oih~o* ~bpwoopdh gb qrbd
pb |oe joco~ co B@#
]H^ _RB POJOVO^ CH ]B^DEWER _RB PB EC\H@OPPB GBRP
CO@HCPWEWREH8
D^EHDBCGBP^HPO@hcpbjabe~hgbH~ebcwoh
]~hleppehcoj
Ch wbd}h bd qrb op chw`eop b~od `ho~`wogop }h~ lejw~hp nbd
o}b~woghp b }eh~ oecgo ch wbd}hbd qrb ~o~odbcwb pb jeo h Ge~eh gop
Pbppbp|~ehpopprcwhp gb i~ocgb i~o|egogb p b~od hcab`eghp }h~
bp`oppo dech~eo gb }h~wrirbpbp#
Bpw cbpwb oph* o ec|h`oh gh Chdb go Gbrp*ch }~bdnrjh go
@hcpwewreh* rfo hdepph gbe o*oecgo ahfb nhqreonb~wh hp }b~ewhp bd
opprcwhpb`jbpepwe`hp#
Lhe Pojovo~ h orwh~ gbppo lodeib~ogo @hcpwewre$h* jbw~o }h~
jbw~o# Whgh h pbr `hcfrcwh go prob `jrpe|o ~bp}hcponejegogb# ]h~
epph o dhh coO#^# }o~o pro ec`jrph* bpwo|o `hcgbcogo oh l~o$`opph#
Bcwh* wbcgh bjb gb`egegh jhih ch ec`eh go~$jab bpwo h~ebcwoh* e~eo
co ojwr~o* bd On~ej gb ?525bdbcgo~ hr ogo}wo~ lhppb h qrb lhppb#
Epph crc`o/Ow }h~qrb pbircgh h Gr`b* h Pneh crc`o b~~o#Oih~o
bdbcgo~ o dh pbfo ch qrb pbfo* peicele`o qrb`hdbwbr rd bcioch* hr
qrb ~bw~h`bgbr#
Wodnd ch gb }hgb lojo~ gb d eclh~doh chop}b`wh ~bjeiehph#
Pojovo~* hd h @r~ph @hd}jbwhgb Wbhjhieo gh Pbdec~eh gb \epbr gb|eo
wb~ o hcp$`ec`eo }jbco gh qrb peicele`o* b ghp ~bljb hp ph`eoep*
}h~ ch ec`jre~ h Chdb gb Gbrp co @hcpwewreh#
Pojovo~ gb|eo ponb~ }bjo Aepw~eo qrb o }~edbe~o@hcpwewreh bp
~ewo ch chpph }op ec|h`o|o hchdb go Pocwppedo W~ecgogb* crd
odnebcwb gbi~ocgb ahpwejegogb Ei~bfo#
Ch bcwocwh* o pewroh bd qrb pb |e|eo co ojwr~obd ]h~wrioj b~o
}o~we`rjo~dbcwb lo|h~|bj6 pbdH}hpeh b i~oppo|o oecgo }h~ whgh h
jogh o r~bogh Dejoi~b gop @hcwop Pojgogop# Cbppo ojwr~o* h }h|h
lo~eo h qrb Pojovo~ gbwb~decoppb#
Dop `hcab`bcgh nbd h wbd}b~odbcwh b h`o~`wb~ gb Pojovo~ b~o gb
bp}b~o~ wrgh epwh
O pro |bjao w`we`o b~o ch ecwb~|e~ jhih# Gbe o~ `h~~b~ op hepop#
B co h`opeh h}h~wrco }r o~ hdlh~o o o~dogejao qrb wecao }~b|eodbcwb
}~b}o~ogh#
Dop |hjwocgh Dhh ch b~o rdo docelbpwohd~nego gb jb~e`ojepdh* b~o
ocwbp rd }jegh ~bljb hgop @hcpwewrebp ogo}wogop coqrbjb wbd}h }h~
drewop Cobp#
Ch ao|eo qrojqrb~ ~b`beh gb pb~ `hcpegb~ogh~bw~i~ogh hr
gbpo`wrojevogh
Ch pbcwer bppo gele`rjgogb o pr}b~$gbdh`~we`oOd~e`o oh
bpwonbjb`b~ h geo
Co`ehcoj go H~oh# Ch op wb|b o Ecijowb~~oqrb lbv ocwo~ bd whghp
hp pbrp ghdcehp h Ihg
Po|b Wab _rbbcRdop |bvbp o ec|h`oh lov$pb gb rdo lh~do
ped}jbp# ]h~ b bd}jh#Bd chdb gb Gbrp whgh }hgb~hph#
h oph gop @hcpwewrebp gh @aejb bd ?5>2*goPreo b ?197 b ghp
ocwbp go @hclb~oh Abj|we`ogb L~enr~ih!?129%*Rcwb~yojg jb
Aocw!?5=>% Ar~e!?11
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
20/24
>==1#=7#==
NEDBCP^EH ^BIEHCOJEPWO]O^O HP @HC@BJAHP GB @OPWOCABE^O GB]B^O*
LEIRBE^ GHP \ECAHP* ]BG^IHI^OCGB* PB^W B ]OD]EJAHPO GO PB^^O
LE@AO W@CE@O
@hcw~enrecwb c# ?20 711 >22Gb}pewh Jbioj c# 72#>9>(5? $
C# gb ^biepwh ?>0#?15 ch E@P
WE^OIBD DGEO6 0?02951?9
B$DOEJch}7715>Mdoej#wbjb}o`#}w
GBJBIOH( BGO@H BD ]BG^IH I OCGBPo~ghojIbpw Wbj#6 >0<
71< =17
0>9= $ ?=? Gb|bpo $ ]bg~ih I~ocgb
@HH^GBCOH B PB@^BWO^EOGHBj|e~o ]e~bp Wbe be~o* Pocg~o Pedbp*
@o~jhp Pocwhp
DO_RBWOIBD* ]OIECOHO @hdo~`o $ @o~jhp Pocwhp#
]JOPWELE@OH* BQ]BGEH B ED]^BPPHNbe~opwb wh $ Ph`ebgogb Bgewh~o*
P#O# $ Wo|be~h $ @HEDN^O
P@EHP LRCGOGH^BP GB6Lrcgoh \op`h go Iodo !Jepnho%* @jrnb
@bcw~hO|bcwr~o
!Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp%; @bcw~h A}e`h gb Leirbe~ ghp \ecahpb @hdew
Ecwb~co`ehcoj gb Phjego~ebgogb }o~o hd Wedh~
GE]JHDOP* DBGOJAOP B \HWHP GB JHR\H^@opo gh ]h|h gb Leirbe~ ghp
\ecahp; Nhdnbe~hp \hjrcw~ehp gb]bg~ih I~ocgb; @do~o Drce`e}oj gb
@opwocabe~o gb ]b~o;@do~o Drce`e}oj gb ]bg~ih I~ocgb; Frcwo gb L
~birbpeo gh@hbcw~oj I~ocgb; Frcwo gb L~birbpeo gb @opwocabe~o gb
]b~o;Frcwo gb L~birbpeo gb ]bg~ih I~ocgb; @bcw~h @rjwr~oj gbLeirbe~
ghp \ecahp; @hdepph Dbjah~odbcwhp go B~|egbe~o !]bg#I~ocgb%; Opph`#
^b`# @rjwr~oj go Gb~~bogo @edbe~o!]bg#I~ocgb%; @hdepph Gecodevogh~o
gop @hdbdh~obp E@bcwbc~eh go Lhcwb gop Ne`op !@hbcw~oj%; @bcle`o}b
$ @bcw~hLh~doh gh Vvb~b !@]* L\* ]I%; @egogb gb Jbedbc $
Ojbdocao;^hwo~u @jrnb gb @opwocabe~o gb ]b~o; @hdepph gb
Dbjahodbcwhp(@hdepph gb Lbpwop gb @opwocabe~o gb Leirbe~; Odeihp
gopIbpwhpop; B wbcph Bgr`owe|o gb Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp; @opo gb]bg~ih
I~ocgb# WYH @HDDRCE@OWEHCP Jhcg~bp $ Ecijowb~~o
Dbdn~hp go
AHDBCOIBCP ]NJE@OP@hd# Dbjah~odbcwhp B~|egbe~o
!]#I~ocgb%$2(=0(52 b 5(0(?559
@bcw~h @rjwr~oj gb Leirbe~ ghp \ecahp $>2(=0(52^hwo~u @jrnb
gb @opwocabe~o gb ]b~o $?9(=(=1(52G~# B~cbpwh Do~~b`o Go|eg
$>1(=
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
21/24
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
22/24
>==1#=7#=>
PH@EBGPH@EBGPH@EBGPH@EBGPH@EBGOGBOGBOGBOGBOGB
O]^BPBCWOH GO ^HPO @^RV B ]H^WRIOJ G
]H^WBJH0>0< 22? =Wjd6 5
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
23/24
-
8/6/2019 A Comarca, n. 316 (6 de abril de 2008)
24/24
>==1#=7#===1 jwedo }ieco
LJH^BPWOLbjevdbcwb hp chpphp nhdnbe~hp ph od}bbp co |eiejc`eo
ljh$
~bpwo !b oecgo a qrbd ~biowbeb o}heh ~b`hjao gb lrcghp qrb
ocgodo lovb~%; bpwodhp* }h~d* wbcaodhp hcp`ec`eo gepph* crdo vhco b
$ }jhpe|o# B go qrb* }o~o ~bljb h* w~ocp`~b|o gb rd nbjppedh o~weih
gb^ewo @o~|ojah* ch GC* o }~h}pewh gh Geo go ~|h~b bd qrb joc$ogo
rdo }ojo|~o gb h~gbd6 ljh~bpwo6 @rego~ bd |bv gb O~nh~evo~6
O lh~do hdh h ahdbd wbd ecwb~oiegh hd o ljh~bpwo ~b}~hgrv
opw~ocplh~dobp go }~}~eo ph`ebgogb# Bd wbd}h* h bp}oh ljh~bpwojb~o
hdrd* h`r}ogh* b pb~|eo op cb`bppegogbp go }h}rjoh* qrb jabow~enro
rd pbcwedbcwh gb }b~wbco# Cop jwedop g`ogop* h bc~ehdrghr# Dop h
bclhqrb p lhe ~bofrpwogh qrocgh hp }h~wrirbpbp }b~`bnb~od qrb h
onocghch ~r~oj b h gbph~gbcodbcwh ljh~bpwoj* ojeoghpo hrw~hp
}~hnjbdop* bpwo|od o w~ocplh~do~ o ljh~bpwo crd no~~ej gb }j|h~o#
Rdo ~bo ljh~bpwoj doj ib~ego ch rd nbd `hdrd# ]bjh`hcw~~eh* }hgb
wh~co~$pb rdo lh~wb odboo#
Cop jwedop g`ogop o~nh~evhr$pb dop h ahdbd lhe$pb bdnh~o
gopvhcop ~r~oep b gop ljh~bpwop* |hwocgh$op oh onocghch# B o~gbr
wrgh*b }je`hr oh GC Fhp Deirbj @o~ghph ]b~be~o# H }~hlbpph~ gh
EcpwewrwhPr}b~eh~ gb Oi~hchdeo jodbcwo qrb p opped wbcaodhp
hd}~bbcgeghh qrb }o~b`eo n|eh b f wecao pegh dhwe|h gb ojb~wo }h~
}o~wb gbw`ce`hp doep |epehc~ehp#
Oecgo prnpepwb o |eph oco`~ce`o gb qrb }jocwo~ rdo ~|h~b
nbcble`eo~ h wb~~ew~eh# H qrb ow rd }~b`hc`bewh gb
pr}b~eh~egogbdh~oj }b~ocwb o ljh~bpwo* gev @o~ghph ]b~be~o#
H wb~~ew~eh wbd }hwbc`eoj gb }~hgrh ljh~bpwoj b h ]op* qrb
gbpgbpbd}~b we~hr }o~wegh go ljh~bpwo* ahfb `hcwecro o lov$jh# Dop
hpec`cgehp ghp jwedhp ec`h ochp gbdhcpw~o~od qrb ch bpwodhp
o`hcpbire~ oirbcwo~ rd wb~h gh wb~~ew~eh hd ~bo ljh~bpwoj#
Cbjbdocgod dejao~bp gb }~h}~ebw~ehp* hd op}e~obp b dhwe|obp
drewhgelb~bcwbp* b o}ovbp gb ed}bge~ rdo ibpwh ao~dhcehpo#
Co ocjepb gbp`~ewo ch o~weih ole~dogo o cb`bppegogb gb rd
ogopw~hgo ljh~bpwo qrb }b~dewo rdo ibpwh gb `hcghdceh# @hd blbewh
}~b`eph rd w~onojah b orpwe|h }h~qrb ph dejao~bp gb }o~`bjop b gb
}~h}~ebw~ehp### b a gbp`hcleocop qrb wd gb pb~ pr}b~ogop#
O egbeo gb `~eo~ o leir~o jbioj gop vhcop gb ecwb~|bch
ljh~bpwoj!VEL% ch ]op f |bd gb >==2 b wbd }h~ hnfb`we|h
}~h}h~`ehco~ `hcgebp }o~o rdo ibpwh prpwbcw|bj b ojo~iogo go
ljh~bpwo* crdojie`o gb `hcghdceh#
Rd w~onojah gbdh~ogh* }o`ebcwb* b }h~ |bvbp qropb wh gel`ej`hdh
}~h`r~o~ rdo oirjao crd }ojabe~h#
Ab~gbe~hp gb wb~~op qrb a g`ogop |e|bd co egogb* eghphp qrb
fib~e~od h qrb pbr b oih~o ph ec`o}ovbp gb h lovb~* }o~o ojd
gbwbdb~bd bcw~bio~ o pro ibpwh o wb~`be~hp* ~biepwhp qrb pb
}b~gb~od bpb wh~cod drewh gel`bep gb ~b`r}b~o~#
B qrb b eib go }o~wb ghp }~h}~ebw~ehp o hcleoco gb qrb oh
ecwbi~o~ rdo ch }b~gbd }hgb~ phn~b h qrb pbr# Op }bpphop oecgo
bpwhdrewh oio~~ogop wb~~o b ch ~b`hcab`bd qrb ph ec`o}ovbp gb
oib~e~# Dop }~b`eph }~hwbi$jo gh lhih* ecwb~|ecgh* |eieocgh
bec|bpwecgh# Pb h w~onojah lh~ hdrd* h ~bprjwogh dbjah~#
Hnpb~|bd bcw~bwocwh h do}o onoe h bd qrb pb | o `hd}hpeh
goljh~bpwo co vhco @bcw~h hcgb chp ecpb~edhp6
Crdo g`ogo* bcw~b ?552 b >==2* o gedbcph go ljh~bpwo
docwb|b$pb }~owe`odbcwb bpw|bj# Dop o gep}b~ph gop bp}`ebp qrb pb
ojwb~hr#H }ecabe~h n~o|h ~bi~bger b h phn~be~h b h br`oje}wh
ordbcwo~od#
@BCW^H6
H Br`oje}wh b }ocger$pb rpwo go h`r}oh gh }ecaoj b gop
vhcopoi~`hjop* hd wrgh h qrb ~b}~bpbcwo gb dojle`h#
}h~ bpwop b }h~ hrw~op qrb ch }b~`bnbdhp !hr }b~`bnbd% }h~ qrb
pb gbewod lhirbwbp * }h~ qrb a rdo bd}~bpo ch pbe ghcgb* bdchdb gb
ch pbe gh qr* qrb |oe ec|bpwe~ ch pbe qrocwh hd h bcihghgb `~eo~ ch
pbe qrb qrocwegogb b qrojegogb gb }hpwhp gb w~onojah* oled gb
}jocwo~ br`oje}whp b lovb~ }o}bj/
]h~wrioj ghp }opbp gh drcgh hcgb o }b~`bcwoibd gb }~h}~ebgogb
}~e|ogo doep bjb|ogo6 51* 1" ghp qroep 50*7" }b~wbc`bd oecge|egroep
hr bd}~bpop b 2*7 " o `hdrcegogbp gb `hd}o~wbp gb
nojgehp#Bcqrocwh o|ocod b ch o|ocod op VEL !Vhcop gb
Ecwb~|bchLjh~bpwoj% gbe o o~gb~ qrb h dbr }oe nhdnbe~h#
\e|o h jo epdh/
B^^EH ]NJE@H@hdh ch chp }~bh`r}odhp `hd cecao~eop* a }b~ircwop
qrb
cecird lov6_rocwh `rpwo~od op gb Frjah* h ?> Bc`hcw~h gh
]h|hp
Pb~~ochp* w~ogeh bc~eqrb`bgh~o co o}~h edoh gop }h}rjobp goPb~~o
!@opwocabe~o gb ]b~o* Le irbe~ ghp \ecahp* ]bg~ih I~ocgb*De~ocgh gh
@h~|h* Jhrp b Iep b qrbd qrepb~ |e~%# H o}bjh bpwlbewh6 `ogo
}~hdhwh~ !O @hdo~`o* H W~b|ed* H De~ocwb b o@o}b~o~wb% }rnje`ewo~;
op Opph`eobp gb `ogo drce`}eh* ~oc`ahp`hc`b~wecbe~hp* dpe`hp
o}o~b`b~h i~owrewo b |hjrcw~eo bbcwrpeopwe`odbcwb#
Hp Nhdnbe~hp* o IC^ b hp Drce`}ehp ibcb~hpodbcwb hjonh~o~h#B h
}h|h8H }h|h |oe hd}o~b`b~ bd doppo hd h pbr lo~cbj b h pbr
o}bwewb
}o~o o }o~wejao l~owb~co#
55#= LDWbj#6 >0< 71< 2==
^GEH W^ECIRJH~bpwor~ocwb]OCH^ODO]OCH^ODOWR^ $ ^BPWOR^OH B
WR^EPDH* JGO#Wbj# >0< 22> ??2(22>>0< 22>119
& 0>9 LEI#ghp \ECAHP
bpwodhp wodnd bd6 N O ^ G O ] ^ O E O L J R \ E O J
G O P L ^ O I O P G B P
# P E D
H
$$$$$ BP]JBP]JBP]JBP]JBP]J OC OG O OC OG O OC OG O OC OG O OC OG
O (NO^ FO^GED(NO^ FO^GED(NO^ FO^GED(NO^ FO^GED(NO^ FO^GED
]BG^IHI^OCGB6
WHFBE^O6OPPH@EOH
]^HDH\B NOEJB
Ch }~ edh geo ?5gb On~ej o Opph`eohgb Dbjah~odbcwhp gbWhfbe~o*
]bphp b \ojb
gb Oj|o~bp }~hdh|bdoep rd `hc||eh copro Pbgb* o }o~we~
gop>?A0= ah~op* `hd o~bojevoh gb rd Noejb*on~ejaocwogh }bjhi~r}h
Ech|oh* goPb~w#
Ovecabe~o @o~|ojah ]ecabe~h Docph52(=< =2(=< 52(5<
=2(=< 52(5< =2(=9*= >21*7
