Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
!"" #
!"# $ $
$"# ! !"# %
&' !() *
*! !"#! +
+!,! !--"!(! $*
(.!'' (!
/
&
&0
!"#" $
% % &
'
( %
) *+,-#".
#"*# .
% %/
$ % %0
1 %
!2-
3 +,-#" %
,3(!44456,3,
3,7,8 %0 )
1 0
& %
3 1 %0 !"#"
) 0
% %
9 $
$
-: ;1
:1 :::% :
: : 0 1
:
- 0
0 : + 1:
:
: : :
- :1 ::
+,-#" :
#"1 3
: 1 ;9 8<*98<.
1 % ::
: : : : ! : ,
:: :
-+,-#"11 ; :
:,3(!44456,3,3,7,9 :;1
1 : 0 1
11
1
3 : 1 : #"
1, ::
: :
% : 1 :
9 : : 1;
0 :: 0
! "
#"
$ "
$ $
" !
!
%" $
&'()* "
! + *$
, -
!$ $
+ .
/!
! &'()*$ -
!! $
(%.0001(('(2(3 $
$ !
$ "
*
4 4
$ 5
6 $
$ !!
4
/
7
8
/ $ 7 9 8
: ;9 8
7 7 $ 8 $
( 9 <
! &'()* 7
8 * 7 7 ,
< - 7
$ 7 8 )
9 9
/-&'()* 7 $ 9
< $ (%.0001(('(2(/
- 7 9<
9 8 7
! 7 9 - 9" 7 9
.* 9 8
/ 7 < =
7 7
<
8 9
6
$$ $
!
" ! # $ $ % &
'! % $ %"!#
!
' % $ &$ !'
" %
'() *
' + , -.+,-/ )"
&.)"&/ 0
' ! +,-
$
1 + ! % & ! $ 23 !
$$4#'5
1 + "36 7 % +
$
'
'
1 8
* 7 ' #
8
!" #
!"#$!%!#$"&'(((
)#$*+,)-$. /-*+,)#-$& $.!##$-(
)#$*+,)'). /-*+,)#-$& $.!##$-(
)#$*+,)').*!%+0$--$.!1 2%!#-
!"#$!%!#$"3 )&!.#
)#$*+,)'). /-*+,)#-$& $.!##$-((((
#
$
%
%
#
#%
#&
#'
4
4 !"#$!%!#$"&'
45) .6*+,)#$7$/$6!
45) .6*+,)#$87/#$9$*:33*.$#6%6*(
45) .6*+,)#$)'89;)-68$<6
445) .6*+,)#$ !/!=*8):!>
4 !"#$!%!#$"3 )&!.#
?
@5
((
((
($
('
&%
&&
&'
))
)
*
#!" !"
(((((
A)#)#)-*$.$/)-5!/!)-(((
A)#)#)-B3!-)C)DE $
$$ .!/+,)#' %' 2!'$.3F !')-
/-G!*!##$#$3F !')-#$/F-D!&)-
$$ .!/+,)#' %' 2!'
/-G!*!##$#$3F !')-#$/F-.F:$!-
$$ .!/+,)#' %' 2!'
4 /-G!*!##$#$3F !')-').G -#!%)/!-(
? /-G!*!##$#$3F !')-(((((
? !"#$ /-D) .+,)((
?$$ .!/+,)#' %' 2!'
?$$ .!/+,)#)-.)#)-#$!/-G!*!##$(
5
'
'
'
%)
%
%
#
%
#
(
( +,-
4
4 (((((
4-)CF !')C/F-D!&)-$/F-.F:$!-(
4-)C)#$*+,)').$*$.$/)-#)!3)
4-)CF !')-').*!%+0$--$.!1 2%!#-
44-)4CF !')C""H$!.IJKLM
4?-)?CF !')C/F-D!&)-
45
$
&
#&
($
$
$&
$'
&%
*
$!"
?
?
?N IM
?$-' !+,)#-$- 66 -
?)#$*+,)$- 66 *
?$-6*#)-
?4N ?
?4$-' !+,)#$- 66
?4$-6*#)-
?4 !+,)#$$
?4O#$3!-)-#*=$I').: !+,)#$$M
?4O#$3!-)-#-*=$-$I').: !+,)#$$M
??N L
??$-' !+,)#$- 66
??$-6*#)-
?@5 (
&
&#
&)
&)
&'
)(
)
%#
&
(
(
'
#
&.// !,
@P
@ 5
#$
#
,0 + + ,
5Q 5 (
C (
!"
− #
− #$
− #% ! "
− #&# $#% &
− #'#% &
− #(# ' ()*+,,-
− #).+/ )*+,,-
%
&
)
)
*
*
$ +",-$%
− $# 0 +12& $&
− $#$ 314
− $#% 0
− $#&
− $#' +14
− $#(+15
− $#)1& 6
− $#*+1
− $#.+1 &
− $#/7&8
− $#( 6
− $#$+1
− $#%+1&
− $#&1 ' +1
− $#'+1&
− $#(31
%
&
'
)
.
$
$
$&
$'
%/
%
%$
%%
%)
%*
&'
− $#)31&
− $#*3119:9;
− $#.31<9:9;
− $#$/31= 9:
− $#$31>& 0
− $#$$311
− $#$%311
− $#$&31
− $#$'312$
− $#$(8
− $#$)? $@-&
− $#$* &6<
&(
&*
&.
''
(/
((
((
(*
)$
)%
)'
))
% ,-+",-
− %#?<<31
− %#$?<<31A
− %#%B& 0
− %#& 314
− %#'?3&
− %#(C#6 ?347DE
− %#)C#6 ?0
− %#*<2($
− %#.<2 @1$ +1$631
− %#/1 '2$ <
− %#F #%
− %#$1 & %&
− %#%AGC=3120 +1$0 +1
− %#&AGC=31 0 312$
− %#' +14
*&
*'
*'
*(
*(
*)
**
./
.
.
.&
..
//
/
/$
− %#( +1
− %#)0 20 0$0 006
− %#* 0 +106& &'
− %#. 0 +10
− %#$/ 0 +10066& &'
− %#$ 0 +1006
− %#$$ 0 +10066 6
− %#$% 0 +1 6
− %#$& 0 +1 6$ %&
− %#$'H 0 31
− %#$( 0 +106& &'
/%
/)
/*
/*
/*
/.
&
&
(
$/
$$
& 0!"1
− &# +14
− &#$F.3 +1.GC:C
− &#%F3 +17IC.C
− &#&F3 +17IC.C&
− &#' 0 @.'6$@JJ3
− &#( 0 @  0
− &#)& @K
− &#* 0 +120$006
− &#. 0 +10 ' &'
− &#/ 0 +1 %
− &# 0 0
− &#$ 0 +1006 ' &'
− &#% 0 +1 %
− &#& 0 006
− &#' L+,,F#6CL77
− &#('CL774 0
− &#)'CL770
$*
$.
%$
%$
%&
%'
%'
%(
%)
%.
&
&
&%
&'
&(
&)
&.
− &#*'CL77006
− &#. 0 +1& %&20$006
− &#$/ 0 31$8''#G@JM,
− &#$ 0 31$8''#G@JM,1 2 6$
− &#$$ 0 31& %&G0
− &#$% 0 310
'
'$
'(
'*
'*
'.
' ,-
− '#2< ?
− '#$2=
− '#%2<
− '#&C 6
− '#'4 31 0 $ 6
− '#( %0 +1$# 31
− '#)4 0 +1$& 6
− '#*4 0 31$ 6?
− '#.4 0 31$ 6?
− '#/ 0 +1
− '#1 & 6 7DL
− '#$ 0 31&7N3$LN3
− '#% 0 31@&7N3$LN3
− '#& 0 31+&7N3$LN3
− '#' 0 313&
− '#( 0 31+&.N+,+
− '#)@&? 7N3$LN3
− '#*+&? 7N3$LN3
− '#.3&? 7N3$LN3
− '#$/+&? LN3O
− '#$ 0 31
(&
('
('
('
()
(.
)/
)$
)%
)&
))
)*
).
*/
*
*$
*'
*(
*)
./
.%
− '#$$ 0 31 #
− '#$% 0 31 1&5
− '#$& 0 31 > ? 73
− '#$' 0 31 > ? 7+73
− '#$( 0 +10 31
− '#$)1 &
− '#$*> ? 31 6
− '#$.> ? 31 6λ
− '#%/> ? 31 6λ $λ+ $λ3
− '#%73> ? 6
− '#%$73> ? &O
− '#%%73> ? &-
− '#%&73> ? &3
− '#%'73> ? &+
− '#%(73> ? &@
− '#%)73> ? &,
− '#%* 0 73+
− '#%.73> ? 6
− '#&/73> ? &O
− '#&73> ? &-
− '#&$73> ? &3
− '#&%73> ? &+
− '#&&73> ? &@
− '#&'73> ? &,
− '#&(7+73> ? 6
− '#&) 0 7+73+
− '#&*
− '#&. 60 @,
− '#'/ 0 @,
− '#'1 &6
− '#'$ 0 6
.&
.'
.(
.(
.*
..
$//
$/
$/$
$/%
$/(
$/(
$/)
$/)
$/*
$/*
$/.
$/
$%
$%
$&
$&
$'
$'
$(
$$$
$$$
$$&
$$'
$$)
$$)
− '#'%1
− '#'&+/ 6
− '#''
− '#'(+/ 6
− '#')&
− '#'*&O
$$*
$$.
$$.
$%/
$%
$%$
!"
− # $
% "&'%(
− %#
− %#%
− %#(
%)
(*
+(
+ ,!"-
− +# !"#
− +#% !"#
− +#($λ %
− +#+$λ %&'
− +#.$λ %
+*
++
.(
.+
..
. &'
− .#$( "#)
− .#%$( "#&)
− .#($( "#")
− .#+$( "#*)
− .#.$( *#)
− .#$$( *#&)
− .#/$( *#")
/.
/.
/$
/$
0(
0(
0+
1
− .#0$( *#*)
− .#)$( *#&)(
− .#*$( *#")(
− .#$( *#*)(
− .#%$( *#
− .#($( *# λ
− .#+$( *# λ+λ"+λ*
− .#.,*$() '+-.*/
− .#$,*$() '+-.*0
− .#/,*$() '+-.1/
− .#0,*$() ,+-.*/
− .#),*$() ,+-.*0
− .#%*,*$() ,+-.1/
− .#%,*$() '+-.*/
− .#%%,*$() '+-.*0
− .#%(,*$() '+-.1/
− .#%+,*$() ,+-.*/
− .#%.,*$() ,+-.*0
− .#%$,*$() ,+-.1/
− .#%/,",*$() '+-.*/
− .#%0,",*$() '+-.*0
− .#%),",*$() '+-.1/
− .#(*,",*$() ,+-.*/
− .#(,",*$() ,+-.*0
− .#(%,",*$() ,+-.1/
− .#((,",*$() '+-.*/
− .#(+,",*$() '+-.*0
− .#(.,",*$() '+-.1/
− .#($,",*$() ,+-.*/
− .#(/,",*$() ,+-.*0
− .#(0,",*$() ,+-.1/
0+
00
00
0)
%**
%*
%*%
%*+
%*+
%*+
%*.
%*.
%*.
%
%
%
%%
%%
%%
%/
%/
%0
%0
%0
%)
%)
%%*
%%*
%%*
%%
%%
23
1
!"#$%
− &' (
)*+!,-
− )&' !
− )&"#$
− )&%%&'(()*
− )&)&+,-."/01
− )&.&+,-."///
− )&(*0%&'(()
− )&/"#/2%&33/01
− )&0"#/2%&33//
− )&1"//01!"#4
− )&'2"//0156.!40,-
− )&''"///!"#4
− )&'"///56.!40,-
− )&'%"#"!7
'%)
'%.
'%(
'%1
'))
')(
')0
'.2
'.
'.%
'.)
'..
'./
.#$
− .&'2"#
− .&%& (()*
− .&%.8927 :!'*%; <!
− .&)/
− .&.2.0=2
− .&(2,>0*%&!
'((
'(0
'12
'1
'1
'1%
− .&/"#/':
− .&02,>"0%&
'1/
(
!! "#
$%
&&#
'& (
&)& # !(
#
Análise Elástica Análise plástica
Elastica-perfeitamente
εsyε
LσUσ
Ultσ
O
AC
B σL
σ
ε ε
σ
εε
σ
E
EE
b)a)
d)c)
plástica
*+ ,!-(!.#
/ )& #
! %!
&)& #0&
11
! !
,23 4425446.#
7
!8& !! #$
!!
& !#
5 , 7 .
1& 7& !
!& !1
!&# 1
&% %
& !
!,'9::;.#
0 ! %
# ' ( !
! !
# 0 & % &
7& ( 0 7&,20 449. %! -
#
< !
%! & ( "
& #'7 %
1 & ! !
- !
#
( &
&
#0(
(
1 % 1 !
( &
1(! !
%&& #0
!"#
$
&
! %
! #
= - &%
7 ! ! (
(
#' ( &% -
&%& #
-
7 %
% 8!
!& #
& -
8 7 !
&#" !
! ! &
,)& #9.#
P
δa
Py
P
P P=0
P=0
δa
P=P
P=P
P
Pe
δl
P
P
P=0
P=0 P=P
P=P
0δ δl
ELEMENTO FLEXIVEL
ELEMENTO RÍGIDO
*2 #
2 ! & & !
& % #
%
= %
!&!
1 &
! #
2
% ! & !
! 1# '
! !
$-> 8 ( &% 8 (!
$-? %
1 !
&,23 4@@44.#
A
C
B
D
PP
a)
P
P
δ
P
E, I
P
P
δ
P
PP
∆
b)
$*0$-?,.$->,.#
$ % !
&
!# ' !
8 8 !
! ! (
! # 0 ! &
A !
(
&-1&7#
0( !
#
!"#
&
$ % ! ! - !
2,4@@.#
= %!& % BC
8 & & ,$-?.
71,$->.#
' -& -
D ,4@;. -& ,
(.& -1& (
( #
E - ,$->. 1
&" -&
& , & .# 0
- 9
((,D4@F4@@.#
%
& ,9G;G. &
! A ! &
1#
' & , ! &.
&! #/
, ! .
# ' 1
(!,H
4F9IJ4K4.1!#
#
!
& !
# ' - 1 &
+L,4K.
8 ! ! &
8!
#
'
$ - 1
& !& ,! . -
1
A1&%
& #
[ ] = ,##.
& ! 1 " 1
!!8&&
8 & ! ( # !1
!
! ,M&-44N.#
$! !
8 %! %
&%  7!&
- 1 & !
%!!#
()**1,. 7#
Mecanismo
Elasto-plástica de 2ª ordem
Plástica de 2ª ordem (teoria da plasticidade)
Carga crítica elásticaElástica de 1ª ordem
Elástica de 2ª ordem (não linear geométrica)
Elasto-plástica de 1ª ordem
Deformação característica
Niv
el d
e ca
rga
!"#
+
5! ,!&.-
( % !! %
# ' ! !
1 % !
1,+ 4K923 4@@.#
= % !& %!
!
" &# 2
&, .!A
#
! %7
!1 !( & 1 1
1# 0( ! 1
7 !
)& #N 8& !1
7 #
AVL
BV
AHA
P
HB
B N
P
N
%*0 1& !!#
2 1 !
% !1 & &
%#
AVL
BV
AH
P
HB
B P
δθ θ
NyyN
Nx Nx
A
&*0 1& !#
,
'7 1 & ! 1 &
!
,)& #6.#
%
! &
&#$(-&IO
,9::N. % !
! 71 8& !
#
' % ! -
,.#
'*0 %*IO,9::N.#
/ % IO ,9::N.
-)& #F#0 & !1
7 ,)& #N. % !
&& 1#
+*'9 %IO,9::N.#
!"#
-
)& #K - 1-
! 1# !
& #
$ % & ! -
%!!
"
!#57%
1
&(
! #
( , ! &.
1
% A
1 % #
./0.12
2 ( %
! # ' ! %
%
&!81 !
! % -#0
-7 -
!,7!. %!# %!
%% ! ( 1
&#
/ ! & 9
&
% ! 1
& &
#G&
7& 7
#5
3
%
& 7
#
' % &
! &
8
%
%#
G"
"#0
( O %
- &
! ( ! 1 *
1 %!#
( & &
− 0 7
& ! &
&
− 2 & ! &
1! #
− ' 7 9G ;G % &
%! !
(, -. #
$&
− P 7 !
&
!"#
− G % !
& ( % O 1 %
(
− Q% O (
(
− 2 & ( !
(
− 0 &79G;G
− P % ( #
$ 4
'! 79G
;G & ! &# 0
- %!O &
7 % & ! &
8 !(#G & 7 O
& & & A
% A # )
&!
!#
$ & ! &%
1 ! &#G &
! 1
1 9!7 !
&79G;G % &
#5! %
7&1&-1&#
1 ;-O !
18
& P5E;G O 5'$ 9::: 3Q5'5 '5M5# 5!
% % O !
!&#
1 N % ! O % !
& (9G
;G !1#
1 6!
! & 7
&# $ % ! %
% ! ,
1.#
1 F !
#)8 !
!#
! "
#
$
% %
& %
! $
'()*+),-./0),-(1),223
A
a)
P
C
B
P
D
A
P
C
B
P
D
b)
!"#$45 (6733
6 "
8 */9'3
$ "
" :
%
9
;< 5
;<4 8 %
; < = *())3
=> =>
X
y
z
δZ
Zθ 2
2
Z1θ
z
y
X
Z1δ1δY
X1δ
Y2δ
Xδ 2
Yθ 1
Y2θ
2θX
Xθ 11
2
!"#?9 @6A
)B(B
;< ! )B ;<
=> $
!(B
0 =>
;<
)) )(
() ((
) ) ( (
) ) ( (
) ) ( () ) ( (
) ) ( (
) ) (
) ) (
δ δδ δδ δθ θθθ
= → = = → =
(
(
θθ
*()(3
4 ;<
* $
3 ! $ $
%
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
.
" " C $
$ @
D
%%4
% E
" "
"%
" %
" 0
% % " %
""
%
%
5 $
: " *3
: *3
PPH
L
A
H
E
P
B
G
D C
H
P
F
I
L
J
K
BA
D
E
H
F
O
I
J
Z
O
K
Z
C
X
YG
X
YL
P
P P
P
P P
P P
P
P P
P
1
2L
!"#?/ ?45
F
0
5 8
/
/ 6 */63 /9'
$
4 5
%
5 ! " % 7
*3 +%$" *
" 3
*3 +%8$ *
3
*3 +% "
"
105 $
4 $
5 8
% 7
*3 G $ %
5
*3 G %
" :5
*3 G
""8
*3 %" %
$
*3
*3 D ""
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
0
9 %
5 H81
: " 0
(B*IJ),-K!J),2@1+),223
5
% $ %
% "
0 5
"8 1
5 *
3
D
! 8
F
λ= ⋅ *(()3
= > = >
λC L
5%8
P
A
a)
C
P
P
B
D
P
b)
A
P
C
B
P
D
P P
!"#%?/ ?
1
D
8 75 5*FJ3
5 5*M8FJ3D
5 5
5 %
% $ "
"
" 0
$
!
" 8
6 "
: "
" %
" C $
N % "
@
@O
"
6
% % (6 @6
1 0
5"
9 %
9
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
2
%
" " C λ
N$(() "
" ;< =>
=>
! " λ
$ " $
" " $
"
λ
δ 1Y
1
δ 1X
Y
X
22δX
X
2Yδ
Y1θZ
Zθ 2
!"#.?9 (6A
! (6 ;< *P"P3
(6*'(K3
( (
(
. . . .
)( P )( P.
PQ . (
. .
)( P
Q
− −
=
−
*(@)3
3
F$ *3 ;<
E$
;<
: "
6 5
# 8 "
% 8"
%
#!45)!"!5)46-
%
" (6
9 " C $
F :
%7 " " "
% " %
"$ 0 % 8$ 9
8 C
5)7*()+#&(7*5()6#)+!55)(
9 $
%
"
% $
% "
" (6
! 8$ (6
% "
'(PD 0 " "
% " θθ
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
A
P
M B
L
M
PEI
A BθA
Bθ
!"#/$9 (60 ""
1 % $
$
'(-*1+),,)3
W
M
P
A
M A M B
L
+X
M ext
A
P
!"#0$6
$
(
(
ρ ++ = − *(@(3
!0
( (
ρ ρ
ρ ρ+= + + − *(@@3
R %
*.3 . = * 3 . = *(@Q3
R
( )(
)
ρρ ρ
= − + *(@K3
(
ρ= *(@P3
R(@@ 8
( (
) ) ) )
ρ ρ ρ ρρ ρ ρ ρ
= − − − + − −
*(@-3
) ) ) ) )
ρ ρ ρ ρρ ρ ρ ρ ρ ρ = − + − − −
*(@23
%"" #
( (
.
ρ ρ ρ ρ ρθρ ρ ρ ρ=
− −= = +
*(@,3
( (
ρ ρ ρ ρ ρθρ ρ ρ ρ=
− −= = +
*(@).3
8
δ= *(@))3
S "
N(@,(@).θθ 8
( ) $
θ θ= ⋅ + ⋅ *(@)(3
( ) $ $$
θ θ= ⋅ + ⋅ *(@)@3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
%(@))(@)((@)@
) (
( )
.
.
. . T
θ
θ
δ
=
*(@)Q3
% $$ $$ %
" " " % &
5
% 7
(
) (
* 3 * 3.
( (* 3 * 3
* 3 * 3.
( (* 3 * 3
'
'
ρ ρ ρ ρρ ρ ρ
ρ ρ ρ ρρ ρ ρ
− < − −= − > − −
*(@)K3
(
( (
* 3.
( (* 3 * 3
* 3.
( (* 3 * 3
'
'
ρ ρ ρρ ρ ρ
ρ ρ ρρ ρ ρ
− < − −= − > − −
*(@)P3
! %
1 "%%
*!
6 5
5)7*-+#&(7*5()6#)+!55)(
F 5 55
%
"
*1+),,)3
%
3θ
A
P
MA
L
EI
B
B
θ6
M
P
posição inicial
T
T
∆δ5
δ2
δ1
δ4
!"#1$9 (6 %"
FU
( ) $ $ $
' ' ' ' ' '
θ θ θ θ ∆ ∆ ∆ = − + − = + − +
*(@)-3
( ) $ $$ $ $$ $ $$
' ' ' ' ' '
θ θ θ θ ∆ ∆ ∆ = − + − = + − +
*(@)23
""( "") % "
V$$ $V$ % %
D *
*
+ + ∆ = −
*(@),3
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )(( $ $ $
* ' ' ' ' ' ' +
θ θ ∆ = − + + + − + −
*(@(.3
8
(@()
= *(@()3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
.
%(@)-(@)2(@(.(@()
( ) ( )(
(
.
.
(.
$
$
$
$
' '' '
' '
'
* ' ' +
θ
θ
+ −
+ − = ∆ + −
*(@((3
# % ( , - )
'(,
r θ32δ
A
posição inicial
1δEI
θ
B
δδ
6
4
5
1
r3
r2
r4
6r 5r
!"#2$9 (6 %" ?
.*.
$
)
(
@
Q
K
P
. . . )
. . ) .
) . . .
. . . )
. . ) .
. ) . .
*
− = −
*(@(@3
/
1 "
)
(
@
Q
K
P
. . ) . . .
. . . . . )
. ) . . ) .
) . . ) . .
θ
θ
= ∆ −
−
*(@(Q3
1%(@(((@(@(@(Q 8 %
[ ]
) ( ) (( (
@ ( Q
) ((
@
. . . .
)( P )( P.
PQ . (
. .
)( P
Q
+
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ
φ φ
φ
− − =
−
*(@(K3
3Q@()* =$$φ % N
1 *(...3 R *),,,8(...3 %
+J1*),KP3
4 %
@
)
)(
ρ ρφφ
= *(@(P3
(
(
*) 3
P
ρ ρφφ
−= *(@(-3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
0
@
* 3
Q
ρ ρ ρ ρφφ−= *(@(23
Q
* 3
(
ρ ρ ρφφ
−= *(@(,3
+
( ( φ ρ ρ ρ= − − *(@@.3
+
= *(@@)3
4
@
)
(
(
@
Q
)(
* )3
P
* 3
Q
* 3
(
/
/
/
/
ρ ρφφ
ρ ρφφ
ρ ρ ρ ρφφ
ρ ρ ρφφ
=
− = − =
− =
*(@@(3
+
( ( /φ ρ ρ ρ= − + *(@@@3
% 3Q@()* =$$φ
R*),,,8(...340#*37
) (
(
(
@ (
Q (
@*) 3
@ )
Q Q
@ )
( (
φ φ β β
βφβ β
φ φ β β
φ φ β β
= = −
= + = −
*(@@Q3
1
( ( (
+
πβ = = = *(@@K3
(
(
π= *(@@P3
F " 4V. 8 +WI
3Q@()* =$$φ V)F " %
4 %
GJ*1+),,)37
( Q P 2
(
@-)
). 2Q.. ).2... (@(2Q2....'
ρ ρ ρ ρ= + − + − *(@@-3
( Q P 2
@
@-)
P. 2Q.. -KP... (@(2Q2....'
ρ ρ ρ ρ= + − + − *(@@23
( Q P 2
Q
K.,)
@. (K(.. ).2... (@(2Q2....'
ρ ρ ρ ρ= + − + − *(@@,3
( Q P 2
K
)@ )) ,.-)
P. (K(.. -KP... (@(2Q2....'
ρ ρ ρ ρ= − + − + *(@Q.3
( )(
(( +
ρ = = *(@Q)3
"
4 %
A 1 *),2-3
% 7
( ) ( )())
)) T)(
( ) X
1
1
+1
φ φ∞
=
= + + *(@Q(3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
2
( ) ( )(()
) )T P
( ( ( X
1
1
+1
φ φ∞
=
= + + *(@Q@3
( )
( ) ( )(
@)
( ))T Q
@ ( @ X
1
1
1+
1φ φ
∞
=
+ = + + *(@QQ3
( ) ( )(
Q)
) )T (
P ( @ X
1
1
+1
φ φ∞
=
= + + *(@QK3
( )
( ) ( )()
( ))
)( ( Q X
1
1
1+
1φ
∞
=
+ = + + *(@QP3
! %+! ρ
% %
!()(( %
$ 9
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
P/Pe
φ ι
φ1φ2φ3φ4
#'8!-?'% ?
3
-6
-5
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
P/Pe
φ ι
φ1φ2φ3φ4
#'8!-?'% ?
5)7*-+!"79)(()+! #"!5(
!%
" % *'().3
% 8
*)3 *@3 " %
8$*(3*!J),2,Y(...3
a) Φ
M
MΦ
Φ
M
Rígida
Semi-rígida
Articulada1
2
3
b)
Modelo de cálculo
Comportamentoreal
!"#3?+%N ?
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
! 5 8
$0 %
$
L
w
X
M
M=2WL
8
w
L
M
X
w
L
M
2
24M=WL
X
2
12M=-WL
WL< M <2
8
2-WL120 < M <
WL24
2
DIAGRAMA DE MOMENTOSVIGAS
!"#?/ %
! % "
* 8D (..)3 9 :
%
4 %8$
4 8
%
*1+),,)3
! C $ % $
48δ
!%8$ %$
%$ 8 "
%
6 C %
C $
" "%
1 "
"8$'
()(*1+),,)1F89Z),,-3
P
MA
L
EI
BM
P
θrA
AθA B
Bθ
rBθ
!"#?9 (6 "
F2+ 2+ %
5"
+
+
2θ = *(@Q-3
+
+
2θ = *(@Q23
1 " %
%
$
+ +
' '
2 2θ θ
= − + −
*(@Q,3
$ $$
+ +
' '
2 2θ θ
= − + −
*(@K.3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
"
N%(@Q,(@K. :87
[ $
' '
θ θ∗ = + *(@K)3
[ $ $$
' '
θ θ∗ = + *(@K(3
((
[ T
$
+ +
''' ' 2
2 2∗
= + −
*(@K@3
((
[ T$$
$
+ +
''' ' 2
2 2∗
= + −
*(@KQ3
[ [ [T $ $ $' ' ' 2= = *(@KK3
$% %$
"
( (
[ ) ) $
+ + + +
'' ' 2
2 2 2 2
= + + −
*(@KP3
% '()@
* ) P3 =
r
3r
1
2r
A
EI
r5 r6
4r
∆
B
L
!"#?9 (6?
%
)
(
@
Q
K
P
) . . .
) ).
. ) . .
) . . .
) ).
. . ) .
∆ = + − − − − ∆
*(@K-3
U
6"" * ) P3 =
)
(
@
Q
K
P
) . . ) . .
) ). ) . .
) ). . . )
θ
θ
− = −
−
*(@K23
%(@K-(@K2
[ [
[ [
T . .
.
.
$
$ $$
θ
θ
=
*(@K,3
F (@K, (@KP (@K- 8
( ) [ ] ( )3 45
+ = *(@P.3
9;+<
%8$" 8
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
.
[ ]
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
( )
( ) ( )
[ [ [ ( [ [ [ [ [ ( [ [
( (
[ [
[ [
[ [ [ ( [ [
(
[
. . . .
( (.
.
. .
(
$ $$ $$ $ $$ $ $$
$
$
3 45
$ $$ $ $$
$$
' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '
' '' '
+
' ' ' ' '
'
ρ ρ
ρ
− + + − + + + + + − + −
= + + − + −
*(@P)3
ρ+
(@P) "
5 $$Q $$ (
%(@P@(@PQ(@PK(@PP 8
[ ]
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
( )
( ) ( )
[ [ [ [ [ [ [ [ [ [
( (
[ [
[ [
[ [ [ [ [
(
[
. . . .
( (.
.
. .
(
$ $$ $$ $ $$ $ $$
$
$
3 45
$ $$ $ $$
$$
' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '
' '' '
+
' ' ' ' '
'
− + + + + + + − + −
= + + + −
*(@P(3
[ [
$$
(
[)(
Q
+
'' 2
2∗
= +
*(@P@3
/
(
[)(
Q T$$
+
'' 2
2∗
= +
*(@PQ3
[ [ ( T $ $ ' ' 2∗= = *(@PK3
(
[Q Q Q
) )+ + + +
2
2 2 2 2
= + + −
*(@PP3
T+ =
1 0 4
(@(K
#!45)!"!5)4#6!+5
4 % $
"
1
*/9'3
9
$
1 (@(K " 8
)B(@)
% φ)φ(φ@ φQ !
)B
*)B3
(B %
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
0
1 % " 8
5"
"
y
E, A, I
x
E, A, I E, A, I
1 2 3
E, A, I
1
y
L
x
L/3 L/3 L/3
!"#%$6 (6
6 " %
" (@(K
7 ;<)BE
;6<%
""0
" %
; </ = *(@P-3
9 ;/<(@P- ;<;6<
(@P2
[ ] [ ] [ ]/ 6= + *(@P23
! " ;5/5<
;5/5< $
% " $
%" ;/<
;5/5< % "
1
;< ;6<
0 )B
1
5)7*-+#&(7*5()6#)+!55)(
4 (6" 8$
'()K*\),P.1+),,)3
P θA
A
L
TAM
EI
θ
B
w
M
B
B
P
B
A
TB
Aw wx
!"#.?9 (6?
4 NJ8N */NN3
(@P,
( ( (7 8δ δ δ= + Ω *(@P,3
((
((
. (
7
δ
= *(@-.3
( )(
(
. (
8 * *
δ θ θ
= − − + + +
*(@-)3
# %
*.3 * 3
*.3 * 3
θ θ
= = = =
*(@-(3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
2
"
@ () ( @ Q* 3 9 9 9 9= + + + *(@-@3
8 9%.9 .9(.9, :.".:.
"
@ (Q ) ( @ Q*.3 * 3 9 9 9 9 9= = = = + + + *(@-Q3
(@ ) ( @*.3 * 3 @ (
9 9 9 9
θ θ= = = = + + *(@-K3
F (@-( 89%.9 .9(.9,
) @ ( @ (
( ( (
@
Q
( ) ( )
@ ( @ )
9 : :
9 : :
9
9 :
θ θ
θ θ
θ
= + − +
− = − + − ==
*(@-P3
(@-@ "
@ ( @ ( @ ( @ (
( @ ( ( @ (
( ( @ ( @* 3 )
θ θ
= − + + − + + − + − +
*(@--3
) ) ( ( @ @ Q Q* 3 * 3 * 3 * 3 * 3 ; ; ; ; ψ ψ ψ ψ= + + + *(@-23
(@-2 <
) ) ( ( @ @ Q Q* 3 * 3 * 3 * 3 * 3 ; ; ; ;ξ ψ ξ ψ ξ ψ ξ ψ ξ= + + + *(@-,3
%= * )(@Q3% I
%3
( ) ( )
( )
( ) ( )
( )
@ ()
@ ((
@ (@
@ (Q
(
( @ )
( @
ψ ξ ξ ξ ξ
ψ ξ ξ ξ
ψ ξ ξ ξ
ψ ξ ξ ξ
= − += − += −= − +
*(@2.3
% = * )(@Q3 %
; * )(@Q3 ; )
; >$.
N /NN
( )
( $ $ $ 7 6 ;; ;δ = + − *(@2)3
$6 $
((
)( (
.
$
$
ψψ= *(@2(3
) )
.
6 $
ψ ψ= − *(@2@3
M $
( )(
)
.7
;
δ∂=
∂ *(@2Q3
8$
. $ $ $ $ $ $
6 ; 6 ; + − = = + *(@2K3
/
$ $ ;= *(@2P3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
%
(@2K
(
( @ @
@ @
Q P ( P
P )( P )(
; <( P Q P
P )( P )(
$
− − = −
− − −
*(@2-3
(
)K ). @. ).
P P
). K ). K; <
(
@. ). )K ).
P P
). K ). K
$
6
− − − − − = − −
−
*(@223
;< )B;6<
"
"
8 "(@2,
$ "
@
(
@
( (
( @ (
(
( ( @
Q ( P ) ( 8P )8 8)K ). @. ).
P ) )( P P ) 8)( P8 8 8). K ). K
( P ) Q ( 8P )8 8
@. ). )K ).
8P ) 8)( P 8P ) )( P8
). K ).
*
*
+ + + = + + + + + K
:
:
θ
θ
*(@2,3
%
! 8
"
"
] "
% " GJ%
(@@- (@@2 (@@, (@Q. F
(@,.% 88
%"
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
( Q P 2
(
( Q P 2
@
( Q P 2
Q
( Q P 2
K
@-)
). 2Q.. ).2... (@(2Q2....
@-)
P. 2Q.. -KP... (@(2Q2....
)) K.,)
@. (K(.. ).2... (@(2Q2....
)@ )) ,.-)
P. (K(.. -KP... (@(2Q2....
+ + + +'
+ + + +'
+ + + +'
+ + + +'
= + − + −= + − + −= + − + −
= − + − +
*(@,.3
6 8%" ^ * )(@Q3$ $φ = (@,)
(^)
(^(
(^@
(^Q
)).
)P.
)@.
)P.
πφ
πφ
πφ
πφ
= −
= −
= − = +
*(@,)3
"
" % 4 4V.
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
%
8 " * "3 4_.
"
1 " " 8
: " ! " %
" :
0 "
%
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4P/Pe
φ ι
φ4'
φ2'
φ3'φ1'
#'8!-?'% " "
!A(@ % " 3Q@()* =$$φ
% ^ * )(@Q3$ $φ = % "
%%
%
0.
6 % "
C $ "
0%
"
* 3"
4 5"" @O
@
%
1 %
"
(6
1 8
% @6
6 % " "
%#!45)!"!5)46-
D 0
" C $
" *F8
9Z/ 5?@ (..) (..) (..)`\(..)36
%
@6
6 % @6
%1+*),,)39Z/5?@ *),2,3F89Z/5?@
*(..)3 /0Za*),,,3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
%.
% #+7*5):)&)!
(60 "
" @6
T
M
y
x
ya
P
z
zaM zbM
ybM
TP
!"#/?9 @6?"
! :"
'()P
$8 @6
) (
( )
@ Q
Q @
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
*
6A
δ
θ
θ
θ
θ
φ
=
*(Q)3
% F@% "JJFQ
" " *
"""" % & B
C . JJ
5
%/
r
z
y
x1
2r
5r
4r
3r
6r
7r 10r
11r
8r
12r9r
!"#0?9 @6?
% 7
(
)
(
* 3 * 3.
( (* 3 * 3
* 3 * 3.
( (* 3 * 3
'
'
π ρ π ρ π ρ π ρπ ρ π ρ π ρ
π ρ π ρ π ρ π ρπ ρ π ρ π ρ
− <
− −= − > − −
*(Q(3
(
(
(
* 3.
( (* 3 * 3
* 3.
( (* 3 * 3
'
'
π ρ π ρ π ρπ ρ π ρ π ρ
π ρ π ρ π ρπ ρ π ρ π ρ
− <
− −= − > − −
*(Q@3
(
@
(
* 3 * 3.
( (* 3 * 3
* 3 * 3.
( (* 3 * 3
'
'
π ρ π ρ π ρ π ρπ ρ π ρ π ρ
π ρ π ρ π ρ π ρπ ρ π ρ π ρ
<
− −= − > − −
*(QQ3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
%0
(
Q
(
* 3.
( (* 3 * 3
* 3.
( (* 3 * 3
'
'
π ρ π ρ π ρπ ρ π ρ π ρ
π ρ π ρ π ρπ ρ π ρ π ρ
− <
− −= − > − −
*(QK3
!.
! %
48" *'()P3
*'()-3 %
[ ] *P )(3
*
1 * ×
= *(QP3
[ ] *P )(3
*
* ×
= *(Q-3
) ( @ Q K P - 2 , ). )) )( *
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 = *(Q23
) ( @ Q K P - 2 , ). )) )( *
= *(Q,3
;*<
[ ]*P )(3
) . . . . . . . ) . . .
) ). . . ) . . . . . .
) ). . . . . . . . ) .
) ). . . . ) . . . . .
) ). . . . . . . . . )
. . . ) . . . . . ) . .
*
×
− =
− −
−
*(Q).3
%1
8
[ ] *)( )(31 1 ×
= ⋅ *(Q))3
[ ] [ ] [ ][ ]*)( )(3 *P )(3 *P )(3
*
1 * *× × ×
= *(Q)(3
% #+7*5);:&5)<)=+)5"
@6 ! 2. 9Z
F/*),2,3
8@6
% D 0
@6 '()2 0
Y8bY8c
A
a)
BX
ZBF
MYB
YA
b)
Z
ZAMP
F
Y
c)ZA
YAM
F
P
P
P
YBF MZB
!"#1?9 @6?6Y8bY8c
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
%2
M
A
M
P
ZA
BEI
L
P
ZB
YAF YBF
Z
y
x
z
M
P A
FZA
YA M
ZB
L
B
F
EIY P
YB
x
x∆∆ y
S∆ S∆ z∆∆ x
a) b)
!"#2?9 @6?'"3Y8b3Y8c
4 % 0
8 %7
− D "E
− D ""E
− D " E
! "
"D b/A
*),2P3 " * d
3 @69
$
6 5 %
%* 3
*3 9 "
" "
" F "
"
" 1
" '%! 8 )
"
0% 8'(),
.3
8
( ( ( (' = + + *(Q)@3
( ( (
)'
= + +
*(Q)Q3
D "*"3
C ' δ = − *(Q)K3
)C '
δ = − *(Q)P3
9" 8
( (
)
(C
δ = +
*(Q)-3
( ()
)
..
)
(C
C
δδ = = +
*(Q)23
D 8δ/.
" δ5. " δC 8
δ5 δC
(Q)2
( ( ( (
) )
. .
) )
( (/
δ
= + + = + +
*(Q),3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
.
)
/
'
δ =
*(Q(.3
) ( ()
.
)
) (
'
= + +
*(Q()3
!!
D'(),8
( )(
(
)5 5 C
= − + + − *(Q((3
(
α = *(Q(@3
(Q(( 8
( )( ( (
(( 5 C 5
α αα= = + − *(Q(Q3
0
( ) 55 C
α α = + + + −
*(Q(K3
% ## 8
( )[ ]) 5 C
5
α α = − + =
*(Q(P3
.
Y8b
( )) 5 C
α α α α= − + + *(Q(-3
4 8"8Y8c
( ) 5
5 C
D E
β β= + + + − *(Q(23
(
β = *(Q(,3
% ## 8
( )) 5 C
5
D
E
β β = − + =
Y8c
( ))
5 C
D E
β β β β= − + + *(Q@)3
# %(Q(-(Q@)(Q()
( )( )
( ) ( )( )
() ( ( (
(.
(
); (
( ( )
5 C
5 C 5 C
α α α α
α α α α
= + +
− + + +
*(Q@(3
(
)
(.
)
(
F
= ⋅ *(Q@@3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
.
( )( )
( ) ( )( )
() ( ( (
(.
(
)
(
( ( )
5 C
5 C 5 C
β β β β
β β β β
= + +
− + + +
*(Q@Q3
(
)
(.
)
(
F
= ⋅ *(Q@K3
)
@ (
)
)Q
'
F F
= + +
*(Q@P3
! 8" '% 48
'%
)^ ^
@ (
)
)Q
'
F F
= + +
*(Q@-3
( )( ) ( )
( )
(^ ( ( ( (
( )
5 C 5 C
5 C
F
β β β β
β β β β
= + + − +
+ + *(Q@23
( ) ( ) ( )
( )
(^ ( ( ( (
( )
5 C 5 C
5 C
F
α α α α
α α α α
= + + − +
+ + *(Q@,3
.%
*3 9 ""
− '"Y8b
8"Y8b (Q(Q
0 (Q(K %"
#
[ ]
[ ]
.
)
)
5 5 C
C 5 C
?
θ α
θ α α α α
=
=
= = + +
= = − + +
*(QQ.3
0
( ) ( )( ) ( )
( @
@ (
Q T ( T
( T Q T
5 5
C C
' '
' '
θ
θ
=
*(QQ)3
] %'('(
(
@
)
Q ( (
)
( ( (
α α ααα α α
α ααα α α
− = − −
− = − −
*(QQ(3
(
@
)
Q ( (
)
( ( (
α α ααα α α
α ααα α α
− = − −
− = − −
*(QQ@3
− '"Y8c
( ) ( )( ) ( )
Q K
K Q
Q T ( T
( T Q T
5 5
C C
' '
' '
θ
θ
=
*(QQQ3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
..
] %','-
Q
K
)
Q ( (
)
( ( (
β β βββ β β
β βββ β β
− = − −
− = − −
*(QQK3
Q
K
)
Q ( (
)
( ( (
β β βββ β β
β βββ β β
− = − −
− = − −
*(QQP3
F " 8 %
*' ((.3 "
− GY8b
y
M
P
A
FYA
ZA
M
YB
B
F
EIZ
xP
ZB
!"#3?9 @6?GY8b
! $
( @ ( @ P(
Q ( P P( )
@ @
5
' ' ' ' '
∆ ∆ = + = ∆ + = ∆
*(QQ-3
./
') "
"* c3 UJF
%' '( 8
( )
( )( (
P
) )
P ( (
'
α αα α α
−=
− − *(QQ23
( )
( )( (
P
))
P ( (
'
α αα α α
−=
− − *(QQ,3
48 "
UJD'((.8
5
= *(QK.3
5 C = + − ∆ *(QK)3
( @
Q ( 5
' '
∆ ∆ = +
*(QK(3
@ (
( Q C
' '
∆ ∆ = +
*(QK@3
( @@ @
2 Q 5
' '
= + − ∆
*(QKQ3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
.0
(
α = *(QKK3
8
( (
( @ ( @@ @ @
2 Q )( ( )
@ @
5
' ' ' '
α α = + − ∆ = + −
*(QKP3
- @
)( 5
'
=
*(QK-3
F %' '@ 8'G
( )
( )( ( ( (
-
) )
P ( ( )(
'
α α αα α α
−= −
− − *(QK23
( )
( )( ( ( (
-
))
P ( ( )(
'
α α αα α α
−= +
− − *(QK,3
− GY8c
4 8
"" U
2 Q K
( )
@ @' ' '= + *(QP.3
F %','K 84
( )
( )( (
2
) )
P ( (
'
ββ
β β β−
=− −
*(QP)3
.1
( )
( )( (
P
))
P ( (
'
ββ
β β β−
=− −
*(QP(3
48 "
U4 8
( )
( )( (( ( (
(, Q K
) ( ) )
@ @ )( P ( ( )(
' ' '
β ββ ββ β β
−= + − = −
− − *(QP@3
( )
( )( ( (
( ((, Q K
)( ) )
@ @ )( P ( ( )(
' ' '
ββ βββ β β
−= + + = +
− − *(QPQ3
6 % %
Y8bY8c8@6
6 % 8
$
[ ] [ ][ ] 8= *(QPK3
*
5 5 5 5 5 5 C C C C C C = *(QPP3
*
5 5 5 5 5 5 C C C C C C8 3 3 θ θ θ θ θ θ= *(QP-3
%
(QP2* 3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
.2
*(QP23
/3
%φφ
(
(
(
(
)((Q*) 3
)((Q*) 3
' '
' '
6
6
φ υ
φ υ
= = −
= = −
*(QP,3
% #+7*5)-;<>(;)?@
D 9Z bZ IJ @6
5 '(()
!"#?9 @6?H?15
9 "
8 7
[ ] [ ] [ ]*)( )(3
?H5? ?H5? ?H5? 8
×= ⋅ *(Q-.3
;< *)(")(3 @6 " 8
'()2 F*V)e,3%
*
5 5 5 5 5 5 C C C C C C = *(Q-)3
*
5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 C C C 3 3 θ θ θ θ θ θ= *(Q-(3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
/
[ ]
) )) ) -)
- (( P P( - 2( P )((
, @@ 2 K@ , ,@ 2 ))@
QQ ).Q
Q KK 2 ,K K ))K
( PP P 2P @ (P
) --
- 22 P )(2
, ,, 2 )),
).)
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . .
. .
+ +
+ + + +
+ + + +
+ +
+ + +
+ + ++
+
+ +
' + +
+
=
.
Q ))))
( )()(
. .
. +
+
*(Q-@3
1 % . 9Z F /
*),2,3 7
%8 ' ""
8 ' " "
" 5" "c
(8 ' " "
" "c
,8 ' " "
" 5" "b
-8 ' " "
" "b
)8 ' ""*
"c3 b
G8 ' " "b
b
I8 ' ""*
"b3 b
J8 ' " "c
c
/
!"%
)
@ (
)
) * 3Q
F F
=+ +
*(Q-Q3
(
)
Q ( (
α α ααα α α−=
− − *(Q-K3
@
)
( ( (
α ααα α α−=
− − *(Q-P3
Q
)
Q ( (
β β βββ β β−=
− − *(Q--3
K
)
( ( (
β βββ β β−=
− − *(Q-23
( (
P
) *) 3
P ( (
α αα α α
−=− −
*(Q-,3
( ( ( (
-
) *) 3
P ( ( )(
α α αα α α
−= −− −
*(Q2.3
( (
2
) *) 3
P ( (
β ββ β β
−=− −
*(Q2)3
( ( ( (
,
) *) 3
P ( ( )(
β β ββ β β
−= −− −
*(Q2(3
( )( ) ( )
( )
(( ( ( (
( )
5 C 5 C
5 C
F
β β β β
β β β β
= + + − +
+ + *(Q2@3
( ) ( ) ( )
( )
(( ( ( (
( )
5 C 5 C
5 C
F
α α α α
α α α α
= + + − +
+ + *(Q2Q3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
/
=(α
=(β
]" 5"%
( , - 8 M 8
8
( Q P 2 ).( @ Q K
(
( Q P ).( @ Q K
@
( Q P( @
Q
)) K., )QP)-)
@. (K(.. ).2... (@(2Q2.... (-(Q@()P.....
2)@ )) ,.- (-PQ))
P. (K(.. -KP... (@(2Q2.... (-(Q@()P.....
)) K)
@. (K(.. ).2...
'
'
'
π π π π πρ ρ ρ ρ ρ
π π π π πρ ρ ρ ρ ρ
π π πρ ρ ρ
= − − − − −
= + + + + +
= − − − −2 ).
Q K
( Q P 2 ).( @ Q K
K
., )QP)-
(@(2Q2.... (-(Q@()P.....
)@ )) ,.- (-PQ))
P. (K(.. -KP... (@(2Q2.... (-(Q@()P.....
'
π πρ ρ
π π π π πρ ρ ρ ρ ρ
−= + + + + +
*(Q2K3
(
(
ρπ
=
*(Q2P3
(
(
ρπ
=
*(Q2-3
% )GIJ
P ( @
( (
- ( @
2 Q K
( (
, Q K
( )
@ @
( )
@ @ )(
( )
@ @
( )
@ @ )(
' ' '
' ' '
' ' '
' ' '
α
β
= + = + −
= +
= + −
*(Q223
/%
F" %
)
^ ^@ (
)
) * 3Q
F F
=+ +
*(Q2,3
(
)
Q ( (
α α α ααα α α
−=− +
*(Q,.3
@
)
( ( (
α ααα α α
−=− −
*(Q,)3
Q
)
Q ( (
β β βββ β β
−=− +
*(Q,(3
K
)
( ( (
β βββ β β
−=− +
*(Q,@3
( (
P
) * )3
P ( (
α αα α α
−=− +
*(Q,Q3
( ( ( (
-
) * )3
P ( ( )(
α α αα α α
−= +− +
*(Q,K3
( (
2
) * )3
P ( (
β ββ β β
−=− +
*(Q,P3
( ( ( (
,
) * )3
P ( ( )(
β β ββ β β
−= −− +
*(Q,-3
( )( ) ( )
( ) ( )
(( (^ ( (
( )
5 C 5 C
5 C
F K
K
β β β β
β β β β
= + + − +
+ +
*(Q,23
( )( ) ( )
( ) ( )
(( ( (^ (
( )
5 C 5 C
5 C
F K
K
α α α α
α α α α
= + + − +
+ + *(Q,,3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
/.
=(α
=(β
]" 5"% F(
FK 8 M 8
( Q P 2 ).( @ Q K
(
( Q P 2 ).( @ Q K
@
( Q P( @
Q
)) K., )QP)-)
@. (K(.. ).2... (@(2Q2.... (-(Q@()P.....
)@ )) ,.- (-PQ))
P. (K(.. -KP... (@(2Q2.... (-(Q@()P.....
)) K)
@. (K(.. ).2...
'
'
'
π π π π πρ ρ ρ ρ ρ
π π π π πρ ρ ρ ρ ρ
π π πρ ρ ρ
= − − + − +
= − + − + −
= − − + −2 ).
Q K
( Q P 2 ).( @ Q K
K
., )QP)-
(@(2Q2.... (-(Q@()P.....
)@ )) ,.- (-PQ))
P. (K(.. -KP... (@(2Q2.... (-(Q@()P.....
'
π πρ ρ
π π π π πρ ρ ρ ρ ρ
+
= − + − + −
*(Q)..3
(
(
ρπ
=
*(Q).)3
(
(
ρπ
=
*(Q).(3
%').'G.'I'J
P ( @
( (
- ( @
2 Q K
( (
, Q K
( )
@ @
( )
@ @ )(
( )
@ @
( )
@ @ )(
' ' '
' ' '
' ' '
' ' '
α
β
= + = + −
= +
= + −
*(Q).@3
//
%% #+7*5)#!&!A;=!B
4 8 /0Za *),,,3
% " D
5 "
'(((
!"#?9 @6?6
' " % % ."J ."
8 $
x
z
uw
dx+du
p dxz
p dxx
dx
w+dw
dw
(y)u+du
ϕy
ϕyd
(1+ε) dxd
v+dv
(z)u
v
y
dx(1+ε)
u+du
xp dx
p dxy
dx+du
dx
ϕz
ϕz dv
x
!"#?9 @6?6%
6 ' ((@ % $ $
%
Q ( Q (
( (Q ( Q (
L F FL 3 3 + + + +
± = = ± = = *(Q).Q3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
/0
5%/0Za %
'(((
( ) ( ) ( )
. . . .
.
) * 3
+ + + + 3 3 7
+ F + F
+ + L
+ F
ϕ
ξ ξξ ξ
− −= + − − +
− − −+
*(Q).K3
( ) ( )
. . .
.
) * 3 ^* 3
)
+ + + 3 + 7
F F
+ L
F
ϕ ϕ
ξξ ξ
−= = − − +
− −+
*(Q).P3
( ) ( )
. .
. .
* 3 ^ * 3
3 + + +
+ + 7 L
+ +
ϕ
ξξ ξ
= − = + +
−+ −
*(Q).-3
( ). .* 3 ^ ^* 3 ^* 3
7 3 F3 7 L ξ ξ= − = − *(Q).23
1 $
$
[ ] + = + *(Q).,3
*
+ + + + + + M 7 : M 7 : = *(Q)).3
*
+ + + + + + 3 3 ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕ = *(Q)))3
[ ]) ( @ Q K P - 2 , ). )) )( *
= *(Q))(3
=> ;+<
%$
/1
%#!45)!"!5)4#6!+5
6 "(6
% " 8 " @6
% %
" : !
8 "
$
" )('((Q
z
M x1
y
x
y1M
F y1
z1M M z2
z1F z2F
x1F
L
1 2x1,θ ,u x1 x2F M x2 x2,θx2,u
y1,θ
y1,υ
,θM
y2,υ
y2
y2F
y2
,wz1 ,wz2
z1,θ z2,θ
E, A, I
!"#%?9 @6"
6 "8 8
05
*/A/5?@(...3
6 7
*3 9 "E
*3 9 E
*3 9 "E
*3 9 "
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
/2
8 ;<*)(")(3
4 "$
) )
( (
) )
) )
− = −
*(Q))@3
! 8
) )
( (
) )
) )
6A
θ
θ
− = −
*(Q))Q3
6 A
4 " 8 ? " "c
" "b 8
( (
) )
) )
( (( (
( (
)( P )( P
P PQ (
)( P )( P
P P( Q
υ
θ
υ
θ
− − =
− − −
−
*(Q))K3
( (
) )
) )
( (( (
( (
)( P )( P
P PQ (
)( P )( P
P P( Q
θ
θ
− − − − =
−
−
*(Q))P3
03
# "c#J "b
6%(Q))@(Q))Q(K))K(Q))P
( )( )
6
ν=
+ *(Q))-3
8 ;< @6 '((Q
( ) ( )
@ ( @ (
@ ( @ (
(
( (
(
( (
@ ( @
. . . . . . . . . .
)( P )( P. . . . . . .
)( P )( P. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .( ) ( )
P P ((. . . . . . . .
)K
PP ((. . . . . . . .
)K
. . . . . . . . . .
)( P )(. . . . . . .
A A
ν ν
−
−
− − −
−+ +
−
−=
− −
( ) ( )
(
@ ( @ (
( (
( (
P.
)( P )( P. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .( ) ( )
P ( P Q. . . . . . . .
P ( P Q. . . . . . . .
A A
ν ν
−
− −
+ + −
−
*(Q))23
! (B ";/<
(Q)), ;<
;6< @6
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
0
)B
(())2
" (()K@
;/<
[ ] [ ] [ ]*)( )(3 *)( )(3 *)( )(3/ 6× × ×
= + *(Q)),3
;6<
( (
( (
(
(
(
) . . . . . ) . . . . .
P P. . . . . . .
K ). K ).P P
. . . . . .K ). K ).
. . . . . . .
(. . . . .
)K ). @.
(. . . .
)K ). @.) . . . . .
P. . .
K ).P
. .K ).
. .
(.
)K
(
)K
6
ρ ρ
ρ
− − − − − − − − = −
*(Q)(.3
( )( (
ρ = + *(Q)()3
9
"8
0
4 *F 8H 3 "
84GH *4GH3
'((K
z
y
wcvc
θ x
z
y
x
τ xy dA
σx dA
τ xz dA y
z
a) b)
!"#.?9 @673 %3%
8
( ( (
)
( $ $
7 7
3 * 7 7
δη σ δ
∂ ∂ ∂ = + + ∂ ∂ ∂ *(Q)((3
0 6*(Q)(@
"8
) ) ( (
( (
) ) ( ) ) (
( ( (
( (
( ) ( ( ) (
( ( (
. .
P P
.
. .
P P
.
*
6
θ θ−
+ − − − − −
= −
− − − + −
*(Q)(@3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
0
6* '((P$
R %
BP
C
A
X
Y
Z
Y
X
ZT
M
Z
Y
M
M
Y
T/2
Z
T/2
B B
θx xθM y = -M θx =yM
T θx
21 1
B
!"#/?N
F5R θ JJ
* 1
% 8 AG'W
) ) ) ( ( (
) )
^
( (
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .)
( .
. .
.
*
6
'
θ θ θ θ θ θ−
= −
*(Q)(Q3
6
(Q)(K
0%
*(Q)(K
3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
0.
9"
*'((-3
,θ
x1,u,θ x1 F x1
M z1
x1M
z
E, A, I
z1,w
,υ y1
1
L
F z1
y1F
,θ z2
z2,w
F y2 ,υ y2
,u x2F x22
F z2
z2M
,θ x2x2M
x
y
x11B ,θ B ,θ2 x2' 'y2 y2M ,θ,θ y1M y1
z1
!"#0?9 )Q
/A A c *(...3
" "
)) )(
() ((
6 66
6 6
= *(Q)(P3
( (
) (( ( (
( ( () (
) ( ) (() ( ( )))
( ( (( )
) (( ( (
. . . . .
))P. . .
K ). ).
P )). . .
K ). ).
)) (P)) (. .
). ). K K K
((. . .
). K )K
( (. . .
). K )K
. . . . . .
6
ρ
−
−
−−
− −− −=
− −
−
(
*(Q)(-3
0/
) ( ) (( ( (
( ( () ( ) (
( ) ( )( ( (( ) ( )
)(
( ( ( (( )
. . . . . . .
))P.
K ). ). ). ).
P )).
K ). ). ). ).
)) (P)) (
). ). K ). ). ). ).
(
). ). @.
6
ρ ρ ρ
− + −− −
− − −− + −
− +−− − −=
− −− − ( )
( )
) ( )
) ( ) ( )( ( ( (
@
( @. @.
( @
). ). ( @. @. @.
. . . . . . .
− −
+ − −− − − −
*(Q)(23
(
( ( (( )
) ( ) (() ( ( )
( ( ( (( )
()
( )( ( ( (
) ()
. . . . . .).
P )). . .
K ). ).
)) (P)) (. .
). ). K ). ).
(. .
). ). @. (
(. .
). ). ( @.
@.
). ). ).
6
ρ
ρ
−
− −−
− + +−− + − −
− − − −− −=
+− −
− ( ) ( )) () (
( )(( )
@.
@. @.
. .). ). ). @. @.
ρ
−−
− −−
*(Q)(,3
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
00
( )
) ( ) (( ( (
( ( () ( ) (
) ( ) (( ( () ( ) (
) (( ( () ( (
((
))P.
K ). ). ). ).
P )).
K ). ). ). ).
)) (P)) (
). ). K K K ). ).
@((.
). K )K @. @.
6
ρ ρ ρ
− −−
− −
− − + − −− −
−− −=
( )
( ) ( )
) ( ( ) (( ( (
) (( ( () (
( ) (( ( () ((
( @(.
). K )K @. @.
( (
). ). ). @. @. )K @.
@ ( (@
). ). ). @. @. @. )K
ρ ρ ρ
ρ ρ ρ
− + −−
− − −− −
−− −−
*(Q)@.3
.C
$ ; < = *())3 $ $ 5
5F" '
((2 $
rF3
rF1
rF2 F5rF4r
F6r
W(x)
!"#1?9 '"
4 ())8
F
$
[ ] = + *(K)3
! () *1 + ),,)3
%
01
/ + √!E
Q
P
MA BM
PA B
L
L/2 L/2
P
BA
P
Mw
A
L
B
M
( )( )
2
;
−=
= − ( )(
(
@
2
:
−=
= −
BAM
P
Q
aA
L
b
M
BP
( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
; C C 5 C 5
= − − + + +
( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
; 5 5 C 5 C
= − − − + + +
( )( ( ( ( ( ( = − −
B
P
AM
PA
w
L
M
B
a b
( ) ( )( ( (
( (
( ( ( (( ( ) )
2
: C C C C
= − − − −
+
( ) ( )( ( (
( (
( ( ( ( (( ( ) ) ( )
2
: C C C C C
−= − − + − − − −
= −
A
P
M
A
a
L
b
B
B
M
P
0M
( ) ( )( ). ( (( ( ) )
(
C C
= − − −
( ) ( ).( ( (
) ( ( ) ( (
C C
= − − + +
= −
D5#?/ 8
&'!()*!&)#)+,#!-)
02
%
0 ) Q . = =
"
"
! 5 %
" "
!
$
$ Q
/
% " "
$ * 3
%
!
%
% "
" D %
!+A
! $
C
: / 9 ' / @
" *
3" *% 3
! "! #
# $% &
$
' (% )*+,
- %
% %
%$ -
% $ $
.
$( /
/ !"!
$ % %
0 $% ! "!
1
234"!$$56747
%% *+%
$ "88
[ ] = )"88,
9:$ ;< 9:$
234"!
;< = 1 /
#
% 234"!%
# = >
1 ) 234"!,
*+ ? $
!"!
7 %
$- % $ $
% %@$
- #
8 −
@
# -
$$ #
6 1 $ >
$ >% #
$ %$
! #
% % /
1
6 1 ?
$
0 % /
%
' !
$/%$ %$
- -
$
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
@ % #$ $
A
− B=5&
− BC )"+*D,
B=5)B=5,
$%
%
A
− B . )"+*D,&
− B
= >(%?
*+$ ?%
) #,
$ $ E%?
. $ ω $ $ )@/ 0
8FF", " 8
[ ] [ ]( ) G ω− = )" 8,
) #,
? λ $ "
[ ] [ ]( ) G λ− = )" ,
=
$$
0
% >
$$
,
6
$
B=5
% $ B=5
( $ >
$0 $
) ,
%
61 30 GGG3H3*I33
-'.)EB=5)B=5,"!EB
'B=5- $
# /
% $ ? $ /
$% $
$>%
=
% %
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
/
-'.) EB=5)B=5,"!E2
3 (
%
$
- 3>
>
$
# $- =
C
-'.)0BC EB
1
> (#$
#6 C
> "!5 "J
X
y
z
δZ
Zθ 2
2
Z1θ
z
y
X
Z1δ1δY
X1δ
Y2δ
Xδ 2
Yθ 1
Y2θ
2θX
Xθ 11
2
-'.),E= "!+
$
- $ @ $
$ >
(>
6 "!
@ "!
$ !"+*D
O
θxy
X
Y
Vi
Ui
θi
1 2
3 4
1
2
3
4
Rigidez infinitano plano
Rigidez infinitano plano
-'.)/0B" EB
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
2
5 "K % "+*D
"! ! )% ?,
$ $
$ ) ,5 "C
1U
V11θ
y
X
y
2U
2V2θ
X
[M2]
[M1] [M ]=[M ,M , I0 ]1 x1 1y 1
[M ]=[M ,M , I0 ]2x2 2y2
-'.)1E3$ "+*D)?,
" - $ %$
% $ $
%
$ ($-
@$
$ ) ,
/ $% >
/%>>L31/M>
% $$
"! =
/ "!
! $ $ !
)4 /8FNN,5 "O
Y
Z
XO
Z
O X
Y
Z
O X
Pórtico 2
Pórtico 1
Pórtico 1 + Pórtico 2
-'.)2E3$
$(> -
! $ %
= "! $ ?
$ $
4 $
$ #
P$ $
7
= =)7==8FNK,= ")@=8FF ,
$ =
(
$
#
8Q / $
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
3
%%8Q
)=@@38FF8&3/ GG8," "
888
βλ
=−
)" ",
= / %
! %?B=5
% (
$ /
1
3 "+*D $
$> *+ "!
% $ -
? 1 234"!
! ? $$ /
)B=5
"+*D,(*+
!""#$*$%#-'%'#
0 $
$$ % %
$$
$#
! / B=5
6B=5
$% )8! ! "!, $
$
I $
% % $
34
$ $ >
% / (
% $ $%
)RS14T 8FNF&4 8FF ,
a) b)
-'.)EBB=5A,/,
$ ( /)5
"N, / )U/ 8FFC,
>%
-
- $ )V $ 8FCO,
88 8 8" 8 8 8
8 "
"8 " "" " "
8
=
)" J,
$
$
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
3
$ " J
@ )8!,
) !, $ )"!,
Z
Y
X
1
4
3
2
5
8
7
3
2
1
4
6
Y
Z
X
1
2
Z
X
Y
a) b) c)
-'.)3E=B=5E, )8!,, ) !,,$)"!,
6 "!
$%
- #
>
0 B=5
)8!,5 "8G
1
P
b)
P
P P
P
A
a)
C
L
B
P
D
P P
L/3
L/3
L/3
L/3
2
3
4
5 6 7 8 9
10
11
12
13
-'.)4E! A,#, #)B=5,
3
= (
%
*+ >$ $
? $
# #
B=5
( # #
1 % B=5
$$1
6 ( #$(
% %8Q
$ 1 % 6>
1 %
) , $$ $
'% %
) ,
%% #
%8Q ) ,
[ ] = )" K,
$ [ ]
$
@ $ (
$
'
# (#
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
3
0 >$ $
$$
$ #
[ ] = )" C,
[ ]
[ ] [ ] [ ] = + )" O,
;< ( %)%8Q ,;<
) ; < ,
#
B=5)V GGG, ;<
[ ] = )" N,
;<
= )" F,
;< #
6 ;<$ %
6%
/ 6>$ %
λ ?
$
'-
;< $ $ 9:
$% ;< % .
$% $ 9:$ # (
λ= )" 8G,
3,
P
u
Modo instável
Modo estável
Ponto de bifurcação
-'.)EU
'
%$ %$
B $
$ 5 "88&>
$
[ ] G = )" 88,
3 >$
# . $
. @
$ " 88
[ ] [ ]( ) G λ+ = )" 8 ,
[ ] [ ] λ= − )" 8",
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
3/
;< % %
$ 9:λ ? %
.
$
[ ] [ ]( ) λ λ+ = )" 8J,
" 8J $
[ ] [ ]( ) 8 λ λ−
= + )" 8K,
" 8 ( $ $
)@/8FF",
[ ] [ ]( ) 8
G
λ×× ×
− = )" 8C,
[ ] 8 8 λ
× ××= )" 8O,
$ $ $ )$ ,
λ$ )$,
" 8C /
9:W9G: $
[ ] [ ]( ) G λ− = )" 8N,
" 8 %
[ ] [ ]( ) G λ+ = )" 8F,
λ
$ $ (
1 B=5 *+
31
@ $(
$ $ )0*XX0, -
%
0 0*XX0 $%
)@/8FF"&B+ GGG,A
− B7( &
− B=#&
− B&
− BY&
− B+3
U/V )8FOC, L
$ 3M $
% > $
$ )8FF", $$
% %
% =2+=5 $$
1 5=B2Z)B=5,
[ ] [ ] φ λ φ= − )" G,
9φ:$ λ $
$ 9φ:
6 $ ) ? λ, $ $ )
φ, " G
[ ] [ ] 8 8 8 φ λ φ= − )" 8,
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
32
2 #
$ 9 G :
[ ] ( ) [ ] 8 G8 8 φ λ= − )" ,
[ ] ( ) [ ] 8 G88 8
8 φ
λ= − )" ",
@;<9 G : $ 9:
[ ] ( ) 8 8 88 8
8
φλ
= )" J,
( ) 88 88 8
8 φ
λ= )" K,
#9φ: $ 9 G :9 :8
( )( ) ( )G
8
8
W 8
λ = )" C,
@ #
9φ: %# $ 9 G :9 :8
" C ?
λ8
0 #λ8 7T/
[ ] [ ]
8 G8 8
8 8
λ
−=
− )" O,
3
! ( ;<
[ ] 8
− = )" N,
$
[ ]
88
8 8
=
− )" F,
( #λ8 $
A
! G
[ ] 8
−= −
[ ] =
[ ]
=
−
( ) [ ]
λ = −
λ=
4 ?δ
( ) ( )( )
8 8 8
8
λ λδ
λ−
−≤
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
33
0
+ 3/ $ $ $
>
[ ] [ ] [
8
φ φ=
= − −
)" "G,
$ 9 [ :S$ 9 :
0 B=5/% 1
30 GGG3H3*I33
/
#*+0*XX0
!""#5'#067)$
-
> ! >
1
2
3
4
-'.) E!
44
=% $ "!
! $"!(>% .B"
)"+*D,61 $$ )234"!,
!
P
A
O X
C
Y
E
P
P
B
D
P
F
L2
CD
1
L1
3 4
2
L1
A B
O X
Y
xyθ
-'.)0B234"!8, !, !
= 234"!
# #;<"886
%
% $ 0 $
# ! >
$
# #
- $
# " +*D
$
) , %
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
4
61 234"! $$56747
OO=
>
5674701 3
$- %#
//
/ $)@ U GG",5
%
1 $ >$ E
!"! (
#
H
L1
A B
D C
L2
PO
P
HH
P
E
OP
F
I
ZP
J
K
P Z
G
X
PY
X
L
PY
1
L1
A
L2 3O
4
θxy
B
X
DY
2
C
a) b) -'.),0B234"!E0 "!A,,
6 234"!"+*D
*+ "! "!
! 5 "8""8J
@ >$ %
? $
234"!
1
4
=
&234"! $
A
− 2 # &
− 0 - &
− 0 &
− @ &
− = )# ,&
− \ &
− B !&
@ "! !
%
" 5 "8K
δ 1Y
1
δ 1X
Y
X
22δX
X
2Yδ
Y1θZ
Zθ 2
-'.)/E= !+
! G#T$
9]: # 5 "8C =
# % $ * 2
# $
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
4
2
1i
E, A, I
L
j
5
y
x
3 6
4
-'.)10= !0
3 .
# 8Q
" "
" "
G G G G
8 C 8 CG G
C J C G G
; <
G G G G
8 C 8 CG G
C C JG G
− −
= − −
)" "8,
%
= ∆ )" " ,
95: $ ;<
9]:$
" " ( "88
#
4,
@ ^XB ] ]X θ
%
" "
" "
G G G G
8 C 8 CG G
C J C G G
G G G G
8 C 8 CG G
C C JG G
!
"
!
"
!
"
θ
− ∆
∆ − =
− −
!
"
θ
∆
∆
)" "",
2 ;<
8 8 " "
" J
8 8 " "
J "
G G G G
8 C 8 CG G
C J C G G
; <
G G G G
8 C 8 CG G
C C JG G
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
− −
= − −
)" "J,
(
5 "8C 8φ φ "φ Jφ
8Q
$
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
4/
,J" 8) =φ #$) ,A
8
"
J
")8 ,
" 8
J J
" 8
φ φ β β
βφβ β
φ φ β β
φ φ β β
= = −
= + = −
)" "K,
πβ = = = )" "C,
=
π= )" "O,
234"!
#$$$ *$T@/
)8FKC,A
_`G) ,A
( )
8
%
α α αα α
α αα α α
− ⋅ = − −= − ⋅
)" "N,
πα ρ= )" "F,
ρ =
41
_aG) , A
)8 /) ,,
/
) ,
) , /) ,
%
%&
%&
γ γ γγ γ
γ γγ γ γ
− ⋅ = −−= − ⋅
)" JG,
B /)B /
8FKK&^ B /8FCK,
$ $ % .
# 0 %$
#
( )
( )
8
8
%
% π ρ+=
+ − )" J8,
'()(*+,)
+ =
=%
8φ φ "φ Jφ " "J ,J" 8) =φ
;<#
" J
8 8 " "
8 8 " "
" J
J "
G G G G
G G G G
8 8 C CG G
; <8 8 C C
G G
C C J G G
C C JG G
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
− − −
= −
− −
)" J ,
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
42
^Xθ
; <
!! !" !
"! "" "
! "
θ
θ
θ θ θθ
=
)" J",
^/ X$ θ(
$$)*'%9("+).+)'+$*:)'+#
' $ $
6
# $)5 "8O,
b)a)
-'.)2EB A, #, $
# #
# %
( 0 $ #
# % $
3 ! >$
%
# $
4
@ # 0 $ %
A
− 0 #
P
L
A
C
P P
B
D
P
J
π=
-'.)00 !#$
A
P
C
P
P
B
D
P
L
GJ
π=
-'.)300 !#
− 0 $
A
P
C
B
P
D
P P
L
π= =
-'.) 4E0 !$$
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
43
A
P
B
P
C D
P P
L
G K
π=
-'.) E0 !$
6 $ "8N "8F " G " 8 $
% $ # >
G K J < < )" JJ,
P% # $
) #
$,
%#;''""$"$:)'+#"$%:#6'<#
# $
/
/% $
%
/ >- $
θ
%
(
#$
@ /%/ %
θ θθ θ = )" JK,
6 # %$
θ
4
G θθ θ = )" JC,
> %
Gθθ = )" JO,
$$)*'%9("+).+)'+
3 # $ > $ "
$
$ 3 $
$ " ? bc
bc `G > $ bc $
? #
6 $ $%
/
# ?
- -λ λ= ⋅ )" JN,
- # bc W8 -λ # (
-$ ?
0 % # ;<)" J",
(
[ ]" J
J "
J
J
, ,
, ,
θθ
φ φ
φ φ
=
)" JF,
! ;θθ <)" JF, $ $ λ
; θθ < ) " JK, 6 $ ?
bc % $ λ A
Gθθ = )" KG,
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
$ λ $ $
$$ $
$ @ $
$ ; θθ <
$" K8
[ ] [ ] θθ = + )" K8,
;U<; θθ < ;!<
; θθ <!" JO" K8
[ ][ ] [ ]( )[ ] 8 G θθ
− = + = )" K ,
0 λa bc ; θθ <
[ ][ ] 8
− ; θθ <$
(
[ ][ ] [ ]( )8 G
− + = )" K",
λW bc [ ][ ] 8
− $ λW8 λWG
φ" φJ ( $ 88
$ $ $ [ ][ ] 8
−
GKGKdλ$ [ ][ ] 8
−
$ >$ λW8λW bc
0 $ $ (
[ ][ ] 8
− ? bc $
; θθ < )
λa bc , $ ; θθ < $6 ;θθ <WG
$% λW bc $ ; θθ < % λ W G 0 λ` bc #
$ $
6$ λ % ;Gλ%#<
#
J&
λ ρ
ρ= = )" KJ,
#5 "8O
0 $ $
Y
%#;''""$"$:)'+#"$%:#*:=$'#
@ # ; <
!
! !!
θθ θ
θ
=
)" KK,
bc >% / $ λ G θλ λ< <
; θθ < $ # ;θθ <
8 @/λ^
$ ? $
# $ %
$ λ
G ! θλ λ< < )" KC,
@#; θθ <8
8[
!! !! ! ! θ θθ θ
− = − )" KO,
; [!! < (
/ $ 6
/
[
! !! ! = )" KN,
$$)*'%9("+).+)'+
I$ ; [!! < !λ λ= $>
$
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
/ 9
! : 6
%$ %$ /
9
! :WG / >
[ G
!! ! = )" KF,
; [!! <WG 6 ? !λ λ= %
$ λ ; [!! <WG 3 /
$%
$ #-λ
- -λ λ= ⋅ )" CG,
- # λW8
0 $ λ
; <
3 ; [!! < $ # .
6
# ;G λ%#<
λ%#W bc #
,%#;''""$"$:)'+#+*;))#"'.%'#
'
#
/ ' $$
%
/ #= $
$ $
$
! %
,
L
H
A
P
C
B
P
D
L
A
H
B
P
B
D
P
L
H
A
P
B
B
P
D
-'.) E0 !$$% $
0 $%/
#$
3 5 " "
#
PPPP
L
H
H
P
P
H
L
P P P
P P P
P
P
P
L
H
H
H
-'.) E0 ! $
#
$ >
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
/
/ 0
#
$ % # >
$ =#
#
/ $
0 -
%
$
0 $
% % %
#
/ =
% $1 234"!
' $
#
% $
$ %
$ $
$ % % %
#
$ ? % $
G ! θλ λ< < )" C8,
3 $
(# ; < >
$ (#
' $ #
$
L M$ 5 " J
/ $ $
1
; < $ #
;
!! <
L L
H
H
P P
P P
P
P
L
H
P
H
P
P P
L
P
P
-'.) ,E0 ! $
@ # %
#
$ 3 #
$ ? bc
$ $
# =
$ # (
(%
# $
$
!! !" ! !
"! "" " "
! "
!
"
θ
θ
θ θ θθ θ
∆ = ∆
)" C ,
! / "$ θ(
! $ $
[ ] [ ]" " θ θ= $
/
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
2
[ ] [ ][ ] [ ] [ ][ ] [ ]8 8[[!! !! ! ! !" "" "! θ θθ θ
− − = − − )" C",
% )/ ,
0 %; [[!! <A
8 3[ ] (#
#[ ] %A
[ ][ ] [ ][ ] [ ]
G
G
G G G
!
! !!
θθ θ
θ
=
)" CJ,
# / $
A
[ ]
" J
"
8 8 " "
8 8 " "
J C C
J C C
C C 8 8
C C 8 8
. .
. .
/. /.
/. /.
/. /. / /
/. /. / /
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
− ⋅ ⋅
− ⋅ ⋅
= − − − ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ − ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ⋅
)" CK,
/
−= )" CC,
.
. ./
−= )" CO,
) ., ) .,
3% # (#
[ ] %A
[ ] [ ] [ ][ ] [ ]
G G G
G
G!! "!
"! ""
=
)" CN,
#>
[ ]
. .
. .
/ / / /. / /.
/ / / /. / /.
/ /. / /. / /
/ /. / /. / /
− ⋅ − ⋅
− − ⋅ ⋅ =
⋅ − ⋅ − − ⋅ ⋅ −
)" CF,
! ; [[!! <
[[ [ [!! !! !! = + )" OG,
[ ] [ ] [ ] [ ]8[!! !! ! !
θ θθ θ−
= − ⋅ ⋅ )" O8,
[ ] [ ] [ ] [ ]8[!! !! !" "" "!
−
= − ⋅ ⋅ )" O ,
(# ) ,
#
# # $ ; [[!! <
; [!! < %
# # ;θθ <8
− (
#
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
3
; [!! < !
),; "" < 8
−
$ %
3 / #
/
; [[!! < % . ( $
; [!! <$ ; [[
!! <
= # $ #
$ %
/%#;''""$"$:)'+#
@>%
! >
> $ >
/ ! $
; [!! <
; [[!! < #
$
; [[!! < $
; [!! < / $
$ % $$
/ ; [[!! < "!
"! !
#. $ >
!
"!
$ ( $ %$
) ,
! % 234"! %
"! !
4
/)'>"$)%#6)*9(
234"! %
% "+*D
G#T "!# .
> # T GR
)G#T, $ %
#T
$ 3
$ /
"! [ ]0 )" #" ,
/ > - >
% (
P
D
PλY
Z
λ
C
PX
5θ
E
λP
θ
Y
3 3
1
O
A
F
λP
D
44
xy
X
B
E
2
55
5θC
2
F
Pλ
A
5u
1
λ
B
O
-'.) /E6 "!
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
[ ] A
[ ] ( ) ( ) 1 1 1 θ θ= )" O",
6/ ∆
0∆ #T
A
1 %∆ = ⋅ ∆ )" OJ,
1
( A
G G G G G G G G G
G G G G G G G G G
G G G G G G G G G
G G G
G G G G G G G G G G G G
1
%
%
%
%
=
)" OK,
( ) θ= ( )
% %θ=
G G G
G G G
G G G
G G G
1
1
11
1
=
)" OC,
! [ ]0
0∆
[ ]8
0 0
=
= )" OO,
-
0 A
[ ] [ ]
0 = )" ON,
/
[[!!
""OG
" ON
; <0 )"#",
[ ]0
0 ; <0 $$
#
/ $$)*'%9("+).+)'+
3 $
$ ? λ
0 W
[[!!
0
$
/ >
0
" OO
P
L
A
C
P P
B
D
P
P
P
L/2
J
π=
-'.) 1E0 !#$
!"#"$%&'#$('%$)$*!)'+
6 ? % $ > # $
! "!
# $ $ %#
$ ! #
# )5 " C,
3
!λ ? $
θλ ?
#
( ) ( )
! θλ λ λ≤ ≤ )" OF,
6 ? λ3 % $ λ ;0< #
$
/$$)*'%9("#*"#"$'%#;''""$
0 $ $ ?
$ Y
% $ $
;<;X<
;< $ ;X<
$ $ ;<6
$ $ )V GGG,
G 8 8 " 2 2 2 2 2−= ⋅ ⋅ )" NG,
2$ % ;2<
[ ]
2 2
2
2 2
− − − − − − − − − − − − − − − − = − − − − − − − − − − − − − − − −
)" N8,
,
?θ $
2 2
2 2
θθ
= = = = )" N ,
2 2 ⋅ = ?θ
6 $$$
8
2 2−= ⋅ ⋅ )" N",
$ $2
6 ? θ / 3 3 2 >
? $
( )
( ) ( )8
8 8
θ −
− −
=−
)" NJ,
6 $ $ Y
#
-
@ $ % "+*D 234"!
!"!>
/
7$ B=5 1 $ #
%
@ $
# $
! " #$
% &
&"
'
( (
(" )*+,-
( *.#/000
.*1* 23*.*"
'
( "'.*1* 23*.*
(
*.#/000"4
!
! " +& 5
! & %
& "'& %
&
6 ( 7"
. & )*+,-
% 5! "
' &
& 5 % /- ,-" .5 ! (
5 )*+,- &
" - *.# /000 .*1*
23*.*
8 )*+,- (
/- ,92:
.29 *.#/000.*1* 23*.*
( %;< ;<".*1*
23*.* & % &
% &
*.#/000"
# & 5 &
%" ' 5 & &
"
4& $ 5 & 6/-7 = 6>?@A7
&! /- " .
& B5 ( 55
& "
.
% &
&" . 5 /- C4D 6
7 & *E422"
F & %
& B
"
# & ,-
F 6>?@07 .%&
'!6/00/7 5
$ $ 5(" !
( %
% (
% ! "'
( & &
& ! "
&5 B
!"#$
%
− ) & (&G
− #5 H G
− #5 G
− 8 5G
− 4 & 56 ( 7G
− I 5 G
+ )*+,-*.# /000.*1* 23*.*
&" 8 6 7
% ( & "4
.29 " % &
& &
! J& 5 %
6 ((7
" 8
.*1* 23*.* &
6 7 6 7 5
& "
- , )*+,-
,92: ( &/-
> / > /, / , /
/ , / K/ /
> / > /, / , /
/ K / ,/ /
0 0 0 0
>/ L >/ L0 0
L K L /0 0
; <
0 0 0 0
>/ L >/ L0 0
L / L K0 0
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
− −
= − −
6K"/">7
&
D
K"> >φ /φ ,φ Kφ &
>M "
3
i1
2
y
L
E, A, I4
6
x
5
j
'"N4 &/-"9 & "
' & & &
J& 68 ,7" &$
& $ &
& "
# '*.#/000
! $ &
C4D" . 6@"07
& % %
6% &7" 8 (
$ ! F'O'+C)224)3C
81#4.F+4P+F)8.28 " %
: "
.*.#/000 6*.#/000/00/7
&
6*.#/000/00/&7
( ) 0 λ− ⋅ = 6K"/"/7
% λ 6 7 ϕ & 6 7" 4
%
& "
!"#$
(
2 &
:
/ /
/ /
,L , ,L ,
, K ,
,0 ,L , ,L ,
, , K
φ
φ
− − −
= − − − − −
ν= ⋅ 6K"/",7
% :
/ /
,
/ /
>/ L >/ L
L K L /
>/ L >/ L
L / L K
φ
φ
− − −
= − − − − −
ν= ⋅ 6K"/"K7
%% >M "'
% %
(
[ ] ν= + = + ⋅ 6K"/"A7
'.*1* 5
( *.#/000"
'"NO4.C,N4 &/-6.*1*7"
)*
4
&
% ! 6.*1* /00> * >???7" #
5 "'
&! QO4.C,R %/-
& 5B S 1 (T
6.*1*/00,7"
4 %
"- &
".
% % B.F4.6% 7)TT6
7E4)9E+6 DK"/7*E4.FT6
7 )*+F 6 7 .--C.** 6
7"* *E4.FT ( T
% "
. % # U
6>?L@7
[ ]
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
( )( )( ) ( )
( )( )
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
( )( )( ) ( )
( )( )
, / , /
/ /
, / , /
/ /
0 0 0 0
>/ L >/ L0 0
> > > >
K /L L0 0
> > > >
0 0 0 0
>/ L >/ L0 0
> > > >
/ KL L0 0
> > > >
φ φ φ φ
φ φφ φ φ φ
φ φ φ φ
φ φφ φ φ φ
−
− −+ + + +
+ −
− + + + += −
− − − − + + + +
− + − − + + + +
6K"/"L7
/
>/
φ = 6K"/"V7
!"#$
)
%
"
[ ]/ /
/ /
0 0 0 0 0 0
L > L >0 0
A >0 A >0
> / > >0 0
>0 >A >0 ,0
0 0 0 0 0 0
L > L >0 0
A >0 A >0
> > > /0 0
>0 ,0 >0 >A
−
− − = − − −
− −
6K"/"@7
8$% .29 & 5
[ ] [ ] φ λ φ= 6K"/"?7
;P< %;*< WφX
λ"
- &
B
− 4( 6CF7G
− 4( 6C87"
6CF7 6
(5 7
&
& & 9Y" 6C87
% B
− 6 J&7G
− !"#62Z27G
)
− $"%&&'"(62 ZF7G
− )& '"(62 ZF7G
− * & '"( 6. ZF
7"
4 & & &
6&;< ;< K"/"?7
! ! "
' 23*.* 5( .*1*
H
*.#/000 % & !"
'")NOC,N4 &/-623*.*7"
! /- 6&57 % 5
QOC,R & P!!DK", 623*.*/00K /00K7"'
, 5 6 ( 5 7 K
& B3= θ5 ( 36 75 "
'"NOC,N4 &/-623*.*7N & "
!"#$
))
4 &
! & ".% %
5B. 6% 7 ) 6
(T7 )6 % (T7"
8 & C4D (
! ) != + = ⋅ ⋅ + ⋅ ⋅
6K"/">07
; <.*1*
%; < "
.& 6 7 6 & 7
( ) 0 λ+ Φ = 6K"/">>7
> λ= 6K"/">/7
λ> "
6 7B
− "+,"*(-G
− %""'"("%G
− "( "./G
− "#"
# &!
(
$)*+,-". C4D
%)*+,-
6 ( (7 "
)
. & ( $
!5 5
%$
( ( &
5 /"
' ( ! /- &
6DK"A7 5. 6>??,7
&
4)94D"
P=100 kN/m
1 1 1
2 2
66
3
'" N#5 >6. >??,7"
. & >00 U:
ZK">"
4 469#7 )(6K7 )Y6
K7 .6/7> /00"0 ,0@/,"0 ?/,?"0 >L/",/ /00"0 K@/00"0 />K/"0 >>L"0
+,"N8 6. >??,7"
# &
$ & ( % &
5 .
6>??,7 $
% 6DK"L7"
!"#$
)
P=300 kN P=600 kN P=300 kN
1
2
1
2
13
6 6
'"N#5 . 6>??,7 "
'5 )*+,-*.#/000.*1* 23*.* &
ZK"/"
+ 4)94D[ *.#/000 .*1* 23*.* )*+,-
-&6. >??,7 >/,"?V >/>"@0 >/,">0 >/,"/>
8 6 7 >/0"?0 >//"?0 >//"@@ >//"VV
[# ,5& > K"
+,"N# >\ "
' & & &
5 6 ( (7 >]
% &
"
'"%N8>\ & "
# & 55 6D
K"V7 & " . 6>??,7 >\
A\ 4)94D"
)
-./-/0/1/2
5
5( 55 6DK"@7"
# & (
5 6
7"
a) b)
C
D
λP λP
HE 200B
HE
200
B
HE
200
B
A
B
5.0m
7.5m
D
HE 200B
HE
200
B
C
HE
200
B5.0m
A
7.5m
B
λP Pλ
'"&N#5/-B75(&755 "
- (
K"/"> 6)*+,-7" .5 !
(5 (
& "
D ( ( "
!^/00
&^/00
^>A
^ ?
^ >@
.^V@>0/ )(^AL?L0000K )^/00,0000K
+,")NE4/00ON
!"#$
)%
. 5 & ST6/-7
& 1T"3 */,A
5 4^/00 >0LU# #ν^0",
ρ^V"@A+:,"
8$% (
5 ( 55 " .
( & % F 86/0007"4
5"
3 4 5"",67859 :5
DADA
C
1θ
k
B
k
C
2θ
k
B
k
H
L
H
L
1,1 1,2 2,1 2,2
'"(N#5/- 5(N4 "
. & & %
>> >/
/> //
; <
=
6K"/">,7
&0+0102-&
, , K
K , ,
K K /
; </ K K
! !3 !3
!3 !3 3)
4
4
φ φ φ
φ φ φ
+ =
+
6K"/">K7
1564
)&
( )
( )
, , ,
, K
> 0
3)!
!3 !3
7 8
7
φ φ φ
φ φ
= = = = = =
6K"/">A7
' _&
( ) 0 = 6K"/">L7
$
,
,
K K /
0/ K K
4
4
φ
φ
+ = =
+
6K"/">V7
, ,
>6 >76 7 0
,φ φ+ + = 6K"/">@7
& , 0,,,,,,φ = − 88≈2591
/
/ //"K> /,"V?
8
πλ = = = 6K"/">?7
>0@,@"L?8 = "
8 & `> `/ &
%
3 )θ θ= − 6K"/"/07
DK">0"
' % )*+,-
565(7_(^>0@//"LA5("
!"#$
)(
8 )*+,-& 0">A]"
A D
P
B
P
C
'"*N#5/-NC & "
# 5 *.#/000.*1* 23*.*
&
% &
ZK"K"
5D(6_ >0@,@"L?7
4 C 6a&7 *.#/000 23*.* .*1* )*+,-
*/U 2 .Y> >0K,@?A /?>/0 >@//K >0@/, ?@"?] L/"@] K0"@]/ >/L>, >>LA0 >>0?0 >0@/, >K"/] V">] /"K], >>LVV >>000 >0?0/ >0@/, V",] >"L] 0"V]K >0?@@ >0@@0 >0@A/ >0@/, >"A] 0"A] 0",]@ >0/A@ >0@,0 >0@/@ >0@/, A"A] 0"0] 0"0]>L >00V/ >0@,0 >0@/L >0@/, V"A] 0"0] 0"0],/ >00/L >0@,0 >0@/L >0@/, V"?] 0"0] 0"0]
+,"N4 &N#5 ("
8 *.#/000 &
H " '
.*1* 23*.* & .*1*
! ! "8
& "
Z C4D
, & & ,]" -
! & *.# /000 H
*
, && ,]
& K "8
& (
" ' .*1* !
>] , "'
23*.* 5( .*1* (
@ &"
10838
8000
13000
18000
23000
28000
33000
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32
Discretização (# elementos)
P cr
ítico
x
Valor exacto
ANSYS
LUSAS
SAP2000
;"<9 =N# 5/- 5("
. (
% & & 9% K">" =
K &
6 K &7
" . (
& H
H
&"
!"#$
# % 5
& DK">>"
>\ /\ ,\
K\ A\ L\
'"N#5 5(N & "
' & 5 55 6D
K"@&7 % "
3 4 5"",6785>8?6 5
L
H
A D
1,1B
k
θ1
L
A D
C1,2k
B
2,1k
C2,2k
θ2
k 1,3 2,3k
A D
B C
L
k3,1 k3,2
k3,3
'"-#5/- 55 N4 "
(
>> >/ >,
/> // /,
,> ,/ ,,
=
6K"/"/>7
, //
, //
/ / > >/ / ,
K @ K >/
, , /
K K @ >/; <
, , /
>/ >/ >/6 7
/ /
! !
3) 3)
! 3) ! 3)
4
4
φ φ
φ φ
φ φ φ φ
− +
− = + − − +
6K"/"//7
1564
! 3)
φ φ φ= = 6K"/"/,7
_&
( ) 0 = 6K"/"/K7
!"#$
)
, //
, //
/ / > >/ / ,
K @ K >/
, , /
K K @ >/0
, , /
>/ >/ >/6 7
/ /
! !
3) 3)
! 3) ! 3)
4
4
φ φ
φ φ
φ φ φ φ
− +
− = + = − − +
6K"/"/A7
/> , /K 6> 7 , 0φ φ φ+ − = 6K"/"/L7
$ &
/
/ /0"LV 0"LV L"L>
8 8
8
πλ≈ → = = = 6K"/"/V7
,0>/"0K8 = "
& `>`/ b >\ &
> / > /
> /
>"K/K 0",,, >",/L : 0
0",,, >"K/K >",/L : 0 >",/A
θ θ θ θ θ
θ θ θ
+ − ∆ = = = → + − ∆ = ∆ = ⋅ ⋅
6K"/"/@7
DK">,"
A D
P
B
P
C
'")N#5/-NC & "
3)*+,- _5 ^,00?"//
(
0"0?]"
5D(6_ ,00?"//7
4 C 6a&7 *.#/000 23*.* .*1* )*+,-
*/U 2 .Y> ,,>A ,/A> ,0,K ,00? >0"/] V"K] 0"@]/ /?K> ,0/V ,0>L ,00? /"/] 0"L] 0"A], /?,, ,0>, ,0>0 ,00? /"A] 0">] 0"0]K /?,> ,0>0 ,00? ,00? /"L] 0"0] 0"0]@ /?,0 ,00? ,00? ,00? /"L] 0"0] 0"0]>L /?/? ,00? ,00? ,00? /"V] 0"0] 0"0],/ /?/? ,00? ,00? ,00? /"V] 0"0] 0"0]
+," N4 &N#5 55 "
# 5 &
& ZK"A"
3012
2900
2950
3000
3050
3100
3150
3200
3250
3300
3350
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32
Discretização (# elementos)
P cr
ítico
x
Valor exacto
ANSYS
LUSAS
SAP2000
;"<9 =N# 5/- 55 "
!"#$
8 *.#/000 6 (
7 .*1* ! !
"'23*.* 5(&.*1*
, &"9%
K"/ & &
("' &
DK">K"
>\ /\ ,\
K\ A\ L\
'"N#5 55 N & "
8 5 5( 5 55
H &
% !
5("
-111.@
. %
5 &
&& $5" H
%
! "
% 5 %&
&
&"
# 5 &
5
% 6 7 *E422
*.#/000". ! %
% "
. & !
C4D
& E4 /00O" D K">A %
*E422 "
b
h
tf
tw
r
tf
twh
b
ni nj
X
Z
HE 200B SAP 2000 (SHELL)
'" N# E4/00O *E422"
. E4 /00O C4D*E422
ZK"L"
!67 &67 67 67 67/00 /00 ?0 >A0 >@
+,"N8 E4/00O"
. *E422 ! 5 % &
& "'5& &
KV@ >"00 V
!"#$
%
". 562^A"0GE^V"A7
5 4^/00 9#" ' 5
& & "
A
B
5.0m
7.5m
D
HE 200B
HE
200
B
C
HE
200
B
λP Pλ
λP λP
HE 200B
HE
200
B
HE
200
B
5.0m
A
7.5m
BC
D
'"NC 6*E4227N9 565( 55 7"
*E422
*E422"
% "#
!
% *E422".
! "
' $%
& E4/00O6>A7".
% ZK"V"
#
& "
&
3 4 .8" =,67859 :5
8 &("4
"
C _ _ _
>\ V?KL"A? @0KV",L @0A@"/>/\ ?/@/",L ?A?,"K> ?VK@"@A,\ >?0KV"AL >?>K>"A@ >?>A,"?LK\ >?LA,"VK >??K,"K> >??LV"/0A\ ,0V?A"K@ ,>>@0"KK ,>/>?"VAL\
+>
,>>>A",>
+/
,>,0@"LA
+,
,>,,K">K
HE
200
B
A
B HE 200B
Pλ
HE
200
B
D
λP
C
C _ _ _
>\ @0K>"0L @0A0"/L >0>00",?/\ ?V,0"?A ?V?@"?/ >>?>L"?,,\ >?>,@"?@ >?>K?"0@ /K,>K"V>K\ >??KL"V@ >??L/"?0 /A,/L"V>A\ ,>>@V"0L ,>/>@"LK K,L00"0@L\
+K
,>/AL",,
+A
,>,>?",A
C
&67
KKA/>"@V
+,"%N# 5*E422 5("
' % *E422 _
&
!"#$
(
" %(
&>\ />",/]
& & "
DK">V &
ZK"V". 3"
>\ /\ ,\
K\ A\ L\
'"%NC 6*E4227NC & N#5 5("
# % & &
5 & "
=
" 4 %
5 & 5
6& & 7"
Z 5 & 5
% *E422 6 7 %
& %
&
"
*
5 &
&$ &!"
3 4 .8" =,6785>8?6 5
' & 5 55
5 5("
ZK"@ &
"
C _ _ _
>\ //>0L@ /,>?/, /K>@>,/\ V?V/0? @0AK0A @0LA,L,\ ?KA,/K ?L?L?> ?@,>L?K\ >?0?0,A >?>A@A, >?>V,,VA\ /0VLKV, />0@/KV />>,LLVL\
+>
,0@V0VV
+/
,>>?/,V
+,
,>//?,@
HE
200
B
HE
200
B
A D
PλB
HE 200B C
Pλ
C _ _ _
>\ /K>,/V /KA>/K /?,>L//\ @0L/K/ @0L@?/ >0>00K0,\ ?@/,KV ?@VVK/ >/0K0L,K\ >?>V0KL >?>VV@/ /K,>A>0A\ />>,0@K />>AK0, /L?A>0/L\
+K
,>/0?L0
+A
,>/,AL,
C
&67
K,L00V/
+,"&N# 5*E422 55 "
!"#$
= % *E422
_& %(>\
/K"A?] 5 5 (
&
"
>\ /\ ,\
K\ A\ L\
'"&NC 6*E4227NC & N#5 55 "
D K">@
& 5 55 ". 3"
))-./1;A1BC;
& &
"- &
&
&B ".
& & 5
" .
& &
"
4 (
& "
D K">? 5 &
( "
5.0m
HE
200
B
HE
200
B
7.5m
A C
HE 200B
Pλ
B D
λP
HE
200
B
HE
200
B
A
5.0m
7.5m
C
B HE 200B
λP
D
Pλ
a) b)
'"(N#5/- 75(&755 "
4 5 *.#/000 %
K &" #
0"0 >"0 >0
$ "
3 4 .8" =,67859 :5
%
& 5
6 8>7"
- Na &C > / , K @ >L ,/>\ >@,KV",A >0K0@"V, >0>@K"A@ >0>00",? >00,/"/> >00>V"V@ >00>K",A/\ /VKAA"AL >/>?/"A/ >/0,L">A >>?>L"?, >>@>A">A >>V?,">, >>V@V"@@,\ ?,,/@A",0 ,AKA?"K> /A0//",0 /K,>K"V> /,KKL"/> /,/A0"0A /,/0/"?LK\ ,?,/>"A0 /A@0A"A, /A,/L"V> /KK,A"L0 /K//K"A/ /K>V,"A/A\ >0K?K/"0A LK0VV"00 K,L00"0@ K0@0>"K> ,?@,L"KV ,?L0/"/AL\ >/0@V>"?A L@?/@K> KKA/>"@V K/>@@",, K>>V/"L, K0?/,"V0
+,"(N#5 5(6 7N# _"
!"#$
)
& ,
& ,] ( λ"
F 6U":7C 0"0 U >"0 0 U >"0 / U >"0 K U >"0 L U >"0 >0 c>\ @L,>"K> @L,>"?@ @L@L"L> ?@00A> >00?L"LK >0>00,? >0>00",?/\ @L,@"LA @L,?"/> @L?,"V? >0V,0>, >>@?@"V> >>?>L?, >>?>L"?,,\ /,L?/"?@ /,L?,">? /,V>,"K, /K>VV>L /K,>/"?A /K,>KV> /K,>K"V>K\ /,V>,"V0 /,V>,"?> /,V,K",K /KL/@/K /A,>K"V/ /A,/LV> /A,/L"V>A\ K,00A"AV K,00A"VV K,0/A"/K K,KV/LL K,A?@"KL K,L000@ K,L00"0@L\ K,0A>"@@ K,0A/"0@ K,0V>"/@ K,@@V@K KKA>0"?@ KKA/>@L KKA/>"@V
+,"*N#5 5(6aK&7N_ "
ZK">0
& " 9% K", &
& "
0,0E+00
5,0E+03
1,0E+04
1,5E+04
2,0E+04
2,5E+04
3,0E+04
3,5E+04
4,0E+04
4,5E+04
5,0E+04
0,0E+00 2,0E+04 4,0E+04 6,0E+04 8,0E+04 1,0E+05
k - rigidez da mola (kN.m/rad)
P. c
rític
o
1º modo
2º modo
3º modo
4º modo
5º modo
6º modo
;"<9 =)N= _6U7 & 65(7"
. 9% K", (
"
9%K"K &
(
& &
"
10838
0,0E+00
2,0E+03
4,0E+03
6,0E+03
8,0E+03
1,0E+04
1,2E+04
0,0E+00 2,0E+03 4,0E+03 6,0E+03 8,0E+03 1,0E+04
k - rigidez da mola (kN.m/rad)
P. c
rític
o
1º modo
valor exacto
;"<9 =N= _6U7>\ & 65(7"
>0]6 (7"
3 4 .8" =,6785>8?6 5
'
& &
ZK">> &"
- Na &C > / , K @ >L ,/>\ /?L,,A /?K>>V /?,,AV /?,>L/ /?,0>V /?/?@V /?/?@0/\ >@,KV,@ >0K0@VK >0>@KA? >0>00K0 >00,/// >00>VV? >00>K,L,\ /VKAV@, >/,@V/? >/>L?V? >/0K0L, >>?,/// >>?0@?/ >>?0,,@K\ >@L,L0>LA ,AKA??V /A0//@A /K,>A>0 /,KKLA> /,/A0,K /,/0,/AA\ K>K>?K@ /VA>@AK /L?A>0/ /A@?A,K /ALKV@@ /AA@@>?L\ >0K?K,/, LK0VV,K K,L00V/ K0@0>LL ,?@,LL? ,?L0/KL
+,"N#5 55 6 7N# _"
!"#$
4 % &
K &"
F 6U":7C 0"0 U >"0 0 U >"0 / U >"0 K U >"0 L U >"0 >0 c>\ >>>AK, >>>A@, >>AK0/ /,VL@/ /?/,@L /?,>L/ /?,>L//\ @L,A0K @L,AL> @L@?L, ?@00A/ >00?LLA >0>00K0 >0>00K0,\ ?A>LAA ?A>L?0 ?AA>K> >>0/KLL >/0/K,> >/0K0L, >/0K0L,K\ /,V0,KA /,V0,LL /,V/,V@ /K>VVV> /K,>,,, /K,>A>0 /K,>A>0A\ /KL>VL/ /KL>V?> /KLKLKK /A?/?// /L?,,,/ /L?A>0/ /L?A>0/L\ K,0/?>V K,0/?,V K,0K@K? K,KV,@@ K,A??>0 K,L00V/ K,L00V/
+,"N#5 55 6aK&7_ "
-
% 6ZK">/7".
% 9%K"A"
0,0E+00
5,0E+03
1,0E+04
1,5E+04
2,0E+04
2,5E+04
3,0E+04
3,5E+04
4,0E+04
4,5E+04
5,0E+04
0,0E+00 2,0E+04 4,0E+04 6,0E+04 8,0E+04 1,0E+05
k - rigidez da mola (kN.m/rad)
P. c
rític
o
1º modo
2º modo
3º modo
4º modo
5º modo
6º modo
;"<9 = N= _6U7 655 7"
4
" 5 &
! L0]
&
! &
"
8
&
5 55
67 "
-./)-DD+13(&*4
5
D"K">V". 5/- )*+,-
% 6DK"/0&7"
4 5 F 6>?@07 &
( & " .
5 %$ α>α/α,
αK "
4 % %& &
8&$ & "
1
4 3
2
1 2
4 3
1
a) b)
B'
H
Y
D'
A
D
O
B
X
PZ
L2
C'
C
L2 3
L1
A B
xyθ
O
DY
2
X4
C
L1
A'
α α P
α PPα
'"*N#5,-F 6>?@07"
. $ .O8-
". 5 BEL,A06/A0 72>^,@>0 6>A0 7
!"#$
%
2/^,0K@6>/0 7"3 %d>0(,,&
B .^LA0,"/ / 6>0"0@ "/7 )Y^V//>A,/0 K 6>V,"K?@ "K7
)(^>K//V/L0K6A,K">@/"K7 9J ^>V"?0VU/6L/,AP"/75
4^/00">(>0L U:/ 6/?000 U7 9^@0(>0L U:/ 6>>L00 U7" .
( & DK"/0&7"
#5 α> α/ α, αK6#7;P< &6#7;P<
D>> 0"A00 >"000 0"A00 0"/A0 A?0"0 A?A"@D>/ >"000 >"00A >"000 >"000 L0>"/ L>/"0D>, >"000 0"00A 0"000 0"000 A/0", A/0"0D>K >"000 >"000 0"000 0"000 AL0"0 A,/"0D>A 0"000 >"000 >"000 0"000 AVL"0 L0K"@D>L >"000 0"00A >"00A 0"000 A?0"0 L0V"VD>V >"000 >"000 >"000 0"000 A?>"0 A?L"?
F 6>?@07">,?,>,?V"&8*.#?0"
+,")-# 687+"
4 5 F 6>?@07
.%&'! 6/00/7 & D>
6^> V7"
D *.#?0 6+ & 5 >??/7
d E&&! 6>??>7 $
*.#/000".
$ " ' &
ZK">,
"
D !&D>/ α>α/α, αK
& )*+,-" 4 &
*.# /000 &
F 6>?@07"
8)*+,-& L0,"L %5(
687 ^ L0>"/ 6Z K">,7" '
6*.#/0007 687 ^L>,"> &
6*.#?07 /] ("
# &
& b(^>"0bY^0"0 θ(Y^0"0 &
)*+,- *.#/000 $ % & DK"/>"
&
7 &7
'"N#5,-F 6>?@07N- B7 &7"
-% )*+,- (
,- 5"
-./)-/0
#&)*+,- 5
$ 64D9EDK"//7"
H
PλY
Z
C
PλG
2
2
1
D
A
3
C
X
Y
O
θxy
B
4L
L1
H
L2
1L
X
A B
λλ
D
PE
P
F
O
'"N#5,- N5("
8
5 5("4 & &
& 6 7"
!"#$
(
>\ /\
,\ K\
A\ L\
'")N#5,- 5(NC & "
%E4/00O1^2^V"A4^A"0
5 ^/009#"'5 )*+,- *.#/000
K &"
' & )*+,- 6λ^>/A?"/7 *.# /000 6λ^>,,/"/7
&"D
& 6DK"/,7 )*+,- &
*
! .29 5 ,-
$ "
)
. )*+,- &
& % &
5"F
& *.#/00023*.* .*1*
( "8
& Q (R
& "' & .*1* 23*.*65 &
/-7 & )*+,-
*.#/0006 H
&7"
. (
6 7& 55 "
!
" # ! $ % !
&'() *
(+#,,,"+% !
- &'() !. /
-(+#,,,"
+ (+# ,,, * +'(0( 12(+(
% * ! $
! % !
" 3 +'(0( 12(+(
4 - % 4 (+#,,,
! -
4 !
! -
$!"
#5 6!.
6
6% 4 7
4 % %
85
6 "
3
. 4
"
9$% /
% !%
- :;<=>91;<??"
# .
!@
− #!A
− # A
− 1!/!! A
− 9! A
− B !/-A
− &-A
− C. A
9 4$
"
& . 5
$%
"
! !.
"# .
!"B
!
.
"
&%4 /
6 !.
!
!"
D 4 -
!%!
*&'()"
!"#!$%
&
'
E $ 4 %
! 4 !
/
"
F $ / !%
!! 4.
4 $ % ! $
-% " B
4 7 4!
"
E !444
$4/ 4
G;<<<@
− E.!% !
A
− 9 4 %
"
($ 4 4
! !
$
"
+ 4/ ! B9((;<=H4
.
"2.%%
!B. 4
ψ= >"";
' . 4 . /
%5;7"+
(
;7 . . ψ )IF;<H;
;
;
ψ =−
>""
4.!.!
4 ! ! !
J ≥ "
3
44/ "
( ! 5
4/@
− 3A
− E A
− 4 "
# 4/.
$ "
5 !
@
− D- BA
P
P P
X
Y
O
θxy
P
)$*!KL@D- ."
!"#!$%
− ) A
X
Y
O
θxy
P P
P P
)$*!KL@) "
− D- "
θ
XO
xy
Y
P
P P
P
)$*!&KL@D- "
# / ! % MN !%O
% - 8 ! " 4
$
47"
PP
P PP P
P P P
P
P PPP
PP P P
PP PP
P
PP
)$*!(K("
' %
$
4 4 % "
& (
A B
4.0
C
4.0
E
4.0
CG
4.0
P
D
F
H
P
B
4.0
A
4.0
C
4.0
E
D
F
GC
4.0
HH
A
4.0
B
C
4.0
D
E
4.0
F
HHCG
4.0
P P
P P
PP
P P
P P
P P
P P
P P
B
4.0
A
PP
PP
4.0
C
4.0
E
D
F
P
GC
4.0
P
HH
HE
200
B
HE
200
B
HE
200
B
HE
200
B
HE
200
B
HE
200
B
HE 200B
HE 200B
HE 200B
HE 200B
HE 200B
HE 200B
HE
200
BH
E 2
00B
HE
200
B
HE
200
BH
E 2
00B
HE
200
B
HE
200
B
HE 200B
HE
200
BH
E 2
00B
HE 200B
HE 200B
HE
200
BH
E 2
00B
HE
200
B
HE
200
BH
E 2
00B
HE 200B
HE
200
B
HE
200
B
HE 200B
HE
200
B
HE 200B
HE
200
B
UPN 80
UPN 80
UPN 80
UPN
80U
PN 80
UPN
80
UPN
80
UPN
80
UPN
80
UPN
80UPN
80U
PN 80
λP>?< λP><< λPH< λPJJ<
+ !K(K#6"
DJE>";5 !
"3;Q
-!Q ;
! "3J%
$ / " ' 4 %
-9;"
3 (+#,,,% J
6;H"
4
!
!%
-"' . $.
- %
!;!"
!"#!$%
,
&- &.&/
&0%!$12 0!!
' %5
D!>">4
9.:,,"
L
A
HD C
B
P
H
E
P
F
O
I
H
O
Z
P
M
HK
PZ
P
PO
O
Z
P
GY
XP
X
J
P
N
P
LY
P
P
P
X
Y
A B
D
3
C
X
Y
O
θxy
2
4
1
2L
1L
2L
D
A B
E
O
Z
H
C
X
F
GY
PÓRTICO BASE
λ P
Pλ Pλ
λ P
1
)$*!KF "
+ .
4 . $ !
."'
- "
D .RB:RB,,: $
4 !4
"
3
'E>" %"
P,,
P,,
P;<
*P;;
P ;?
+P;"J< &-P">;=JJ &%P?">H>
J
+ !KRB,,:K !.
# !%
4 !%- ;,
! ;J< " B !
%$"3%
BP;,F#"
& 012!!
9 !&'()
! 4
% -"3
D! >"> 4 4
6
. "
'
6 " B
4 /
5 !
$ 6 "
!"#!$%
4
Var. (3.0; 4.0; 5.0; 6.0; 7.0; 8.0)
1L
variá
vel (
3.0;
3.5
; 4.0
)
H
HE
300
BH
E 3
00B
H
variá
vel (
3.0;
3.5
; 4.0
)va
riáve
l (3.
0; 3
.5; 4
.0)
H
HE
300
B
HE 300B
3
HE 300B
1
HE 300B
HE
300
B
H
variá
vel (
3.0;
3.5
; 4.0
)
Var. (3.0; 4.0; 5.0; 6.0; 7.0; 8.0)
L 2
HE
300
B
HE
300
BH
E 3
00B
HE
300
B
H
variá
vel (
3.0;
3.5
; 4.0
)
HE
300
B
variá
vel (
3.0;
3.5
; 4.0
)
HE
300
B
H
HE 300B
HE
300
B
HE
300
B
HE 300B
4
HE 300B
2
)$*!K9 4"
'4 - ! !
4 /
"( /
4. . !
.4 ! "
!
% D!>"="+ 6
6!
"
B 6 ! !
1P1;P 1 R" 3
61?;",4 6R
J,">"# .
!"
,5
P P
PP
PPPP
L
H
H
A B
C
E
H
G
L
H
H
A
D
P
C
B
P
D
F E
P
H
H G
F
P
H
PP PP
L L
H
H
A
P
C
P
E
H
G
H
B
H
A
P
D
P
C
B
P
D
P
F
P
E
H
H
G
P
F
H
)$*!,KF !"
!"#!$%
,
9 4$4
D!>">"3
* .
!
"
+
. $ 6
!@ 1P1;P1 R
4 1 ? ;", R J
,">" D . !
"
! &'() !
6
4"
).%! !
! "
+
! 4-% !
$! -"
#5%
!. /
!"
+ D! >"? . .
! ! "9
. !!
!.6"
3 ! D! >"<
. 4 $
!"' - 44
! "9
6
"
,
A
H
P
H
P
I
H
E
L
1
B
L
2
F
D C
A
1L
H
F
D
Z
PH
O P
P
GY
X
K
P
O
Z
P
J
P
L
X
Y
H
P
Z
PH
O
P
H
I
K
P
O
Z
E
A
LB
2
C
H
L1
B
D
F
P
GY
XP
H
P
P
L
X
Y
J
I
H
H
P
P P
PK
P
J
P X
Y
Z
O
E
D
L2
1L
A
E
HC
LB
2
F
C
K
HHP
G
P
HL
P
P
I
P
P
P
G
P
J
P
P
L
P
M
P PO
O
N
P
P
X
Y
Z
P
P
M
O
O
Z
M
P
N
P
P
X
Y
PO
P
Y
XO P
Z
O
P
P
P
M
PP
X
Y
P
N
O
P
Z
)$*!3KF ."
!"#!$%
,&
1
B
L
2
F
D C
Z
PH
O P
P
GY
X
K
P
O
Z
P
J
P
L
X
Y
P
M
P PO
O
N
P
P
X
Y
Z
P
P
M
H
A
H
E
H
I
P
M
N
B
D C
P
PO
F
PH
Z
K
O
PZ
X
Y
P
G
J
X
YL
P
H
A
D
B
H
E
P
H
I
P
H
F
P
P
K
O
J
P
PZ
P
Z
PO
O X
YP
P
P
PO
Z
O P
NM
HC
A
P
G
X
YL
P
H
E
P
H
P
I
D
B
C
P
H
F
P
K
P
P
J
P
G
P
L
Y
X
P
P
P
O
PZ
PO
Y
X
P
P
1L
2L
L1
2L
1L
L2
E
A
H
P
H
P
I
H
L
)$*!4KF ."
,(
#5
!
!"
! .
!
4 !.
"
&&0
9 % ! &'() 6 !
! "
B !
/!"'4
.. / D!>"="
'D!>";, !
"
)$*!5KL "
E -
/ % 4 !
! "S4 %
!"#!$%
,
4 !" E
! -
! ! "
9!>";>">">"J4
." 3 ! 4 %
. . 6
%"
2D - sem diagonais
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0
L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
3.0 m
3.5 m
4.0 m
6!78$%KT .K!"
2D - 1 diagonal
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0
L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
3.0 m
3.5 m
4.0 m
6!78$%KT .K;!"
,
2D - 2 diagonais
0
5
10
15
20
25
3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0
L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
3.0 m
3.5 m
4.0 m
6!78$%&KT .K!"
2D - 3 diagonais
0
5
10
15
20
25
3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0
L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
3.0 m
3.5 m
4.0 m
6!78$%(KT .K!"
T4 4
! !
" ' !
! ; !
. !
6 6 " ' 4
4
"
!"#!$%
,,
'-!
" E -
4 -
!
"T4 6 1PRPA>J.
6 1PJ! N
! " B $ 6
! 6 ! !
4 " 9
D!>";; ! !
4 % 4
!/$θPJ>Q"+
! θUJ>Q"
Fx
θ=45°<45°θ
=Fy
yF =Fx
xF <Fy
F >Fy x
Fx
θ>45°
y>F
xy<FF
L L L
H H H
)$*!K ! /18R"
+4 . !5
A 4 6 1 !
4 !
;! !"
! .1R
.
."9 &'() ! !
. !(+#,,,"+!/
*&'() 4$
!(+#,,,"
,3
V0 0W
)$*!KL !1PRP"
!"#!$%
,4
V0 0W
)$*!&KL ;!1PRP"
35
V0 0W
)$*!(KL !1PRP"
!"#!$%
3
V0 0W
)$*!KL !"
3
+ !
4
/
"E !
%$ - 4
4 D!>";J>";>"
4
4 ! 5
4 "
9 !
" +P,4
-
4!!$D!>";H"
0W
)$*!KL !+P,"
9 4 . 6
! -%
"
!"#!$%
3&
+ ! 4;Q
- . "9
4
!"
9 4
%
4!
"
! ! ."
3D - sem diagonais
0
1
2
3
4
5
3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0
L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
3.0 m
3.5 m
4.0 m
6!78$%KT .K!"
3D - 1 diagonal
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0
L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
3.0 m
3.5 m
4.0 m
6!78$%KT .K;!"
3(
3D - 2 diagonais
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0
L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
3.0 m
3.5 m
4.0 m
6!78$%,KT .K!"
3D - 3 diagonais
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0
L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
3.0 m
3.5 m
4.0 m
6!78$%3KT .K!"
B ! 4 ! .
- !
" # ! ; !
5
/"'!
% #≈ - RP",4
4 %1"
3
.4!"
!"#!$%
3
V0 0W
)$*!,KL ;!.1PRP"
3
V0 0W
)$*!3KL !.1PRP"
!"#!$%
3,
V0 0W
)$*!4KL !.1PRP"
33
3 4
/ X- XY θ% $"9
% . $"3 4
! ! 4
!!$"
+N!
-! !/4$"
3D - 1 diagonal
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0
L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
3.0 m
3.5 m
4.0 m
6!78$%4KT .K;!."
3D - 2 diagonais
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0
L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
3.0 m
3.5 m
4.0 m
6!78$%5KT .K!."
!"#!$%
34
3D - 3 diagonais
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0
L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
3.0 m
3.5 m
4.0 m
6!78$%KT .K!."
# . 4 4 - !
4
!N "B ..
. F >"< >";, >";; 4
6 !!>";,.
!>";;"+ .
5 "
+ 4/ 4
$4 ! "
Z!>"< ;! 4
.
. . ; !
"
+ . !
4 ! !"'!
4 6
! " B
RP "> J",
6 1P>",H", R1 4
!"
45
B - 4 !
! $4 .4
! 1 R" #
$ .
,; 6
!"
' !
E >" / 4 $4
"
1PJ"<λP>=J?<
1P>",λP>H<=?,,
1P>";λPJHJJH;<
1$ X- XY θ% X- XY θ% X- XY θ%
,<>>> ,>J>J ,?= ,<>>; ,>>,< ,?<J ;",,,, ,JJ>; ,HJ;
;,,,, ,J?;< ,=? ;,,,, ,J?>? ,=H, ,=H=J ,=< ,>>
; ,>H?? ,JH ,=>H ,>H>? ,> ,=> ,=, ,;HH; ,J=>
+ !&KL&'()!. RP">"
#6 >",$4 -
- X- . Q " E $ /
N $ Q 4
X-"
L=5.0m L=5.1m
1º PISO
2º PISO
3º PISO
)$*!5KL!.RP">"
!"#!$%
4
'D!>", $ E
>" 1P >", >";" ' !
4 / / $ !. 1P >";" 3
. "#1P>",
$ $ Q X-
.41P>";"'N
4 !"+$
4
$ "
4 !
"
D% 1R4
- 8 = ⋅ " E 8 < ⋅ !
$ ! $
$ "# 8 > ⋅ !.
! !%Q
"'4 4- !4
!44 - -
% "
+4 - /
!
! .."3
6 4
4 "
B!/ !
.444
"
4
(-&
(0%!$12 0!!
3 - ! %
4 6 9.
:,,J,,J"
+ . %
4 / %!Z(+B2Z39[&F3;
/"
D!/@
− # A
− Z! A
Z"9"#\#""R @
9@
">I'8
;">I'8
+ !(K9! "
− (!A
(!R @
9@
",I'8
;",I'8
+ !K(!KZ(+"
% /@
− ;">F\;">E
4F / E!"
' % 4 % /
% 4 ! 6 !
"+%;<<
4 ! ;> F\E
6%"
!"#!$%
4&
+ $ ! !
/4 - 44 "
D./ -
.%$,";> "
B .RB+ $4
!4 "3
% BP;,F#"
$ $ $& $( $
,,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;?,+ ;H,+
,+ ,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;J,+
& ,+ ,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;J,+
( ,,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;?,+ ;H,+
,+ ,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;J,+
J,+ ,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;J,+
, ,+ ,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;J,+
3 ,,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;?,+ ;H,+
4 ,,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;?,+ ;H,+
5 ,,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;?,+ ;H,+
+ !K(/ .RB+"
'E>"H / "+!
RB;?,+"
L
HE 180A
L1L1
HE 180A
2
P1
1LL 1
P2P2
HE 180A
L2L2
HE 180A
HE 180A
L4L4
HE 180A
HE 180A
L 2
P5
P9
P6P6
HE 180A
P10P10
1L
HE 180A
L3L3
HE 180A
P3 P4
HE 180A
P7P7 P8P8
)$*!K# "
4(
4
!/ ! ! 4
/"
' D! >";
4 / " + !
. D!>""
H
H
H
H
H
L 1 1L
L 2
2L
1L
)$*!9# "B4"
B ! ! 5
6 !." ' - %
.
! @
+ R 1A
'N $11RA
'N $111R"
!"#!$%
4
T 1R
' 6!!
1 R"3 6
1?;",4 6R
J,">"# .!
"
B ! 6!
(+#,,,
&'() ."!
% .
/! @!! 5"
'N $1 1R
' N $ 1 4
D!>""9
5 !"
HE 180A
L1
HE 180A
L4
P6
HE 180AHE 180A
L2 L3
P7 P8
P10
L4
L1
HE 180A
HE 180A
P10
P2
L2
HE 180A
L3
HE 180A
P8P7P6
HE 180A
P1
1L
P2
2L
P5
2L
P9
HE 180A
P3
L 1 L 1
P4
HE 180A
)$*!&9# "! $"
& $1 >
. 1 R 6 ! " Z
1. $
1;11J"
4
L3 - 5 PISOS L3 - 4 PISOS
)$*!(9# "T .1"
3 $ /@
!"
'N $11 1R
' 4N
$11D!>">"
L2, L3 - 4 PISOS L2, L3 - 3 PISOS
)$*!9# "T .11"
!"#!$%
4,
(0
3
4"
#
!/ - 4
6"
'E>"= 6
D! >"H 1;P1PJ", RP", % J
6;H"
'L 'D-#
(+#,,, &'() B (+#,,, &'() B
; >>"H= >J,"H ,"<;] ;>H"J ;J<H",J J">,]
>H?";, H,?"=> H"H=] ;>?;"< ;>"; ";J]
J,";< J,<"J= ;"==] ;?,"H= ;;?"== J"H<]
J =?"H? ?,"=> >"=?] <<"?J ,H"; H"H]
> ??"?> ?H,"> "H>] ,>H"=? H=";; H"J]
H =;", =H;"< H">] H,"?= ?><"<= H";<]
= HJ"H HH>"H H";,] =<?">= <=?"J H",]
+ !,#6 "
3 6 $
% -(+#,,,"#
5
! % % 4
% /%
$",,]"
'E>"= 4%
.
"
9 ; 4 6%
4$4 "
43
H
H
L1 L1
H
H
Pλ λ2P
Pλ
Pλ
λ2P
λ2P
L1
2Pλ λP
2Pλ λP
2Pλ λP
H
2PλλP
Pλ λ2P
Pλ2Pλ
2Pλ λP
Pλ2Pλλ2P 3Pλ
HE
220
A
HE
240
A
HE 180A HE 180A HE 180A
HE 180AHE 180AHE 180A
HE 180AHE 180AHE 180A
HE 180AHE 180AHE 180A
HE 180AHE 180AHE 180A
1 2
H
2P
2P
H
L1
H
λ
H
λ
L1 L1
λ3P λ2P
λ3P λ2P
λP
λP
2P
2P
H
λ
λ
λ3P λ2P
λ3P λ2P
λP
λP
HE
160
A
HE
140
A
HE
140
A
HE
160
AH
E 1
80A
HE
180
A
HE
180
A
HE
180
AH
E 1
80A
HE
200
A
HE
200
A
HE
180
AH
E 2
00A
HE
220
A
HE
220
A
HE
200
AH
E 2
00A
HE
220
A
HE
220
A
HE
200
A
HE 180A HE 180A HE 180A
HE 180A HE 180A HE 180A
HE 180A HE 180A HE 180A
HE 180A HE 180A HE 180A
HE 180A HE 180A HE 180A
HE
140
A
HE
140
A
HE
160
AH
E 1
80A
HE
180
AH
E 2
00A
HE
200
A
HE
220
AH
E 2
20A
HE
200
AH
E 1
80A
HE
140
A
HE
180
A
HE
180
AH
E 2
00A
HE
200
AH
E 2
20A
HE
220
A
HE
140
A
λ
HE
180
A
λ
λ
λ
HE
220
AH
E 2
00A
λ
HE
240
A
L1
H
HE
200
A
HE
200
A
L2L2
H
HE
200
A
HE
220
A
L2
HE
200
A
HE
200
A
H
λλλλλλ
H
HE
180
A
HE
180
A
HE
200
A
HE
200
A
H
λPHE 180A
Pλ
λPHE 180A
λP
HE
180
A
HE
180
A
λPHE 180A
λP
H
PHE 180A
P
HE
180
A
H
HE
180
A
HE
200
A
HE
180
A
H
HE
220
A
HE
200
A
H
Pλ 2PλHE 180A HE 180A
λP PλHE 180A HE 180A
HE
200
A
HE
200
A
λP λPHE 180A
H
λP λPHE 180A
HE
180
A
HE
180
A
λP 2PλHE 180A HE 180A
H
P 2PHE 180A HE 180A
HE
180
A
HE
180
A
λP λPHE 180A
P PHE 180A
H
HE 180AλPλP
H
HE
160
A
3
HE
160
A
2PλPλHE 180A HE 180A
H
HE
160
A
4
HE
140
A
HE 180AλPλP
HE
160
A
5
HE
160
A
H
L2
HE
220
A
λ
HE
200
AH
E 2
20A
Pλ2PHE 180A
PλPHE 180A
HE
180
A
Pλ2PHE 180A
P2PHE 180A
Pλ2PHE 180A
HE
140
A
!"#!$%
44
HE 180A
HE 180AλP
Pλ
λP
λP
HE 180A
HE 180A
HE 180APλ
Pλ
λP
λP
λP
λP
HE
140
AH
E 1
80A
HE
200
AH
E 2
20A
HE
220
A
HE
140
AH
E 1
80A
HE
200
AH
E 2
20A
HE
220
A
HE 180A
HE 180A
HE
200
AH
E 2
00A
λP
Pλ
HE
200
AH
E 2
00A
λP
λP
HE 180A
HE 180A
HE 180APλ
HE
180
AH
E 1
80A
HE
160
A
Pλ
λP
λP
HE
180
AH
E 1
80A
HE
160
A
λP
λP
L2 L2
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H6 7
)$*!K# "
('!$12 0:0;
3 ! (+#,,,&'()"
#%!!%-
;; ! .
2#'2#'?,"+ % !-%
4 ."
D/! D!>"=@
− 9;@9!A
− 9@9! 5 "
λ1P
Caso de carga 1
λPλP λP
λ λ
P
PP
λ
λPλ
λP
P
Caso de carga 2
λ2Pλ3P2Pλ
λ2Pλ1P λ2P
λ λPP
λP
λP
)$*!,K ! "
55
#
3D - sem diagonais
0,2
0,3
0,4
0,5
0,6
4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
INST3D - H=3.00INST3D - H=3.50INST3D - H=4.00SAP2K - H=3.00SAP2K - H=3.50SAP2K - H=4.00
6!78$%KT ."
# #
)$*!3KT ."
!"#!$%
5
#9;@!
3D - com diagonais (1P)
0,5
0,6
0,7
0,8
0,9
1,0
1,1
1,2
1,3
1,4
1,5
4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
INST3D - H=3.00INST3D - H=3.50INST3D - H=4.00SAP2K - H=3.00SAP2K - H=3.50SAP2K - H=4.00
6!78$%&KT .λ#"
# #
)$*!4KT .λ#"
5
#9@! 5
3D - com diagonais (1P, 2P, 3P)
0,3
0,4
0,5
0,6
0,7
0,8
0,9
4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0L (m)
P cr
ític
o ( x
10 3 )
INST3D - H=3.00INST3D - H=3.50INST3D - H=4.00SAP2K - H=3.00SAP2K - H=3.50SAP2K - H=4.00
6!78$%(KT .λ#λ#λ#"
# #
)$*!&5KT .λ#λ#λ#"
!"#!$%
5&
' .
$"'
$ 5-
4 1R "
3 (+# ,,, &'()
-" E ;,]
% (+#,,,&'()!!
"
E ! . 4 . 4
!4
4 "'! 4
.Q4 4
!- ."
(<"0! 0$ =0:&.%">!$12 0:0;/
! N $1 D!>";
6 1 R !"
5 PISOS 4 PISOS 3 PISOS
2 PISOS 1 PISOS 0 PISOS )$*!&K1KT ."
5(
H=3.0 m - sem diagonais
100150200250
300350
400450500550600
0 1 2 3 4 5
Laje L3 - nº de pisos
P cr
ític
o i
L=4.0 m
L=5.0 m
L=6.0 m
L=7.0 m
L=8.0 m
6!78$%K1KT .!KQ RP","
H=3.5 m - sem diagonais
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
0 1 2 3 4 5
Laje L3 - nº de pisos
P cr
ític
o
i L=4.0 m
L=5.0 m
L=6.0 m
L=7.0 m
L=8.0 m
6!78$%K1KT .!KQ RP">"
H=4.0 m - sem diagonais
100
150
200
250
300
350
0 1 2 3 4 5
Laje L3 - nº de pisos
P cr
ític
o
i L=4.0 m
L=5.0 m
L=6.0 m
L=7.0 m
L=8.0 m
6!78$%,K1KT .!KQ RPJ","
!"#!$%
5
H=3.0 m - sem diagonais
250
270
290
310
330
350
370
390
410
4 5 6 7 8
L (m)
P cr
ític
o
i
0 pisos
1 pisos
2 pisos
3 pisos
4 pisos
5 pisos
6!78$%3K1KT .!1RP","
H=3.5 m - sem diagonais
250
270
290
310
330
350
370
390
410
4 5 6 7 8
L (m)
P cr
ític
o
i
0 pisos
1 pisos
2 pisos
3 pisos
4 pisos
5 pisos
6!78$%4K1KT .!1RP">"
H=4.0 m - sem diagonais
200
220
240
260
280
300
320
340
4 5 6 7 8
L (m)
P cr
ític
o
i
0 pisos
1 pisos
2 pisos
3 pisos
4 pisos
5 pisos
6!78$%5K1KT .!1RPJ","
5
@
# #
)$*!&K1KT .!K> "
# #
)$*!&&K1KT .!KJ "
!"#!$%
5,
# #
)$*!&(K1KT .!K "
# #
)$*!&K1KT .!K "
53
# #
)$*!&K1KT .!K; "
# #
)$*!&,K1KT .!K, "
!"#!$%
54
! 4 N $ 1
"
T4 6N $1.
! -4 - 1
F>";>>";H>";="E
$14N
"
+ $ .
N " 9
.
$$ "+ 1
%%!%.
! D!>"?"
#%
)$*!&3K9 1 "
' . N $1
4 Q !"
5
3 % ! 4 4
-$1@"9 $1 -
.
MO"+ Q MO-
! 4
6"
). . 4 6 1 %
6!"9
1RF>";?>";<>","
9 . ! N
$14
4 !
!8"
Z 4
4 !> 1D!>">"
5 PISOS 4 PISOS 3 PISOS
2 PISOS 1 PISOS 0 PISOS
)$*!&4K1KT ."
!"#!$%
H=3.0 m - com diagonais
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
0 1 2 3 4 5
Laje L3 - nº de pisos
P cr
ític
o i
L=4.0 m
L=5.0 m
L=6.0 m
L=7.0 m
L=8.0 m
6!78$%K1KT .!KQ RP","
H=3.5 m - com diagonais
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
0 1 2 3 4 5
Laje L3 - nº de pisos
P cr
ític
o
i L=4.0 m
L=5.0 m
L=6.0 m
L=7.0 m
L=8.0 m
6!78$%K1KT .!KQ RP">"
H=4.0 m - com diagonais
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
550
0 1 2 3 4 5
Laje L3 - nº de pisos
P cr
ític
o
i L=4.0 m
L=5.0 m
L=6.0 m
L=7.0 m
L=8.0 m
6!78$%&K1KT .!KQ RPJ","
H=3.0 m - com diagonais
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
4 5 6 7 8
L (m)
P cr
ític
o
i0 pisos
1 pisos
2 pisos
3 pisos
4 pisos
5 pisos
6!78$%(K1KT .!1RP","
H=3.5 m - com diagonais
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
4 5 6 7 8
L (m)
P cr
ític
o
i
0 pisos
1 pisos
2 pisos
3 pisos
4 pisos
5 pisos
6!78$%K1KT .!1RP">"
H=4.0 m - com diagonais
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
550
4 5 6 7 8
L (m)
P cr
ític
o
i
0 pisos
1 pisos
2 pisos
3 pisos
4 pisos
5 pisos
6!78$%K1KT .!1RPJ","
!"#!$%
&
@
# #
)$*!(5K1KT .!K> "
# #
)$*!(K1KT .!KJ "
(
# #
)$*!(K1KT .!K "
# #
)$*!(&K1KT .!K "
!"#!$%
# #
)$*!((K1KT .!K; "
# #
)$*!(K1KT .!K, "
3!>";>">"4
!
4N $1"+ 1;QQ
! 6!4Q
.4%JQ>Q 1"
BD!>"=>"?>"<>"J,
44-J> 1. 4
$$
-"E- .
4 $1MO%4
!4 4
4 !%
MO"3. ! .
MO !%
-"
(&<"0! 0$ =0:0:&.%">!$12 0:0;/
4 PISOS 3 PISOS
1 PISOS 0 PISOS2 PISOS
5 PISOS
)$*!(K11KT ."
!"#!$%
,
' 5 6 $ 1 1" 9
. . 5 4
N
1"
# 1 11
!. 4
! 4
5 "
. !"
! . 1 1 4
4%!"
H=3.0 m - sem diagonais
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
0 1 2 3 4 5
Laje L2 e L3 - nº de pisos
P cr
ític
o i
L=4.0 m
L=5.0 m
L=6.0 m
L=7.0 m
L=8.0 m
6!78$%,K11KT .!KQ RP","
H=3.5 m - sem diagonais
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
0 1 2 3 4 5
Laje L2 e L3 - nº de pisos
P cr
ític
o
i L=4.0 m
L=5.0 m
L=6.0 m
L=7.0 m
L=8.0 m
6!78$%3K11KT .!KQ RP">"
3
H=4.0 m - sem diagonais
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
0 1 2 3 4 5
Laje L2 e L3 - nº de pisos
P cr
ític
o
i L=4.0 m
L=5.0 m
L=6.0 m
L=7.0 m
L=8.0 m
6!78$%4K11KT .!KQ RPJ","
H=3.0 m - sem diagonais
250
300
350
400
450
500
4 5 6 7 8
L (m)
P cr
ític
o
i
0 pisos
1 pisos
2 pisos
3 pisos
4 pisos
5 pisos
6!78$%&5K11KT .!1RP","
H=3.5 m - sem diagonais
250
300
350
400
450
500
4 5 6 7 8
L (m)
P cr
ític
o
i
0 pisos
1 pisos
2 pisos
3 pisos
4 pisos
5 pisos
6!78$%&K11KT .!1RP">"
!"#!$%
4
H=4.0 m - sem diagonais
200
220
240
260
280
300
320
340
360
380
4 5 6 7 8
L (m)
P cr
ític
o
i
0 pisos
1 pisos
2 pisos
3 pisos
4 pisos
5 pisos
6!78$%&K11KT .!1RPJ","
9 . 5 4
$1"+ N
F >"= >"? >"<. ! 1
6 QQ "T4 J>Q
! $ !
4 4
"S41Rλ"
+/. 5
1 4 "
+4/ 1 .
"
H=3.0 m - com diagonais
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
0 1 2 3 4 5
Laje L2 e L3 - nº de pisos
P cr
ític
o i
L=4.0 m
L=5.0 m
L=6.0 m
L=7.0 m
L=8.0 m
6!78$%&&K11KT .!KQ RP","
5
H=3.5 m - com diagonais
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
0 1 2 3 4 5
Laje L2 e L3 - nº de pisos
P cr
ític
o
i L=4.0 m
L=5.0 m
L=6.0 m
L=7.0 m
L=8.0 m
6!78$%&(K11KT .!KQ RP">"
H=4.0 m - com diagonais
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
550
0 1 2 3 4 5
Laje L2 e L3 - nº de pisos
P cr
ític
o
i L=4.0 m
L=5.0 m
L=6.0 m
L=7.0 m
L=8.0 m
6!78$%&K11KT .!KQ RPJ","
H=3.0 m - com diagonais
200250300350400450500
550600650700
4 5 6 7 8
L (m)
P cr
ític
o
i
0 pisos
1 pisos
2 pisos
3 pisos
4 pisos
5 pisos
6!78$%&K11KT .!1RP","
!"#!$%
H=3.5 m - com diagonais
200250300350400450500
550600650700
4 5 6 7 8
L (m)
P cr
ític
o
i
0 pisos
1 pisos
2 pisos
3 pisos
4 pisos
5 pisos
6!78$%&,K11KT .!1RP">"
H=4.0 m - com diagonais
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
550
4 5 6 7 8
L (m)
P cr
ític
o
i
0 pisos
1 pisos
2 pisos
3 pisos
4 pisos
5 pisos
6!78$%&3K11KT .!1RPJ","
9 K $1 K 4
..4
N $ 1 1"+
Q F>"H>"=>"?
! >Q "L%41R
6!"
+ 5
N 1 4 "
+ / 1
$ 4 .11"
#% .5
MO !D!>"J="
2 PISOS
#%
)$*!(,K9 11 "
' -
D! >"J? 1 RP1PJ
$D!>"J? D!>"J?"
B!MO\MO BMO
)$*!(3KL"
!"#!$%
&
# ! MO
MO " +
! 44
6 "
6! λPJ?;
!λP;J;"Z4
%;>] \$ 6
!"
B . . D! >"J?
4 !. "
9% !@
− + !
A
− / . % /
$ A
− 3 4
"'
-A
− 3 N $
A
− ( !
$$
!"+ !. .
4 -
A
− + ! 4 !
! M 6O$!
"
(
& 5
0%!$12 0!!
+4 D!>"J<.
% !. "
5.0
5.05.0 5.0 5.0
4.0
4.0
4.0
4.0
5.0
5.0
4.0
4.0
4.0
4.0
4.0
4.0
)$*!(4K# ;, "
!"#!$%
' . 1
R 5 %
"
5.0 5.0 5.05.0
5.0
5.0
5.0
5.0
HE
120
AH
E 1
20A
HE
120
AH
E 1
20A
HE
120
AH
E 1
20A
HE
120
AH
E 1
20A
HE
120
AH
E 1
20A
HE
120
A
HE
120
A
HE
120
AH
E 1
20A
HE
120
A
HE
120
A
HE 120AHE 120A
HE 120AHE 120A
HE 120AHE 120A
HE 120A HE 120A
HE 120AHE 120A
HE 120A HE 120A
HE 120AHE 120A
HE 120A HE 120A
P1 P2 P3
P4 P5 P6 P7 P8
P9 P10 P11 P12 P13
P14 P15 P16 P17 P18
P19 P20 P21
)$*!5K# ;, "
3 ! .RB+
BP,>F#"D!/!
!! $"
3 /Z(+
@
− # A
− (!#K",I'89K;",I'8A
− Z! #K">I'89
;">I'8"
$!//@
− ;">F\;">E
4F / E !" D %
"' %
4 / % 6
! " +% ;<<
4 ! ;> F \ E
6%"
+ ! 5 RB ;H,+
/E>"?"
$ $ $& $( $ $ $, $3 $4 $5
,+ ,+ ,+ ,+ ,,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;?,+ ;H,+ ;J,+
,,+ ?,+ ?,+ H,+ J,+ ,+ ,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;J,+
& ,+ ,+ ,+ ,+ ,,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;?,+ ;H,+ ;J,+
( ,,+ ,,+ ?,+ H,+ H,+ J,+ ,+ ,+ ,,+ ;H,+
>,,+ >,,+ J,,+ J,+ ,,+ ?,+ H,+ J,+ ,,+ ;H,+
J>,+ J,,+ J,+ ,+ ,,+ ?,+ H,+ J,+ ,,+ ;H,+
, ,+ ,,+ ,,+ ?,+ H,+ J,+ J,+ ,+ ,,+ ;H,+
3 ,+ ,+ ,+ ,+ ,,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;?,+ ;H,+ ;J,+
4 ,,+ ,,+ ,,+ ?,+ H,+ J,+ J,+ ,+ ,,+ ;H,+
5 >>,+ >,,+ J>,+ H,+ ,+ ,,+ H,+ J,+ ,+ ;H,+
>>,+ >,,+ >,,+ J,,+ ,+ ,,+ H,+ J,+ ,+ ;H,+
>,,+ >,,+ H,+ ,+ ,,+ ?,+ J,+ ,+ ,,+ ;H,+
& ,,+ ?,+ ?,+ H,+ J,+ J,+ ,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;J,+
( ,,+ ,,+ ?,+ H,+ H,+ J,+ ,+ ,+ ,,+ ;H,+
>,,+ >,,+ J,,+ J,+ ,,+ ?,+ H,+ J,+ ,,+ ;H,+
J>,+ J,,+ J,+ ,+ ,,+ ?,+ H,+ J,+ ,,+ ;H,+
, ,+ ,,+ ,,+ ?,+ H,+ J,+ J,+ ,+ ,,+ ;H,+
3 ,+ ,+ ,+ ,+ ,,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;?,+ ;H,+ ;J,+
4 ,+ ,+ ,+ ,+ ,,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;?,+ ;H,+ ;J,+
5 ,,+ ?,+ ?,+ H,+ J,+ ,+ ,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;J,+
,+ ,+ ,+ ,+ ,,+ ,,+ ;?,+ ;?,+ ;H,+ ;J,+
+ !3K(/ K#RB+"
# ! 4 %
! 5 !
D!>">;"
!"#!$%
,
3P
P
λ
λP λ2P Pλ
4Pλ2P
λ2P
λ
λ4P
λ2P
λ
2P
4Pλ
λ
λ4P
λP
λ2P
2P
λ4P
λ
3Pλ
λP
λ2P Pλ
)$*!K !"
9$ 4
% ! 4 !
- "
P12P11
HE 120A
HE
120
A
HE
120
A
P8
HE 120A
HE
120
A
P13
HE 120A
HE
120
A
HE 120A
HE 120A
P14
HE
120
A
P19
P15
HE 120A
HE
120
A
P17P16
HE 120A
HE
120
A
P20
HE 120A
P21
P18
HE 120A
PÓRTICO CONTRAVENTADO
PÓRTICO CONTRAVENTADO
PÓ
RTI
CO
CO
NTR
AV
EN
TAD
O
HE 120A
P1
HE
120
A
P2
HE 120A
HE
120
A
P3
HE
120
A
HE 120A
HE 120A
P4
HE
120
A
P9
HE
120
A
P5
HE 120A
HE
120
A
P7P6
HE 120A
HE
120
A
HE
120
A
P10
HE 120A
HE
120
A
)$*!K#"
3 D! >">
% ! "
3
0
& 6
"
)$*!&K"
' 6
λP ?;JH" +
6λP;;<><"
3D!>">4
. !
-" + !
4%%Q
Q "
9 .
4 4
"9
4 !
$ "
!"#!$%
4
PÓ
RTI
CO
CO
NTR
AV
EN
TAD
O
HE 120AHE 120AHE 120AHE 120A
PÓRTICO CONTRAVENTADO
P10
HE
120
A
P5
HE
120
A
P2
HE
120
A
P1
HE 120A
P9
HE
120
A
P4
HE 120A
HE
120
A
P3
HE 120A
P11
HE
120
A
HE 120A
P6
HE 120A
P13
HE
120
A
HE 120A
P8
P12
HE
120
A
P7
PÓRTICO CONTRAVENTADO
P20
HE
120
A
P15
HE
120
A
HE
120
A
P14
HE 120A
HE
120
A
P19
HE 120A
HE
120
A
HE 120A
P16
HE 120A
HE
120
A
HE 120A
P18P17
HE
120
A
HE
120
A
P21
HE 120A
)$*!(K7 "
+% 4
$
!!%/ D!>">J"
;7 7
)$*!KL"
&5
L 6
" 9
! λP ;><>J 4 ;7
λP ;;<><" '4 . %
?;JH"
B- D! >">> 4
- 4
#<#;"
& #<#;D!>">H4N
/! !
% "
#<#;
)$*!KL7 "
#5 !
;,Q .>Q "
B N 4 6
λP;>?,> !"
!"#!$%
&
!+ J !+
!# J !#
)$*!,KL ! "
E ! J N
6λP;>;>>!4>
λP;>H"B
" E ! N
-
!JN D!>">="Z
> N - -
/$ 4!"
&
)$*!3KL !> "
' D! >">? >
! 4
! "
):
9 !@
3 . A
+ !!
A
3 4
A
!"#!$%
&&
3 4 -!
/8/$A
9
4
4A
+
% ! !
!@
;"
A
" &% !
4 % !/
A
" &% .
4
A
J" 3
4
!MO%"
# % 4 /
!
! - $ ! !" (
4 .
/ -% "
!
" # ! $
%
& '#
'
#' !
( &) ( * +
,-%
)##''./0*1
!#
'#
'%
&#''
#
#%
2 3
'$%4
5
67 ) (8
9
'
% :
(
&)
#%/##;
;
'%2
; #
'
#%
4 # '
%& #
'<=$"
'##
%1'
#> >
'
67 ( &
46(&)7
%&$
#%
4./0*1##
?1?1 #*
%
1 6(&)./0*17
./0*1#@A!
?1 *1
%
9 ?1 *1 $
## '%
4 $
$
!"#$"$$"$ %%&'$ "("
)
' % 9
#
# !
%
6#7
>
%8#
5
− / '
' #'
$'%2
">
%
− ## #
# % + ' <=
>
###
#
#'%-'
'#
#
##!%4
'
' >'
#?%
− 4>
>>
%/##
%
− :
%
- # ;
*
##
' % -
#!%
67 2#
9 #
; % 1
# $
%
9 #
>
$
%
- ' #
$
#
#>
# %&
#;#
%
##
$
%
9 #
63BC7$$#%
4'#
#'#"%
6#7 D -
)#'?1*1
%)!
# >
#
!"#$"$$"$ %%&'$ "("
+
;%
9 #>
#
$%
& " #
%9
$ $ #
67% 2
%
8# # ;>>
#
##!%
$ >%
#
'
%
-
# ## # '
%E'./0*1
' ##
## %
./0*1
'%
*1 '
%0
'
%
''
#
,-
% - ' $ #
$
"%
2
' ##
' >$#%
! "#$% &$' !()*( $% +'*$% ! % ", ,"'
--./0.123$"$" ,4'
5 / ! "#$ % & ' (!) "*# 6%$
'7%*%7% !8%(
5'+!,-%5*( $%#,"49
:;<&0 / . -
$ / 0% *# '. 0 $,"' $ ",( ,"'
4*!!"*4 &$' /. $ / -- =0=> 8!"*( $(*! 7 $ *3*'
4*!!"%9
:;<&0 0 /%1. "# -
%%$23$$,"'$4*!!"*4!(?*(%&$'
/@$>-->/0>1 8!"*($(*! 7$ *3*'4*!!"%9
;& /== " %%
% .% :!%! ! !% "$ (,'! !
4!?"*9*3!"%*!$$" $$" $$" ,4'
/=@ /%1.$ ' 4 "%5%/
0%?*%%!" *$* *3*'4*!!"*4:?!9*3!"%* 7$A"$?*$
9
/=@> /%1.$'4"%5%
/ 0% % # 5 * ! #7
:7'$" 6! * $ 8B*( -- 1/=01/ *!"*4! "!%%
6%!9C
/=@@ 43 03. # % 0 #
$8-, !"% D ",( ,"!% &$' $ -- >=.0.1 *3*'0 $8-
!"48$"!%%E"! "* *
/===0455%% $B, $!
"#'?$% *8-"!%%$% ! 8,%("* $% ! -$*$ $ !% "$ !8 % ", ,"% ! 4F
*3*' !(GH$ ! % ", ,"% !-" 8! $ ! 4!?"* *3*' 9 $" $
$" ,4'
:C/==> 6 %"! *(!0''4'!6$$ '*%!6
!"%!79
: C I /=.> %# 6 $
"! *(!0''4'!6$$ '*%!6!"%!79
;:; /==/5$%%& 6%
-."#J$"9*3!"%* 7"!%%!65$"A9
9:/=.K/%1./ #(E"60
*''C$4A,%?
/==%78-.%% 9!98'%'%
/%.,"$-! $88* !!$ "*L *$
2 -4#.4
3 5 :; 3 1M $4"!%%$ ! $% ",GH$
! N'*( ! *% :!8 1 N'*%! ! &!"**(GH$ !4,"G -->.0.@
*%#$$" ,4'
2 %%<:4."7-4
5 4 .% 5 :; 3
!-" 8! $!4!?"* *3*' (,'!!4!?"*9*3!"%*!$
$" $9$" $$" ,4'
!
2 1 04
" * O"$(!!*4% $ ?!
$!"!(!P $$% $8-, (*$*%!84!?"*Q: *%#$$" ,4'
2 1 0 0$.04$ $
"# - / 6 * O"$(!!*4% $ :?! !3! ?
!" *$' $!"!(!$ $8-, *$' ",( ,"!%:!(?$'$47Q-!"/1K--
K0> *3*'0 $8-"!%%*%#$$" ,4'
E/=.1 4%%5$"#$"! *(!0''4'!6$$
'*%9
/== % # ..4 "(!'
!(A!"(!65$"A9 ?!I %, :/=.>"#$/
0%8 /#3-.&$'/(E"60*''!65$"A9
I 9/=@@%%5$ "#$4'%!3*!"
(!65$"A9
I 9/==/5$-.6 "!%%'$"*
9
I 9E0 CC/==. '6--.%.3$
"!%%'$"*9
I 9E0 CC059 /
$ "# - 6 !!' ",( ,"!% / -- /0
C$"!
I /==K -. $
6-"*4!"0&!"'4!65$"A9
9E;/==-$%% (E"60*''
: 9:CEC/=@@%%$&$% "
!*?$'"!* *$
/=.>%"#5$%% $''*R # ",(*!4!
/==/%7-.% %% /%.
3*%$"7 $88* !!
C E & 9E9 C /=@= 5$
6%"# -/ 0%$,"'$ ",( ,"'4*!!"*4
&$'//K$/=@=--1>.01.=
EE/=>%%%5$"#$(E"60*''
EE/=>@/%1./%$6$,"'$ ?!
",( ,"'*3*%*$ &$'=1:/
E:5 ?!I /=@. $6-.$,"'$
",( ,"'4*!!"*4 &$'//:.--/K/0/K/=
IE C/=>@5$$6*15$=
#$,"'$ ?! ",( ,"'*3*%*$ &$'=1:.
:I /=>K"#5$6!"48$"!%%!6
5$"A9
95 C /=.K "#$ 5$ $$"?$ !" *$'
,#'*%?!"%!*!:?!! ?!"'%
/=> 5$65$.$#$,"'$ ?!
4*!!"*4!(?*(%*3*%*$&$'@>1
C5 : : /=.= -. %% 5$ E"
,#'*%?*4
"
C</===%%5$..D-$$$
9C
C9I :9/-34."# -/
-$!-" 8! $ *3*'4*!!"*4 *$' ?!40
C,49*3!"%* 7:*:*6
CIC1#%%4>5*O"$(!!*4%$:?!
!3! ? !" *$' $!"!(!$ $8-, *$' ",( ,"!%:!(?$'$47Q-!"
/>--1@01@1 *3*'0 $8-"!%%9C
; /=. 5$ "#$8 % # 5$ -$
$$'./(!8*("!%%!65$"A9
&5 C /=K> 5$ 6% %%
6*1(?!% !"9*3!"%* 7"!%%(?!% !"9C
91*%6"#.$4448?"#$%9
"#$%@ A%B A979C
91*%6"#.$444&A%
A979C
C/=. =# $ -.5$04%8
%%, !"6$" ?%$$9C
E9I EE;=%%$
$?I*'!7D$%(
C/=./=%%$(E"60*''!65$"A9
:I /=KK0"/%.6% ",( ,"'4*!!"-
@K
#
C&S /=== $ 4 / %% (
9*3!"%* *% !"*!%"(?* !( ,"! *3*'4*!!"*4&$'M/--K0>
"!%! ! ?!K ?59*T$'*!"(*!(! :?!:?"!%?$'$:?!
:?*"*''!*,8(,' 7$!(?*('4*!!"*49*3!"%* 7$*T59
/=@=-.-5$ "#-.C51
",( ,"'4*!!"*4!"*!%&$% "!*?$'!65$"A9
5 /=@ / / 0%8 5$ .# --'*!
(*!(!,#'*%?!"%9C
5/=@=%%0&5$.#'%!3*!"!6
5$"A9
; C/=>@"#$=%%$(E"60*''!6
5$"A9
;;U;/=@5$256$,"'$ ?!
",( ,"'*3*%*$ &$'/>:./@=0/1
/=@K '.% %% : 4 D **% P"*$ $
R,*-8! $$(*' $%!'?$,-!"*$"!#"%V#'*(%!:"%-$" !%*%#$
$" ,4'
:/5%%(E"60*''$" ,4'
9: /=>K /%. $,"' $ ?! ",( ,"'
*3*%*$ &$'=/:/
/===6$8"#$44>#"! *(!
''!6!"%!79
&@,,, .%%$E-.*&$
'% $8-, !" ",( ,"!%(!"A!'!7 '*$"*9
$
# & @,,, & -$ $
-. "# - %% & / $ '
$8-, !" ",( ,"!%(!"A!'!7 '*$"*9
( & @,,, & -$ $
-. "# -%%&%$"% $8-, !"
",( ,"!%(!"A!'!7 '*$"*9
;; / 04 - $ 6 2.
0 %% $ . 0% 0 -.
4( ?!%*%(,' 7$ ?!&*"4**$'7 !(?*(% * , ! !
9*3!"%* 7'(A%#,"4&*"4**9
9E0 C C 0 059 / - -. "#
- 6 2. 3 $ 4*!!"*4 ",( ,"!%
--/1=/0/K'%!3*!"(*!(!
9E0 C C0 059 / 3$
-. "# - "%/. $,"' $ $% ",( *$' !!'
!%!"(?K.--=.0='%!3*!"(*!(!
9E0 C C 059 /# 3 $ '.
4 6 !" *$' $,"' $ $'*% ",( ,"!% @ -- =///0=//
'%!3*!"(*!(!
9E0 CC59CC 059 /( $ 7 -
6:?*0I ''! ",( ,"!%=--11K01>/'%!3*!"(*!(!
::/=@@%%$-."/%.(E"60*''
*4-,"!
:C E/=>/ "#$ 5$
(E"60*''!65$"A9
%
: I/==2.
68F, W0 ! "$!% V*$%7J-!"*8! (*+!
#"%V#'*(%"*%-X
&E9/[email protected] ?'#,
I&I /=>.04%.%%$&$% " $
(
I"#--$$%%8
4#$44#>#4##G%1.. $8-, !"
",( ,"!%( '*+"*9
W90/%1. '.6!-" 8! $ *3*'
4*!!"*49*3!"%* 7$I !"'$$ "*$
5E0550EC/==1"#$$%%
" *(!''
;CC5%%$/%.D-$$$9C
;CI ; :5/=@="#6# A!9&/
6%5 6%#(E"60*''$$9C
!"##$
%&'
%&(
%(( (
)$$$
)
)
$$)"
"#$)"
()
"#$ )*
()"$
$$
'(
("
(
)+(
&
,$$ )
&)
-$$)
)%"
-$$)"
'(
)
)*
($"&-$$
) $%+ $
)
)
(././
!$$')"
)'
') *'
')* '
)'
') *'
!$$ ')* '
(
) *
)*
)
'./&
0$$')"
')'
')'
0$$
-$$
'(
(+,$$
